Ben Bucksch wrote:
> 
> The policy isn't working.
  ...
> [...] can we use full disclosure now?

I don't think you've demonstrated problems with the policy but rather that
we have to do a better job implementing it. A *much* better job.

>     * Public security bug lists [...]
>       per policy only list *fixed* bugs anyways.

Not true, there are guidelines for issuing immediate warnings
http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/security-bugs-policy.html#disclosure

If we haven't done so when appropriate that's a failure of the security
group, not the policy. As a member of that group you share in that failing.

> I propose the following changes to the policy and procedure:

A good starting point for discussion, that's what the security group mailing
list is for (not, I should point out, [EMAIL PROTECTED] cc'd in this
thread, which is for reporting potential problems). If you'd raise these
points there I'm sure we could improve things greatly.

-Dan Veditz
_______________________________________________
Mozilla-security mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/mozilla-security

Reply via email to