On 5 Apr 2008, Richard York wrote: > I haven't heard the Rob MacKillop version - is this the same as > Julia's version 1, please?
Not quite - although it's closely related. -------------------------------------------------------- X:2486 T:Flowers of the Forest (The Liltin') M:4/4 L:1/8 K:G G2 GG AB de|dB AG E2 D2|G2 GG AB de| dB A>G G4||\ DE =FF EF GG|DD BA GE DD|D2 EG e2 dB|A2 AB/A/ G4||** --------------------------------------------------------------------- The source I have (the Scots Fiddle book I mentioned previously) states that both this and the "modern" tune are played at the Selkirk common riding, the older one as a lament, and the modern one as a march. I've never been so I can't verify this (or otherwise) Julia To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
