On 5/7/06, Graham Anderson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
On Sunday 07 May 2006 14:09, jdd wrote:
> I don't see there is really problem with tables, but I don"t
> like the new layout
Everyone should heed this warning!
I cannot stress enough the importance of leaving the design of an important
and busy website to people who have *significant* web design experience. More
harm than good will happen if people who obviously have no large or
commercial website design experience continue to make arbitrary changes to
the design of the opensuse website.
It is a wiki. People who have *significant* web design experience, can
join in anytime. But if you look at the history there is quite a small
number of people who have done most of the existing work on the wiki,
working from a bare skeleton.
The design process of a wiki is to make the change, and then review by
peers, like we are doing here. Significant structural changes are
rare, and the pivotal pages tend towards stability, with a jolt every
now and then.
The documentation page layout is now *broken*. The 'Other languages' box
now renders *below* the page footer in Firefox and probably on other browsers
too.
The documentation page is not broken. The Other Languages box is
another matter...
Using tables for layout breaks accepted design principles for a few good
reasons. Two of the most important reasons are as follows.
<SNIP comments about tables and usability>
All your crticism of tables are totally valid, and there is no dispute.
However the old Documentation page had a two-column table as well, and
is only modifed.
(I have to admit I introduced that table in my layout of the
Documantation page last year).
I agree that we should replace my use of tables for layout. It is no
defence that a lot of wiki including Wikipedia uses them extensively,
especially for index and front pages.
This will also impact any front page redesign, as the suggestions I
have seen use tables extensively.
Peter 'Pflodo' Flodin