See also this, today from Yair Rosenberg  who is probably not that progressive, 
but still: 



Douglas Macgregor is a retired U.S. Army colonel who has become Fox News host 
Tucker Carlson’s go-to foreign policy expert. In recent appearances on the 
channel, he has argued 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJxNj82OhCAQhJ9GbhhoUOHAYS77Hs2PSgZhAhj38dfxtEmnU1WdfJX2RgP4FUg0wACY4AufuAY5esdBLgKkFtxq7QbJ-h6wJ8w9utGVg-yGhTDpCdVsZ6-EdzNDMSGg82jVyjxJZu_90wbxGuDnnuu6xlpSinlrveTw5dzxp6R4U9s_SXO4vt6Xc0vY6IFuq2Erla7l9znSfrp3qNRhTa1kWs_WItLzXTHmQLngiktxI0g1x1aS3-8fjqeSdGPP9KbhwJjIs2n0ZgYhJr4oDcsCgjHglimU9g8HdV4J>
 that the U.S. should not sanction Russia and that Vladimir Putin should be 
allowed to annex as much of Ukraine as he wants, which is why many today 
consider 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdj0mOxCAMRU-T7CiBIaFYsOhN38MMCaggRAw93L7pkr7s7yfZ8ndaAbgD1qiBAlDOJNuYAvFwloGQHITizChlF0F78NgTXj3ahy15DdoreRwGn9QBWovc0G23CJuwEqXbcU069H63hX8s8Dk1T4SY0v_6nELJ_vLfbdrsXcTZN7UzKshRfkj1d6ndV4Iulyu24NvkNU_S68j35F-xlUraOE_ferxOMhpp-EvK6KQcZLwqxsuvVeezJBdmhuzfr3dtRnoRnzGm9V1JdHoHzjcmnwqkBE4pMEOfKMwfubxehw>Macgregor
 to be less a neutral observer than a Russia apologist 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdT8GOhCAU-xq9PQMPHIcDh7nsf4A8lYg4gee4-_erkzRN0zRNG6xBDBO20aJAFEoOspcGdRdGiXpQqI2S3pix0YIXcpxc5jh24761i-2DNj0-lFOoJE795J_eiGDGIZDuUbfJLszv2qhXgz8XzvPsrprgYvrz5CrfRZdfjlqjy1DZMQF_gCmlCsdaXMyXsUOKlSnfatp_IdNZYT6oMoT9mGFz41xo3gu4HGDNROmOfpILcYsF3gfH3Ba7zXsKy_Vlo-8Ftv5IK9B2DWq_DDHYByrVy-FpcBhQCYHSi6fT_h_ZwGHi>.
 What they may not know is that he’s also a longtime purveyor of anti-Semitic 
ideas.

“We have a huge problem with a class of so-called elites, the people who are 
wealthy, very wealthy in many cases and they are, as the Russians used to call 
certain individuals many, many years ago, rootless cosmopolitans,” he told the 
Serbian American Voters Alliance in an October 2021 speech 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdzUtqwzAUheHVSLOY-5AsaaBBaUiXUDrUy7WJHIdExnT3FYbDz5l92TuiPJFcPAERMBrU6EgNOSEpw6QcY3QuCQVtLqHV8GhLGtK2ytmHcUqTLgxWkY4pFGa0JU04AhpLWlY_t_Z8C_4QdOv72_a2D7H0646fL7CPz-98CL41wVfquHz59Xeree7eWk6m-bjX-6WsYany7GXJfiRm3RFHxhADEEawQcV_dKM8aQ>uncovered
 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdj0uOwyAQRE8T77CgcWKzYJHN3KNNtzEKHwvweI4_VqRS6alWr8gaANpgCBYkgNRqVk9lYBrJKZhmDZPRajXGPSbZd8YeMffgRlfSsFuJvLLZnGNFRC_mBRZ8kt7cpvSLcIh27_1oD_1-wM-d67rGxBQwYe9c21iqv-et_InMV7uxn-7DVTissZUsNvwtNXQWVE4fsYmEzlf2pYrWS2aBnkXIFDzncjZxcDkii1bOvgtsAfNQbfIl0n4_SPwV73Y940dwwhCHb4tA9gVaP9W8GJhn0FKCWuWC0_oPeGhgEw>
 by Matt Gertz at MediaMatters.

For those understandably unfamiliar with this terminology, “rootless 
cosmopolitans” is an anti-Semitic euphemism 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdjsFuxCAQQ78m3DaCGVLCgcNqpf5GNTA0QYWAElp1_750JcuSfbAfOwvAnyCSAwkgURm1KAt65qBAGwRtUXlrw6Rl3yP1TEdPYQ61iN3JFVfPGFgThsV7jQwLWb1KRM-KRHZ77-2a8D7B-9Az_dR4hGfItUVONNdzGzWdYzPHma72O-L9_6JepbaaU6fj40GlUdoOcbqy1cz7oCnxBdGd_85ft1goZfHyW2L3BoiLMqsFYwClBOXlStr_ARrRSvY>
 for Jews that was popularized 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdkE1vgzAMhn8N3Frli0IOHKimTut1066IJAaihpiRtPz9uVhW8jhy3teya7UQbhSlbwUTgkle84proc7OcqFqKZSW3GhtC8XyDEMOQ8zeni0u5dyqEbQ1UilmeTVC5SzISo5MS-NUI20Z2jnnNRWyK8SNct_384Q4BXgr0INBfCS6wfnsMRL9zNB_48tD7j_xBVtcIOZ-iK4n__4Oe-q5Vg11_tZT01F8dd29kLc5FPIDSOIymfVFzAndH8GGmAMk8rlaTAuuGHwe4rtOhxPBMx72l3XzMSew9G3cMGb7nqHc2mXC4GbawnKMXubWPMPjBMvgQ3mcJ-_ai5Cy4nWjRV0LyZjghjWDMv-cS3JV>under
 Stalin in the Soviet Union. Adolf Hitler also repeatedly referred 
<https://emails.theatlantic.com/c/eJwdzUuKwzAQBNDTWLuI7pJsWQstZjP30Nc28SckbZjjjwgURVGbV4IHSoPaAgggw45H9rC6ZIZ1BtYbTt7nwZKsNcoeT9myzteh1tCyb1MrERGYaLaeRwfTXIkzF9Oa2sMq8voM5mfAb89ySz1TfS_6rKLj3a-aruv5IfRJIJqItfyJeodjufaydveoX05Cuvfnox5x29W3H1sJE4wZ2c0ertNE4ERztOkf1AY__g>
 to Jews as disloyal cosmopolitans, lamenting in his manifesto Mein Kampfthat 
“it is no longer princes or their courtesans who contend and bargain about 
state frontiers, but the inexorable cosmopolitan Jew who is fighting for his 
own dominion over the nations.” In other words, there is exactly one type of 
person who uses this sort of language in everyday conversation.

In case his audience missed the point, though, Macgregor added: “They live 
above all of this, they have no connection to the country. There is nothing 
there that holds them in place, and they are largely responsible, in my 
judgment, for the condition that we are in today.”


Best,
Michael

> On Mar 17, 2022, at 4:00 PM, Ted Byfield <tedbyfi...@gmail.com> wrote:
> 
> This is my favorite debate strategy: when you don’t have a substantive 
> argument, just say your interlocutors are incapable of understanding the 
> truth.  It works for Macgregor’s fanboys on Fox, no reason it shouldn’t work 
> on nettime. 
> 
> Cheers,
> Ted
> On Mar 17, 2022, 18:26 -0400, Stefan Heidenreich <m...@stefanheidenreich.de>, 
> wrote:
> it's a double bind + cognitive dissonance problem:
> 
> for most western intellectuals, after years of fighting for the right
> causes (which I also supported and keep supporting) it is very difficult
> to realize that one has been gaslighted as useful idiot for the
> military-industrial complex.
> #  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
> #  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
> #  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
> #  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
> #  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nett...@kein.org
> #  @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject:

#  distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
#  <nettime>  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nett...@kein.org
#  @nettime_bot tweets mail w/ sender unless #ANON is in Subject:

Reply via email to