* Philippe "BooK" Bruhat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> [2006-06-12 20:55]: > Le lundi 12 juin 2006 à 20:09, A. Pagaltzis écrivait: > > > >> An improvement would be to turn it into a forum, maybe merge > >> with CPAN forums but keeping reviews separate from technical > >> support questions. (Bad reviews such as "how do I compile > >> module X" can be moved into technical support forums too.) > >> Reviews that are voted as useless can be culled by > >> moderators. > > > >I think that’s the most sensible suggestion so far. Now for > >someone to supply the tuits and JFDI for it… :-) > > A forum? As in "a place for flames and uninformed discussion"? > How exactly is that an improvement? :-)
Some would argue that’s what CPAN Ratings already is. ;-) (I don’t see it as bleakly, but I don’t see forums quite that bleakly either ;-) ) > However, having review editors that can act based on the > useful/useless votes is enough to remove the occasional junk > comment (or spam ?). Well, the idea is mainly, I think, to have someplace sensible to move “cna u help me i cant compiel tihs” droppings, as well as a way to keep the occasional “this isn’t a review, I want to respond to that other review” junk from cluttering the place. Shrug. I dunno. Regards, -- Aristotle Pagaltzis // <http://plasmasturm.org/>
