On Mon, Sep 15, 2003 at 11:06:45AM +0200, Jean-Marc Lasgouttes wrote:
> Andre> This would work in this case but not differ much from what we
> Andre> have. Moreover, I cannot imagine how to make this work with
> 
> [appendix example]
>  
> Andre> How would you do that?
> 
> What about
> 
>    Counter
>      Name                 section
>      String               "\arabic{section}"
>      AppendixString       "\Alph{section}"
>    End                   
>                         
>    Style Section         
>      LabelStyle           Counter
>      LabelCounter         section
>      LabelString          "$$String(section)"
>    End

Would work, but I _really_ don't see the benefit compared to the current
working solution

    Counter
      Name                 section
    End                   
                         
    Style Section         
      LabelStyle           Counter
      LabelCounter         section
      LabelString          "\arabic{section}"
      LabelStringAppendix  "\Alph{section}"
    End

that would pay for the work to implement it. Most notably, your solution
is one line, two words and 43 chars longer than what we already have and
uses one more element of cryptic syntax.
 
> Andre> [And why are we looking for a replacement for an existing and
> Andre> working scheme anyway?]
>  
> When we are changing a syntax people are going to use (and that we
> will have to support for sometime) we might as well get it right.

Sure. 

> BTW, it will be necessary to document this stuff too.

I was thinking about a small 'LyX Layouts HOWTO'...

Andre'

-- 
Those who desire to give up Freedom in order to gain Security, will not have,
nor do they deserve, either one.     (T. Jefferson or B. Franklin or both...)

Reply via email to