Stan,
I addressed you and the List directly about the data on NWA 1836/3133 and
you were wrong. If you are too lazy to ask Dr. Bunch yourself, look in the
archives as this two year argument is over. NAU and Carnegie's data do not
support a pairing, look it up. I think you are borrowing Aaronson's numbers
in regards to the these new listings, I will ask Dr. Bunch tomorrow. There
is no need to argue with a source who has gotten wrong so many times.
Good Night,
Adam
- Original Message -----
From: "stan ." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>; <meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com>
Sent: Sunday, October 15, 2006 2:54 AM
Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] [ebay] ending in about 2 days
It is obvious you want it both ways. You base your Brachinite
Brachnite? i thought we were talking about angrites. In any event i am not
basing the potential pairing on anything i see - as i said i am just
relaying information provided to me by my sources. researchers and
moroccains alike
pairing visually yet your Acap looks identical to 12 kilograms of material
the Aaronson's were selling over the last year. You are in touch with Dr.
Bunch, ask him about NWA 1839/3133 as this has already been addressed on
the List in some detail and as usual you came out on the short side of the
stick.
I did? from what i recall you claimed there was new data that argued
against the 1839/3133 pairing.
I also recall Jeff Grossman posting to the list saying something to the
effect that based on the data avalible currently a claim of pairing wasnt
unreasonable.
you claim there is new data that argues against this - i have asked you to
provide the data 4 times now in the last few hours and yet you dont offer
anything to support your claim other than tales of this mysteryous 'new
data'. I fail to see how i'm the one comming up short either then or now
on this issue. I'm not the one going on about 'new data' that i cant
produce.
Ask Dr. Bunch if your new Acap is paired to all of the other 12 kilograms
unless you are using another Aaronson number in which case he will not
report back to you.
I'll be sure to ask next time I speak with Dr. Bunch. in the mean time if
you look at
http://www4.nau.edu/meteorite/Meteorite/PrimitiveAchondrite.html you will
see the minerology of the paired stones all are virtually identical,
whereas the data for nwa 2775 is nowhere near close.
______________________________________________
Meteorite-list mailing list
Meteorite-list@meteoritecentral.com
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list