--- In LibertarianEnterprise@yahoogroups.com, "Gary F. York" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > Zack Bass wrote: > > To clarify your position, consider the following: > > > > One day Jane says, "I'm tired of this, let's do something else," and > > Kevin says, "No, this is what I'm into today, keep it up," and Jane > > says "I refuse! I hereby abrogate this Contract! Sue me!" > > > > And then either: > > (1) Kevin gets out the manacles and holds Jane steady in position for > > his activities until it's time to go watch the new episode of House, > > OR > > (2) Kevin threatens, "I will kill you if you don't keep your end of > > the bargain," and Jane says, "I'm outa here," and Kevin cuts out her > > heart in accordance with the Non-Performance Clause that Jane agreed to. > > > > Now, as I understand it, your position is that (1) is an Initiation Of > > Force, but (2) is not an Initiation Of Force (since you did say, "Cut > > away"). > > > > NOW have I got that right? > > > I suspect you already know that you have not "got that right." >
No, I honestly thought that you had agreed that #2 was not Initiation Of Force. > > As I would have it, both your scenarios are an initiation of force. The > first is obvious; the second by invalid contract. > I misunderstood. So now you are saying that a Contract to sell one's organs to the Organ Banks, thereby assuming room temperature, is "Invalid"?
