SOLUTION... Ok FINALLY figured this out... I am posting my solution here since I have not seen it successfully posted anywhere else in my 2 days of trying to figure this thing out. Quite surprisingly it has a very simple solution. Initially I was trying to set the form submission using jquerys document ready routine. This won't work, the reason is jquery only binds document ready to the dom on the initial page load. Since I am using a load call to load the form it only exists after that has been called. I tried to use the livequery plugin to rebind it but the documentation is sparse for how to use that, so I just gave up, plus I think it can only bind to events that "bubble" and document ready doesn't bubble. Anyway so I tried to figure out if there was anything that would handle the form besides document ready and ended up changing document ready to jQuery(document).click(function() { and that seemed to work! Then since this form can be called from multiple areas on the page, I initially thought I would have to setup a unique target id. I couldn't ever figure out how to pass the target id into the script so the document.click could read it. Then it hit me, I don't need to pass the target id at all. When I load the ajax form I just surround it in a div class called commentadd. Now a user is probably only going to use one form at a time so this works. Anyway below is what I did in code and I hope it helps someone. I am quite surprised there isn't a tutorial somewhere on this since I saw quite a few people asking but no one posted any solutions. Ayway hope this helps someone. I know it may be simple to a lot of experts out there but I am rather dense when it comes to javascript and jquery.
P.S. for the beginners: on the INITIAL LINK below. the 0 in parenthesis is the id of the comment you want to add. I tried to simplify the stuff as much as possible from my original scripts so it would make sense. Also jQuery I used is the same as the $ you see in many scripts. ---JAVASCRIPT--- //submit the form and return results of form submission to target class div jQuery(document).click(function() { var options = { target: '.commentadd', // target element(s) to be updated with server response }; // bind to the form's submit event jQuery('#frmaddcomment').submit(function() { // inside event callbacks 'this' is the DOM element so we first // wrap it in a jQuery object and then invoke ajaxSubmit jQuery(this).ajaxSubmit(options); // !!! Important !!! // always return false to prevent standard browser submit and page navigation return false; }); }) //add a comment function add_comment(CommentId) { new jQuery('#addcomment'+CommentId).hide().load('/comments/ add_comment/'+CommentId, {}, function() { jQuery(this).slideDown('fast'); } ); ---HTML--- <div class="commentadd" id="addcomment0"> <img src="/images/comments.png" class="icon"><h1>Add Comments:</h1> <form action="http://localhost/index.php/comments/add_comment" method="post" id="frmaddcomment0"> <input type="hidden" name="CommentId" value="0" /> <p><label for="title">Title:</label><br /> <input type="text" name="title" value="" maxlength="255" size="43" id="title" class="textfield" /> <p><label for="title">Comments:</label><br /> <textarea name="description" cols="41" rows="10" id="description" class="textfield" ></textarea> <input type="submit" name="submit" value="Submit Comments" id="submit_comments" /> </form> </div> ---INITIAL LINK--- <a href="javascript:add_comment(0)">Add New Comment</a>