>> BTW can you use it as a normal HD? If so, then it's a useful device.
> 
> From what I've read, yes.  In fact, the same HD mechanism is used in a
> third-party portable firewire hard drive product (whose name I've
> forgotten) that sells for, get this, $399 US.  So the iPod is the same
> price, and it plays music too!  (and I'm sure is much more stylish)
>
> So folks are saying this thing is 'only an MP3 player' and then comparing
> it to some thing with a 64M flash card in it (holding 9 songs vs. 1000), or
> some 6G thing with USB connectivity that weighs 3 times as much--how long
> do you think it will take to load your 5G of songs at 12M/sec vs. 400?  are
> you really going to carry something that weighs a pound around?  not to
> mention that this Nomad thing has a famously inelegant interface.


Yes you can use it as a hard drive if it is hooked up to a firewire mac
only. Windows compatibility is possible in the futur but only if for some
strange reason there is enough demand. Windows users will probably opt for
the more functional Nomad instead (which can also be used as a
CROSS-PLATFORM storage device) since it allows analog recording, 4.1 and
more audio formats support not too mention 20GB of storage space.

The worst thing about the Nomad is it's USB connection. The size and weight
are not the worst things in the world. The discman format has already been
largely accepted size-wise (how many discman has Sony sold to date?) and at
14 ounces it can hardly be considered something to 'lug around'. Not that
I'd want to JOG with any hardrive based solution, but both products do
feature like 5 minutes of shock protection.

As for moving 5GB of data through a USB pipe that COULD be a pain if speed
is an issue (which it rarely ever is for consumer markets), however who
moves around 5GB of MP3's at a time? Especially when you 20GB to work with
instead, that way you just add the new songs you downloaded to your device
as opposed to replacing them. And that's another thing... what if I don't
want ALL of my songs in the iPod? Apparently it SYNCHS with itunes... not a
question of picking and choosing the songs to add, besides my 15GB MP3
collection is too big to synch with an iPod. Anyways, even if I DID want to
move over 5GB of data at a time, I think the USB speed is an acceptable
tradeoff for its other advantages. USB Win compatibility has its advantages
in numbers too... what good is a high speed connection if I can't copy my PC
buddy's MP3 collection (or other files) onto my player, or give him my
songs?

Don't get me wrong, Apple had the right idea coming out with the design that
they did it's as different as the rest of their products, I just hope that
future products are not dependant on iPod's success cause I have a feeling
it will be another cube, nice but not worth the cost. I read somewhere that
the unit was overpriced to meet demand at first and that it may drop by as
much as $100 USD before Christmas, big maybe on Win compatibility
post-christmas.

The iPod is an MP3 player that must be sold like other mac products - form
is more important than function. Keep telling yourself this over an over
again if you're going to buy one. It's small, fast, easy to use... and
recharges off the firewire bus in an hour. If your mom or dad wants an MP3
player this is the one. If there's the slightest bit of geek in your blood
you will pooh-pooh it.

I would have liked to see the fireplayer idea that was floating around (same
idea but could display QT-compatible video files or iTunes visuals during
MP3 playback). THAT would be revolutionary, unfortunately the video
component would probably put it into the laptop price range. Or how about
licensing the RioVolt design and making it mac-like? Since most macs come
with CD-burners it would have made sense and offered a cheap solution
(RioVolt MP3/CD discman MSRP $225).

All in all it will remain a matter of opinion.

Dylan Walters


-- 
Mac Canada is sponsored by <http://lowendmac.com/> and...

Shop Canadian, visit Mantek Services          <http://www.mantek.mb.ca>
       Low Prices That Will Keep YOU and Your MAC Smiling

      Support Low End Mac <http://lowendmac.com/lists/support.html>

Mac Canada info:        <http://lowendmac.com/lists/mac-can.shtml>
Send list messages to:  <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To unsubscribe, email:  <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For digest mode, email: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subscription questions: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Archive: <http://www.mail-archive.com/mac-canada%40mail.maclaunch.com/>

Using a Mac? Free email & more at Applelinks! http://www.applelinks.com

Reply via email to