If Gonz was going for an old "color" look, like from old slides, especially those that have faded over the years, then I might agree with you. But, as an old look based on B&W photography, not even close, IMO.
Shel > [Original Message] > From: William Robb > The colour reminds me of some Autochromes that my father in law has. > If you are going for an old look, I'd say you've hit the mark pretty close. > It's a very good portrait. > From: "Gonz" > Subject: PESO PAW Another soft shot > > > > My youngest, she loves drama and this was her chance to act out a little > > in front of the camera. I didnt make it entirely Black and White. > > Trying to get an "old" portrait look. Do I need to desaturate more? > > > > http://www.g0nz.com/4imgs/data/media/1/anframe.jpg