Op zaterdag 26 maart 2011 13:19:10 schreef Michael scherer: > On Fri, Mar 25, 2011 at 09:33:04AM +0100, Tux99 wrote: > > Quote: andr55 wrote on Fri, 25 March 2011 01:29 > > > > > My though was essentially that firmware is so close to hardware that > > > its > > > actual free/non-free status shouldn't apply - we should treat it like > > > (almost) part of the hardware. > > > > I agree with that. After all nobody (apart from R. Stallmann) questions > > the fact that the BIOS of their PC is non-free or all the other firmware > > or microcode on various chips on the motherboard and on expansion cards > > and peripherals. > > In fact, this bother a lot of people : > > People who write coreboot for example ( http://www.coreboot.org ). The > project started because someone wanted to be sure that his cluster didn't > have bios problem. It is a daunting task to hit any key on 1000 servers, > especially if none of them have a keyboard. > > People who just want to know how the pc work, for example, students in low > level system. Lack of source doesn't really help to understand and learn, > at least for the average people. > > People who maybe want to understand why the driver they wrote broke with > firmware update ( happened on some Apple laptop because apple updated > something that broke video driver on linux ). Or why it work with some > card and not some other, since they have a different firmware. > > People who wonder if their TPM chips is really under their control or not. > Maybe a bunch of loonies. Maybe they are just ex sony customers screwed by > their vendor, or people who had 1984 on their Kindle before Amazon removed > it. > > Or simply people that want to know what was fixed for their hardware. > ( https://admin.fedoraproject.org/updates/F14/FEDORA-2010-18594 ). Or just > want to avoid security issues ( > https://events.ccc.de/congress/2010/Fahrplan/track/Hacking/4174.en.html ). > Or avoid waiting 5 minutes delay when booting a server for likely no good > reason. > > Or people that have trouble because the lack of free software in their area > prevent them from doing their work as security researcher, as demonstrated > by the project Osmocombb ( http://bb.osmocom.org/trac/ ). > > But, yes maybe if we remove some security researchers, some cluster admins, > some people that would prefer to not be screwed by vendor, some kernel > developpers, some impatient sysadmins, some students, some coders and RMS, > there is no one who question it.
i agree that free software is important, but if it's a blob without released source code but with BSD license, i really don't see the problem. perhaps someone could just ask the people who licensed it, for the source code...? but this is a thing to do for FSF, not mageia. that is my point. it doesn't mean i don't agree with what those people are doing, they should release it with it. But that still doesn't make it the job of Mageia to fix that.
