Maaf, dari tulisan anda saya jadi tahu banyak. Termasuk bahwa yang anda
tahu tidaklah sebanyak yang anda tuliskan. Hampir sebagian besar dari yang
anda tulis hanya berdasar dari analisis anda terhadap informasi yang
kelihatannya belum cukup lengkap, apalagi akurat.
Dari sisi produktivitas menulis, saya kagum dengan anda. Namun kalau
dilihat dari kualitas tulisan, sebagian besar tulisan anda (apalagi yang
isinya cercaan dan kekesalan anda terhadap berbagai tokoh) malah terlihat
rendah mutunya.
Maaf, saya terpaksa menyimpang dari konteks, karena harapan saya kita bisa
masuk ke diskusi yang bisa saling menambah wawasan, namun ternyata telah
menjadi tumpahan kekesalan anda dengan sumpah serapahnya. Belum lagi,
terlalu banyak hal yang saya tidak sependapat dengan anda tentang topik ini.
Silahkanlah kalau anda menganggap bahwa yang anda tulis dan pertahankan
adalah benar menurut anda. Semoga anda dapat terpuasi.
Salam,
Budi
At 10:21 PM 12/19/99 -0500, you wrote:
>Ah, pura-pura sok tak tahu saja nih. Kenapa permisinya ke INTERFET kan
>karena UNTAET cuman organisasi gombal, yang belum ada giginya. Ini kan sama
>dengan permisi masuk ke wilayah manapun yang masih dicokoli oleh militer.
>Biarpun ada badan tersendiri, ijin yang manjur jelas ke yang militer.
>Sedangkan ijin ke organisasi gombal tak terorganisir macam UNTAET cuman jadi
>cap stempel. Ini tidak hanya terjadi di Indonesia kok.
>
>Dengan demikian, Buyung sudah benar. Lagipula, sebetulnya Buyung kan sudah
>mengirim ke kedua organisasi itu. Tapi karena INTERFET lebih berperan, maka
>si Cockroach pujaan anda itu yang njeplak duluan. Dari sini kan anda bisa
>lihat siapa yg punya kuasa di sana. Apakah si Brasil itu atau si Cockroach
>yang punya kuasa?
>
>Oya, di bawah ini saya tempelkan ketua KPP-HAM si Hasibuan yang asal
>nyamblak itu. Masak kalau sudah ke Timtim lalu melihat bangunan terbakar
>lalu dapat mengambil kesimpulan bahwa TNI menyuruh pembumihangusan? Kalau
>sesederhana itu, wah, makin ketahuan kualitas 'pendekar-pendekar HAM' dan
>'pendekar hukum' deh.
>
>Mau tahu kualitas pakar hukum kita? Mari kita tengok Harkristuti dosen UI
>(kampus ORBA? Hehe...). Alasan bahwa dia nggak mau bergabung dengan Buyung
>karena si Buyung cuman koleksi informasi. Katanya mestinya lihat fakta dan
>kenyataan lapangan. Ini kan namanya dosen gemblung. Ijasahnya jangan-jangan
>aspal? Atau FHUI memang segitu aja kualitasnya? Kalau sekedar melihat fakta
>dan kenyataan lapangan bahwa gedung-gedung terbakar sih nggak perlu ke
>Timtim. Cukup lihat di arsip TV doang sudah cukup. Mana mau melihat
>langsungpun dilarang sama si Cockroach. Yang lebih penting informasi dong.
>Gimana bisa terjadi demikian, dari pihak sana dan sini digali info siapa yg
>suruh ngungsi, siapa yg bakar membakar. Ya fakta sih memang perlu juga.
>Cuman nggak lalu dibolak-balik kayak orang bikin nasi goreng gitu. Dosen
>gemblung kok bergaya.....:) Sudah jualan nasi goreng aja deh.
>Tobat-tobat...... :)
>
>Nah, si UNTAET gombal itu lihat deh. Begitu kena tuduhan langsung berkelit
>bilangnya welcome. Mana itu si Cockroach yang berani njeplak itu? Mana
>alasan keamanan itu? Katanya sudah aman sejak sebulan yg lalu?! Memang payah
>kalau jendral yg cuman kebagian ngebersihin sampah di garis belakang Vietnam
>kayak Cockroach dikasih jabatan. Jadinya ngelunjak. Persis kayak Marjuki.
>
>Wah, kalau sekarang Buyung ke Timtim sih kondisi lapangan sudah diset-up
>sama INTERFET deh. Jangan-jangan si Cockroach memerlukan untuk bikin cacat
>penduduk lokal. Ini biar kelihatan makin dramatis. Nanti rombongan juga akan
>dituntun untuk melihat lokasi-lokasi tertentu saja. Lokasi ini sebelumnya
>sudah diset-up, lengkap dengan penduduk palsu, yang sudah disetel bagaimana
>harus menjawab pertanyaan-pertanyaan.
>
>Buyung...buyung.... tugasmu berat nian nak. Coba dulu ikut jadi Brutus
>terhadap Habibie, elu kan sudah jadi Jakgung. Kalah strategi sama Marjuki
>sih....:) Yah, nasib.
>
>
>JA
>
>-----------------------------
>>From: Budi Haryanto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>>Reply-To: Indonesian Students in the US <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>Subject: Re: Apa yg terjadi di Timtim?
>>Date: Sun, 19 Dec 1999 15:10:12 -0800
>>
>>At 08:35 AM 12/19/99 -0500, you wrote:
>> >Lho, yang mestinya jadi pernyataan kan mengapa Interfet masih ada?
>>Katanya
>> >kalau sudah muncul UNTAET lalu INTERFET dibubarkan? Kenapa pula masih
>> >bercokol di situ? Jawabannya hanya satu kawan! Karena Aussie belum
>>mendapat
>> >legitimasi untuk mengatasnamakan diri sendiri sebagai bagian dari pasukan
>> >UNTAET. Apa anda mau berkelit bahwa UNTAET hanya pemerintahan sementara
>> >sehingga tidak punya tentara? Ah, salah kawan. Sudah 4 kali orang UNTAET
>> >masuk ke Timbar secara ilegal, dan di antara mereka adalah tentara.
>> >Duplikasi ini yang menunjukkan bahwa Aussie mempunyai kepentingan dengan
>> >membandel untuk membubarkan diri.
>> >
>>Budi:
>>Anda mau ngomongin apa kawan? Arahnya kemana kawan?
>>Yang saya sayangkan (dalam posting terdahulu) adalah tindakan Buyung yang
>>salah karena mau masuk Timtim kok ijinnya ke Interfet. Lha wong Timtim
>>sudah dibawah tanggungjawab UNTAET kok minta ijin masuk ke yang lain.
>>Jadi, jawaban anda atas posting saya nggak pas nyambungnya. Sayang......
>>
>>Salam,
>>Budi
>
>---------------------------------------------
>
>KPP HAM Invites Adnan Buyung Nasution On Trip To East Timor
>Jakarta, Kompas Online
>
>Chairman of the Investigation Commission of Human Rights Offenses (KPP HAM)
>in East Timor, Albert Hasibuan, denied allegations voiced by Adnan Buyung
>Nasution (Chairman Advocacy Team of Human Rights of TNI Officers) that
>failure to enter the region was due to a conspiracy between the National
>Commission of Human Rights, Interfet and the United Nations Transitional
>Administration in East Timor (UNTAET).
>
>"There is no conspiracy. What conspiracy? Let's go together to East
>Timor to watch from nearby the burnt carcasses of buildings and
>homes. Let's go to Suai also and visit the killing site at the church of
>Suai," Hasibuan told Kompas Sunday (19/12) in Jakarta.
>
>A report said that after unsuccessful efforts to enter East Timor,
>Nasution concluded that he was under the impression that a conspiracy was
>going on between the National Commission of Human Rights (Komnas HAM),
>Interfet and UNTAET. Nasution said, however, that his impressions might have
>been wrong.
>
>UNTAET also denied the allegation in a press release, that it had
>refused entry to Nasution. "It is not true that UNTAET and Interfet
>refused entry of Nasution. You are welcome, please come in, but let
>us know 24 hours before coming over," Sidney Jones, a staff member
>of UNTAET's rights unit said.
>
>"There is not one delegation from which ever country, that has
>demanded immediate entry into East Timor, and certainly not if a
>delegation consists of 27 members, Sidney Jones said explaining at
>the same time that Nasution had not informed them how long they
>would stay, and whom they like to meet.
>
>"We have accomodation problems, transportation and security problems," he
>explained further.
>
>No reasons
>
>Referring to a temporary conclusion of the Advocacy Team that the offenses
>were an expression of disappointment on the side of the public, Hasibuan
>said that it was not a justified reason. Errors made in the past and
>disappointment of the public are no reasons to justify human rights
>offenses.
>
>"Like it or not, we have to admit it. If an error had been made by Unamet,
>that would not whitewash human rights offenses. The logic
>that arson taking place in most of East Timor by new arrivals, should
>be linked to the psychological situation of a disappointed people, is
>just unacceptable," Hasibuan said.
>
>"KPP HAM does not want to blame TNI (Indonesian Armed Forces)
>which has an official policy like we have when we meet the TNI Chief
>Commander and President Gus Dur. It is difficult, however, to
>mention the names of TNI members once you've observed massive destruction,"
>he said again.
>
>Explanations in the offing
>
>Starting Monday (20/12) KPP HAM will be conducting a series of
>meetings with various groups who knew of the HAM violations in East
>Timor. Foremr Chief Commander General Wiranto, is one of the persons who
>will be sounded out for more informations.
>
>Saturday (18/12), at Bina Graha, Wiranto told the press that he will
>explain or provide informations to KPP HAM about the East Timor
>problem. He also regretted that KPP HAM had published a collection
>of facts, which, in his opinion, held a onesided version.
>
>Wiranto told reporters to great length, about a chronoligical situation in
>East Timor, from the start right to the end of the incidents.
>
>He said, his involvement in East Timor in 1976 had been of a strategic
>nature which formed a link to the recent polling opinion in the region.
>
>"It was my duty to explain the real situation of East Timor to the
>public. Because of moral responsibilities, it was assumed that I knew
>exactly what happened in East Timor," said Wiranto who smiled a lot
>that afternoon.
>
>The former TNI Chief Commander in BJ Habibie's government also
>said, KPP HAM should be provided with facts, indeed. It is, after all,
>their task to look for data and facts, not to investigate or indict
>people.
>
>"KPP HAM is looking for facts to forward it to the National Commission of
>Human Rights, which, in turn will be handing these over to government," he
>said.
>
>He also said, throwing wide open the results of the fact collection and
>informations by KPP HAM, only worsened the problem. Wiranto showed the
>collected facts which KPP HAM had published, a good part of it stemmed from
>Unamet quarters, Interfet and from pro-independence communities.
>
>"No explanation had been requested by the Indonesian government,
>the Indonesian military, Indonesian bureaucrats, and from the
>pro-integration side. They count just a few. But it has been exposed,"
>he said.
>
>Wiranto said also that publication by KPP HAM cannot be justified.
>"I regret this very much." Later he said, his request to Adnan Buyung
>Nasution and colleagues had been made to prevent the other side
>from misusing the law against his group, the Indonesian Armed
>Forces.
>
>So, he said, the team of lawyers is not going to oppose the court, if
>there will be a court case. They are there to also protect citizens
>from such irregularities.
>
>Meanwhile, Hendardi, Chairman of PBHI, and Indonesia University
>lecturer, Harkristuti Harkrisnowo, Chairman of the Foreign Department
>National Mandate Party (PAN), Bara Nasution, said that the trip of Nasution
>and company had only been a public stunt. Locals and the international world
>would then be able to see how he and his team have really been working. But,
>he failed in these efforts.
>
>Harkristuti said that he refused to join Nasution's team. Nasution is
>only collecting information, not the facts of real happenings which are
>keeping global attention trained on it. (*)
>______________________________________________________
>Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com
>
