Hi Denis,
On Fri, 2011-01-14 at 17:59 +0200, Denis Kenzior wrote:
> Hi Jarko,
>
> Both are active and the modem should be reporting both. At least that
> is how I understood the specifications.
>
Well that is a bit debatable. As 27.007 states:
command:
+CCFC=<reason>,<mode>[,<number>[,<type>[,<class>[,<subaddr>[,<satype>[,<time>]]]]]]
<reason>: integer type
0 unconditional
1 mobile busy
2 no reply
3 not reachable
4 all call forwarding (refer 3GPP TS 22.030 [19])
5 all conditional call forwarding (refer 3GPP TS 22.030 [19])
<mode>: integer type
0 disable
1 enable
2 query status
3 registration
4 erasure
response when<mode>=2 and command successfull:
+CCFC:<status>,<class1>[,<number>,<type>[,<subaddr>,<satype>[,<time>]]][<CR><LF>+CCFC:
<status>,<class2>[,<number>,<type>[,<subaddr>,<satype>[,<time>]]][...]]
<status>: integer type
0 not active
1 active
So actually they aren't both "active" at same time as the logs show but
personally I don't really care as long as the results are consistent
regardless which API you use which is not the case at the moment as
querying through org.ofono.CallForwarding can give you different result
than using org.ofono.SupplementaryServices.
> A bit, but having the AT command logs would help greatly.
Well hopefully these will help. I have numbered each step and copied
corresponding logs after it. list-modems doesn't cause AT queries to
modem(except on a very first time which I have already done) so I have
copied what it prints regarding CF. It's a bit long though so sorry
about that.
#1: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 0
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply =
VoiceUnconditional =
#2: ./test-ussd '**61*+358401234567*11#'
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=2,3,"358401234567",145,1,,,20\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=2,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 1,1,"0401234567",129,"",,20\r\n\r
\nOK\r\n
#3: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 0
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply = 0401234567
VoiceUnconditional =
#4: ./test-ussd '**21*+358401234567*11#'
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,3,"358401234567",145,1\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 1,1,"0401234567",129\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
#5: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 1
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply = 0401234567
VoiceUnconditional = 0401234567
#6: ./test-ussd '*#002#'
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 1,1,"0401234567",129\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=1,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n+CCFC: 0,4\r\n+CCFC: 0,16\r
\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,32\r\n+CCFC: 0,64\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,128\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=2,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n+CCFC: 0,4\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,16\r\n+CCFC: 0,32\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,64\r\n+CCFC: 0,128\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=3,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n+CCFC: 0,4\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,16\r\n+CCFC: 0,32\r\n+CCFC: 0,64\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,128\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
#7: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 1
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply =
VoiceUnconditional = 0401234567
#8: ./test-ussd '##21#'
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,4\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,4\r\n+CCFC: 0,16\r\n+CCFC: 0,32\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,64\r\n+CCFC: 0,128\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\nOK\r\n
#9: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 0
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply =
VoiceUnconditional =
#10: ./test-ussd '*#002#'
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=0,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n+CCFC: 0,4\r\n+CCFC: 0,16\r
\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,32\r\n+CCFC: 0,64\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,128\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=1,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n+CCFC: 0,4\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,16\r\n+CCFC: 0,32\r\n+CCFC: 0,64\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,128\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=2,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 1,1,"0401234567",129,"",,20\r\n\r
\nOK\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: > AT+CCFC=3,2\r
ofonod[30925]: Default: < \r\n+CCFC: 0,1\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,4\r\n+CCFC: 0,16\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,32\r\n+CCFC: 0,64\r\n
ofonod[30925]: Default: < +CCFC: 0,128\r\n\r\nOK\r\n
#11: ./list-modems
[ org.ofono.CallForwarding ]
ForwardingFlagOnSim = 0
VoiceNoReplyTimeout = 20
VoiceNotReachable =
VoiceBusy =
VoiceNoReply = 0401234567
VoiceUnconditional =
So as can be seen the result changes between #5 and #7 although nothing
has been changed. What's more concerning is that at #9 ofono claims that
no CF is active but as can be seen in #11 actually VoiceNoReply no
longer is "quiescent" but "active".
-Jarko-
_______________________________________________
ofono mailing list
ofono@ofono.org
http://lists.ofono.org/listinfo/ofono
