On 2012-05-25, at 20:34 , Albino Biasutti Neto wrote:

> Hi.
> 
> 2012/5/25 Louis Suárez-Potts <[email protected]>
> 
>> 
>> 
>> On 2012-05-23, at 12:21 , Andrew Rist wrote:
>> 
>>> As part of the transfer of the web properties of OOo to the ASF, the set
>> of related domains has also been offered to ASF.
>>> We (PPMC) need to decide what we want to do with the related domains.
>> There are three obvious options available to us:
>>> 
>>> * Ignore and let the domains expire
>>> * Continue to register to block squatting, but do no more
>>> * Continue to register and forward to oo.o
>> 
>> 
>> As I have mentioned more than once, I seem to own openoffice.ca and would
>> be willing to contribute it (or whatever one does) to AOO. In general,
>> historically we have approached the owners of such sites and asked them to
>> work with the community.
>> 
>> 
> +1
> 
> The better option.
> 
> There are many alternatives. I don't like very much and confuse me.

Likewise. I prefer very simple and when possible friendly solutions. Only if 
the rose of friendship is crushed should we show our thorns. But in general 
what I would rather have is that for all similar to AOO domains a) pointing to 
AOO proper, and if needed, the NL projects, and b) hosting, as mirrors, code, 
binaries, documents, if that is desired.

There is a third point. One reason I tacitly enabled and even silently promoted 
the development of these satellites was to promote the global ecosystems that 
implicitly support OO by providing support, etc. Thus, I'd be in favour of 
proposing a model where a domain that reflects "openoffice" and is used in 
behalf of the wider community, be promoted. The only things to stipulate would 
be, I imagine, that any binaries or code offered as representing or identical 
to AOO *be* such; and that any representations of or on behalf of AOO be in 
keeping with Apache's ethos. That said, should it be the case then, that there 
is no need for such satellites and that they only serve to confuse, then, of 
course, we simply say, no—to this proposal, to the satellites, unless there is 
a good reason for them.

But I think as long as the freedom described above is not confusing and does 
not lead to deception, that it will only actually help the expansion of the 
communities.

We do need robust ecosystems.

Louis


> 
> Albino

Reply via email to