Anton,
A
I think the work you do is marvelous and a great teaching tool.A Too
much music in this world and not enough time to assimilate it all.A
With your intabulations it allows players of different levels to play
together.
A
BTW, have you ever thought of doing intabulations of medieval music.A
I have done some on occasion for the purpose of playing with other lute
players.A They can be quite challenging as well.
A
please continue to upate us.
A
Bruno
Montreal Canada
[1]www.estavel.org
A
On Tue, Jul 24, 2012 at 10:23 AM, Taco Walstra
<[2]wals...@science.uva.nl> wrote:
On 07/23/2012 05:04 PM, Anton HAP:ger wrote:
Ok,
I wrote that IMSLP always check the uploads and need A at least one
day. Because I often make a transcription for guitar too, it seems
that IMSLP cannot handle with the same file name.
But sorry if you feel that my more hundreds of Intavolations for 2-4
lutes in any tunings are to much,
anton, I didn't write that I don't like your intavolations or guitar
arrangements. Please don't be so quickly offended by what I wrote
and please do continue your work. I only asked what the purpose is
of sending emails for every addition or minor change to a piece,
while there are so many better alternatives for getting the
attention of your efforts like a webpage with a "latest additions
page", a rss xml feed, twitter or simply a separate mailing list.
It's just an idea, not a critic on what you do.
Taco
I will not upload any more Intavolations. My work was thought for
the luteplayers in any level. Not everybody can play the English
Treble Ground duets or the very complicated Terzi duos or some else.
If I look at mediafire, where I first uploaded my Intavolations,
there are more than 15000 downloads! So I dont understand your
opinion about solo lute players. May be,- but thats one of my
reasons I do the Intavolations!
I was 10 years teacher for classical guitar and later 15 years for
the Renaissance lute. And my experience with all the hundreds of
pupils was that they could benefit a lot of ensemble playing.
Rhythme, Hearing, Playing prima vista, and a lot more. But a crucial
effect is the sound effect of more lutes in an ensemble. Because of
the less technical demand the lute players in an Ensemble has an
overwelming soundeffect. But I dont want to defend my work. So if
you feel so, I dont will upload any more Intavolations.
I think my announcements are not too much, when I have a look at
some gibberish you can find here. (More than one has complained
this!)
But ok, why should I make any uploads more?
So all lute players who has downloaded my work, will give thanks to
you!
Anton
To get on or off this list see list information at
[3]http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
--
--
A
Bruno Cognyl-Fournier
A
[4]www.estavel.org
A
--
References
1. http://www.estavel.org/
2. mailto:wals...@science.uva.nl
3. http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
4. http://www.estavel.org/
