@Kay,

I have no idea.

I trust that someone else can indicate how this works.  

Having successfully built from source seems to be a key requirement, and one 
would hope that at least three people confirm that.  Of course, there is 
support for some many platforms and user configurations that I don't know what 
can be said for coverage at this level.

On the general incubator list, there has been discussions around the fact that 
the essential release is the source code and that it be buildable as well as 
satisfying other conditions regarding dependencies, IP, signatures, 
documentation, notices, etc.  Many view the binaries as conveniences.  

For us, the binaries have been essential components and are a goal of this 
consumer-facing project.  But that is a quality issue, not so much a release 
issue, perhaps.  On the other hand, the binaries are artifacts of the release, 
and so conditions on those artifacts apply as well, it seems to me.

Here's the key FAQ on releases that I am aware of:
  <http://www.apache.org/dev/release.html>.

This is one of the key items:
  <http://www.apache.org/dev/release.html#approving-a-release>.

That is about top-level-project PMC releases (the IPMC is the top-level for 
us).  Elsewhere, it is pointed out that the conditions for incubator releases 
are in addition to those:
<http://incubator.apache.org/guides/releasemanagement.htm>.

There is a great deal of material in that incubator release management guide, 
although it is all in draft.  Although there are many placeholders, I think it 
provides a good picture of the essentials. 

 - Dennis

-----Original Message-----
From: Kay Schenk [mailto:[email protected]] 
Sent: Saturday, April 21, 2012 16:22
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [DISCUSS][VOTE] Release Apache OpenOffice 3.4 (incubating) RC1



On 04/21/2012 01:01 PM, Dennis E. Hamilton wrote:
[ ... ]
> Committers and PPMC members are expected to cast informed ballots.
> If any contributor casts a "-1", it should be accompanied by a clear,
> specific explanation and suggestion of actions that would cure the
> situation.
>
> Here is something that all project contributors can participate in,
> with or without voting:
>
> PARTICIPATE IN QUALITY-ASSURANCE COVERAGE OF THE CANDIDATE
>
> It is valuable to download the source code and confirm that binaries
> can be built.

OK, I have a question on this one. MUST we download and build or can we 
vote on an already built (binary) version? There was some discussion 
about this, and, yes, there are notes about this on general information 
for Apache releases, but...I jsut noticed the vote from Hagar Delest 
which implies he used a binary so this is why I ask.

Meanwhile, I will download the source and try my hand...just in case. I 
DO want to vote, and vote correctly.

I have had NO issues with the binary I now have.


[ ... ]

Reply via email to