Dag Brattli <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
> "Bj�rn Mork" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
>
> > Ahh, good news ;-) I have excactly the same problem with my 8810. So
> > then maybe it isn't the phone anyway? These are my experiences with
> > the 8810 and the most recent Linux-IrCOMM:
>
> I don't think there are any relationship here. The Ericsson impl. is quite
> different from the Nokia one. Notice that we have only one Ericsson user
> which has problems, and he is not sure if he has subscription for data
> connections or not. No carrier is the correct response if you don't
> subscribe to data connections.
Oh, well. My mistake.
> The IrDA impl. of the Nokia 8810 is very insane, and the log you provided
> me from a successful connection between Linux and the 8810 is not a
> "correct" IrCOMM session. It is therefore very difficult for me to make
> Linux-IrCOMM work for this phone. Well, I must admit that I haven't traced
> the problem fully, but the reason is partly that I received some of your
> logs so many days after the first ones, that I got out of the IrCOMM
> debugging mode ;-)
Ummm, sorry about that...
> I still have the logs, so I might try again when I get
> into IrCOMM debugging mode again ;-)
The irdadump log from a successful (as always) Psion Series5 <-> Nokia
8810 connection could maybe help shift your mode? :-)
As you know, I don't understand much of what's going on. But I noted
one major difference: The Psion sends complete commands like ATD123456
in a single package while Linux-IrDA splits it and sends A,T,D,1,2,3,4,
5,6 in separate packages. As you can see from the timings, this not an
interactive session but from a chatscript. The commands are still split
up in single character packages, even if it completes in just a few ms.
This made me think: Maybe it's just a problem with package assembly in
the 8810? If so, is there any way to make Linux-IrDA behave like the
Psion does? I have no problem believing that this is caused by a bug in
the phone, but other IrDA-stacks are obviously able to avoid it...
(he said, pushing for IrCOMM mode :-)
You can find the Psion<->8810 and Linux<->8810 dumps at
http://www.mork.no/~bjorn/s5-8810.txt
http://www.mork.no/~bjorn/linux-8810.txt
The Linux<->8810 dump is the same that I sent you previously (from
kernel-2.2.12 with the 2.2.12-irda3-patch).
Bj�rn
_______________________________________________
Linux-IrDA mailing list - [EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www4.pasta.cs.UiT.No/mailman/listinfo/linux-irda
