On 03/01/2012 11:35 AM, Rob Weir wrote: > On Thu, Mar 1, 2012 at 2:24 PM, NoOp <snip...configure your client properly> > wrote: > > <snip> > >> So in order to avoid further confusion, I still think it would be >> helpful to clarify which version the 'Call to volunteers' are supposed >> to be testing (ooo-dev or 'full normal install'). >> > > I think testing either install set is fine. Most bugs are in common > or are clear from the context. But I'll try to be more clear with > future notes.
Thanks, a followup on the user list regarding this is necessary (IMO). I also suggest that AOO follow the tried & true method of posting DS/Beta/RC et al on: http://www.openoffice.org/download/index.html rather than on a "Calling all volunteers: It is time to test" with a unclear link to <https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OOOUSERS/AOO+3.4+Unofficial+Developer+Snapshots> and asking users/testers to go there to download rather than some cwiki.apache.org page. Further I very much disagree that "testing either install set is fine". I've already pointed out that a test 'reporter' is not able to distinquish between the two via the Help|About results. Were I a developer and/or QA person I'd definitely like to know if the tester/reporter is testing/reporting version x (ooo-dev) or version y (openoffice full standard). It is obvious that you did exactly what I tried to point out; you sent out a msg asking users to "If you are ready to test, you can download the latest developer snapshot build from this page". You then downloaded the other: OOo_3.4.0_Linux_x86_install-deb_en-US.tar.gz instead & reported the install (albeit with new tester results from '/openoffice.org3.4-debian-menus_3.4-9586_all.deb' - it's OK we've all been there done that). I've already pointed out that there are differences between the ooo-dev builds and the ooo 3.4 builds. A tester on the user list has already reported a printing difference between the two... see: "Printing problem with OOo-dev 3.4" from Josef Latt. To simply fob off testing between the two (particularly when I've pointed out that both report the same in Help|About). So how are any 'evaluators' able to tell if the 'report' from user x (your's for example) is from someone that is testing x or y? I certainly hope that further "tests" on AOO/OOo do not take a similar shotgun approach. I think it also *very* important to point out to user/testers that downloading and installing one or the other will wipe out/overwrite existing installations of earlier versions. Granted that not many standard users will have had earlier ooo-dev or ooo 3.4.x versions installed before testing. *But* if they had it is *important* to advise them that installing these new untested versions will replace their existing installs. And yes, I did have previous versions of both installed (linux and Windows) and the r1293550 versions overwrote the existing installs. For me that is not an issue, but for a standard user it may very well be a *significant* issue. I fail to understand why it is so difficult for you to: 1) reply to my questions on the user list (afterall you did post there asking 'users' to test & you've still not replied on that list), and 2) just post a followup to the original "Calling all volunteers: It is time to test" and clarify that users should download and test x or y... and also please report which version you've downloaded, installed, and tested. Point being is that I think that AI should review, revise, and fix how you ask & promote pre-release testing. I do not believe that there need to be new rules as the process/rules were well established under OOo. Follow those & perhaps AIOO can improve on them. I'd also pay particular attention to the former OOo release mailing list whereby folks could report 'showstoppers', release test issues, etc. Gary Lee ...
