Am 10/25/2011 02:02 PM, schrieb Robert Burrell Donkin:
On Mon, Oct 24, 2011 at 2:08 AM, Marcus (OOo)<[email protected]> wrote:
<snip>
The problem is that the ASF do not want to host and provide services of
special software for single projects. I can understand this as even the ASF
infra is a team of volunteers and their time is limited as it is for all
others.
I think this is a little open to misinterpretation. Hopefully a Mentor
will jump in but (until they do) I'll do my best to explain a little
bit more about the way infrastructure works here at Apache...
The infrastructure team at Apache is an independent, volunteer-led
self-organising community of experts. Apache delegates infrastructure
to this community, and provides resources to sustain their work[1].
When asking infrastructure for help, it's essential to remember this
and engage with them as peers with special expertise. Anyone arriving
with a solution or a request for a new service must expect to be
challenged to defend and refine their choice of solution.
Thanks for the explaination. I thought it would be a kind of just
another project. But it's not.
To move back to the particular, this is a migration issue. A valuable
service is about to be closed and needs to be migrated. Whether this
is right long term solution is open to debate but accepting a service
for a temporary period doesn't raise the issues that committing to
provide a similar service for all projects forever would. Please
explain the problem to infrastructure and ask for their help to find a
solution.
I know a service like MirrorBrain could be a high value of any Apache
project that provides file downloads, so it should be helpful for every
project.
As it is able keep the overview of all possible mirrors that offers
Apache aoftware there needs to be only a single instance and not per
project.
Let's see what to get until Friday. Otherwise he have to start again.
Marcus
[1] The team has a budget and some flexibility to bring additional
resources - included hired help - when needed. Apache has adequate
financial resources but is culturally resistant to committing to
additional spending without good reason. Apache values independence.
Dependency on funding risks that independence.