If my .forward contains:
  /tmp/test/maildir/
And /tmp/test is owned by another user:
  $ ls -lrtd /tmp/test
  drwxrwx--- 2 root users 6 2009-09-01 19:19 /tmp/test
And I belong to the following groups (notice I belong to users, but my primary group is wheel):
  $ id -n -G
  wheel floppy audio video cdrom fuse plugdev scanner users
And my user id is jonny:
  $ id -n -u
  jonny

Then, when mail is sent to jonny, it bounces, and in /var/mail.log I get:

  Sep  1 19:36:57 (none) postfix/local[5730]: warning: maildir access problem 
for UID/GID=1000/10: create maildir file 
/tmp/test/maildir/tmp/1251859017.P5730.augustine: Permission denied
  Sep  1 19:36:57 (none) postfix/local[5730]: warning: perhaps you need to 
create the maildirs in advance
  Sep  1 19:36:57 (none) postfix/bounce[5738]: 511C3A13D87: sender non-delivery 
notification: 6F8E0A13D89
  Sep  1 19:36:57 (none) postfix/qmgr[5333]: 511C3A13D87: removed
  Sep  1 19:36:57 (none) postfix/local[5730]: 6F8E0A13D89: 
to=<[email protected]>, relay=local, delay=0.1, delays=0.03/0/0/0.06, 
dsn=5.2.0, status=bounced (maildir delivery failed: create maildir file 
/tmp/test/maildir/tmp/1251859017.P5730.augustine: Permission denied)

I think this may be by intention, as I find in set_ugid.c:
/*      set_ugid() sets the real, effective and saved user and group process
/*      attributes and updates the process group access list to be just the
/*      user's primary group. This operation is irreversible.

I worked around the issue by doing:

  $ sudo chown jonny /tmp/test

Having postfix pay attention to all the user's groups would be a nice feature. It is not important for me any longer, now that I understand postfix only uses the primary group id, but it may save some other person some hunting in the future.

Reply via email to