On Oct 26, 2011, at 12:11 PM, Marcus (OOo) wrote:

> Am 10/24/2011 03:08 AM, schrieb Marcus (OOo):
>> Am 10/23/2011 11:50 PM, schrieb Peter Pöml:
>>> On Sat, Oct 22, 2011 at 01:15:34 +0200, Marcus (OOo) wrote:
>> 
>> Hi Peter,
>> 
>>>> it seems the end is near and the "download.services.openoffice.org"
>>>> host on Oracle side with our Mirrorbrain instance will be shutdown
>>>> in one week.
>>> 
>>> Okay... Little question, wouldn't it make sense, at this point, to take
>>> the download.s.o.o VM and move it somewhere else? I don't have the disk
>>> space myself, but maybe somebody else has? Perhaps the ASF can provide
>>> the space? (Other than disk space, the requirements are pretty modest.)
>>> Then the entire download service could continue to run, with very low
>>> effort, and without the need to build everything from scratch for now.
>> 
>> The problem is that the ASF do not want to host and provide services of
>> special software for single projects. I can understand this as even the
>> ASF infra is a team of volunteers and their time is limited as it is for
>> all others.

They are building a lot special for AOOo. THANKS!

So, it depends. If we define a stack for services and get support then it is a 
lot like the MWiki and Forums. Infrastructure will help secure the servers, but 
the project will need to provide sysadmins.

I've heard that "Jails" are available.

>> 
>> Furthermore, I don't know details about the VM setup and where it's
>> detailed located. Do you?
>> 
>> However, I like your idea. It requires indeed only a bit diskspace and
>> internet access. The maintainance could be done by us, the project
>> members. If you would share a bit of your knowledge then I could
>> takeover the admin role. ;-)
> 
> @Peter:
> Can you tell me how to get to the VM? Or at least which important config 
> files to save?

Are there requirements for more than what is on the mirrorbrain page?

http://mirrorbrain.org/requirements/

Extracting the list gives:

Apache HTTPD server
mod_mirrorbrain
mod_form
mod_geoip / libGeoIP
PostgreSQL (or Apache DBD API compatible driver)

mod_asn ?

        • Python and some modules: psycopg2, sqlobject, cmdln.
        • Perl and some modules: Config::IniFiles, libwww::perl, DBD::Pg, 
Digest::MD4, Date::Parse

If we are on ASF hardware then we won't want to serve a local copy:

So, "Alternatively, a pseudo file tree can created locally. In that case, 
MirrorBrain needs to be configured to never deliver files directly."

http://mirrorbrain.org/archive/mirrorbrain/0045.html

>> @List:
>> Has anybody an idea about where to host this service? It doesn't need to
>> be necessarily inside the ASF.
> 
> Really nobody?

If the mirrorbrain instructions are that simple and can be easily supplemented 
with detail.

Like what database is currently being used on download.s.oo.o? and which 
version?


> 
>>>> As we cannot buildup a solution that is running, tested and
>>>> long-term-proven in a few days I would like to ask you if we can
>>>> switch to your "openoffice.mirrorbrain.org" instance as long as we
>>>> have no other solution at hand.
>>>> 
>>>> In the past it was a very reliable host that we have used when there
>>>> were outages (mostly unplanned as you know) and doesn't resulted in
>>>> a significant higher load on the host.
>>>> 
>>>> So, it would help us very much to have a stable download section
>>>> until we have an own solution here at ASF.
>>> 
>>> Yes, please use my host for now!
>> 
>> Great, thanks a lot.
>> 
>>>> Thanks in advance and have a nice, sunny weekend.
>>> 
>>> Thanks a lot. Same to you all,
> 
> Marcus

Regards,
Dave

Reply via email to