On Apr 22, 2012, at 1:21 PM, Dave Fisher wrote: > > On Apr 22, 2012, at 1:02 PM, Rob Weir wrote: > >> On Sun, Apr 22, 2012 at 3:57 PM, Dave Fisher <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>> On Apr 22, 2012, at 12:47 PM, Rob Weir wrote: >>> >>>> <snip> >>> >>> >>> You snipped out the important part: >>> >> >> Sorry, thought you answered your own question there. But since you >> bring it up, there is no requirement for a DISCLAIMER file. There is >> however a requirement for making the user aware of the incubation >> disclaimer. See this page, where several options are listed: >> >> http://incubator.apache.org/guides/releasemanagement.html#notes-disclaimer > > Keep in mind that page is clearly labeled as a "DRAFT". > > http://incubator.apache.org/guides/releasemanagement.html#status > > The DISCLAIMER file is certainly in the correct place in the Source > distribution.
Well, I was not correct here. It is in the SVN, but fails to make it into any of the distributions. I did a MacOSX build, reviewed the NOTICE, LICENSE, rat-exclude and rat output from a nightly build. An amazing job was done with the Headers and the RAT report! Here are my concerns: (1) DISCLAIMER ought to be included in all packages. We'll have to see if this is a SHOULD or a MUST. (2) LICENSE contains copyright statements which ought to be part of the NOTICE file. Again we'll see if this is a SHOULD or a MUST. (3) When building from source there was no warning about the inclusion of Category B? I think that the Building Guide should be edited to more clearly explain the ext_sources and ext_libraries. I know we have the information. It is more making this clear. Again, I'm not sure if it a SHOULD or a MUST for a build to pause and get explicit permission to download category B. Regards, Dave > > I think that I answered the question, but I would like to ask our project > Mentors if this will be an issue in IPMC voting. I've seen enough on > [email protected] to know that it may be for some and not others. > > So, while this is not a problem for me, if it is likely IPMC will request an > RC2 over this we should know now. > > Regards, > Dave > >> >> -Rob >> >>> The SDK and Binaries are missing the DISCLAIMER file. Is a missing >>> Incubation DISCLAIMER in a binary package enough to prevent release? I >>> think probably not, but this may be an edge case. The application pop-ups >>> do mention "Incubation" and every page linked back to thewww.openoffice.org >>> shows the Disclaimer... >>> >>> Regards, >>> Dave >>> >>> >>> >>>> >>>> -Rob >>> >
