I apologize for taking so long to reply.  Petitioning is wrapping up in 
NY and we're all busy.  Because I am in a hurry, I intend to commit the 
cardinal sin of not reading the whole thread before replying.

>> The kind 
>> of total knowledge you are proposing is difficult to obtain.
>>     
>
> In your previous posts you have repeatedly stated (without evidence)
> that "total knowledge" of all market participants is necessary when no
> Government is present. Now you are implying (falsely) that I am
> "proposing" the same. 
>   

That's a fair criticism.  I have assumed that because, in a global 
economy, businesses could be committing aggressive acts all over the 
globe.  How can I, as a consumer, know what every multinational 
corporation is doing everywhere it does business?  If I don't know, how 
can I intelligently boycott the bad ones?  I don't see how what you're 
saying, that no one will do business with the bad guys, is workable 
without that kind of global information reach.

>> I'd 
>> much rather have distributed, municipal courts handle such matters
>> case by case, being constrained by law against allowing hearsay and    
>> other improprieties.
>>     
>
> Easily-corruptible artificial authorities CAUSE the negative effects
> on the market that you fear the most.
>   

I'm talking about punishing people for violating the natural rights of 
others.  Government policies which attempt to control the economy are 
another matter.  You're right, such policies do make things worse and 
not better.  However, I don't include protection against theft, murder, 
arson, etc. under "market regulation".  They are moral crimes whether 
commerce is involved or not.

> We have already discussed how market forces keep business owners in
> check, but we have not yet talked about what would MOTIVATE a business
> owner to WANT to initiate violence in the first place. 
>
> Will businesses violate Individual Liberty simply because there is no
> threat of State violence? 
>
> ---Sasan

If a company destroys its competitor(s), they get all the business, and 
make more money.  The desire for wealth is all the motivation human 
beings require.  In fact, money and property probably provide the most 
causes for dispute.

Chris



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Reply via email to