Klaus, If you want to play tunes in concert G and D, with a compass between D and b, with the simplest possible fingerings (holes rather than keys) then a G chanter is certainly what you need. If you use a D chanter you will have more range for playing notes below this compass, but will lose range at the top - only going up to (real) f sharp typically. You don't want to use overblowing! D chanters sound wonderful, but aren't what you need for playing along with others. G chanters can sound a bit shrill, and are fiddly to cover the holes properly (think of a sopranino recorder). So if you get the chance to try before you buy, do so. John
-- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
