Chris,

We all feel passionately about it, I'm sure. As I mentioned to Gord, we all 
want Logic as well. Hell, every DAW should be accessible for that matter. 
Naturally, Pro Tools has become the first fish to fry. I'll post a separate 
message about Logic. See also my lengthy post about the meeting details.

Cheers,

Slau
Thanks, C
On Nov 14, 2012, at 11:42 AM, Chris Norman wrote:

> Sorry, hit the wrong key there...
> 
> There's obviously things you can't discuss, and that's fine, but as you said, 
> when people don't know the whole truth, they tend to jump to assumptions or 
> whatever, as we have obviously done with suggesting Avid be brought into the 
> loop regarding this bug and so on.
> 
> But, now you've said all that, I'll personally try and be more understanding 
> etc, but please please please, if there's anything we can do, please let us 
> know. I feel strongly about Pro Tools accessibility, and not because I think 
> it's my right as a blind user to be able to use Pro Tools, but because I 
> enjoy working with Pro Tools, and it's a world better than using Garage Band 
> to record with. Maybe if and when logic Accessibility comes along, I'll feel 
> different, Logic certainly looks like a nice piece of software, but I'm sure 
> there'll always be room for PT.
> 
> Anyways, I'll stop rambling now, but stay on it, and remember there's a whole 
> community willing to help in any way we can.
> 
> Look forward to hearing of your progress, and as always, have fun!
> 
> Take care,
> Chris Norman
> <[email protected]>
> 
> 
> 
> On 14 Nov 2012, at 16:27, Slau Halatyn wrote:
> 
>> Members of this list,
>> 
>> I'm writing an open letter to all of you with my concerns and a request. 
>> I've been working on the issue of Pro Tools accessibility for a very long 
>> time. I wasn't involved with the initial progress back in OS 9 but I did 
>> become deeply involved under OS X. I never campaigned for this "position," 
>> for lack of a better word but I took on the role, firstly, for personal 
>> reasons, having wanted to have an accessible platform as an audio engineer 
>> and, secondly, for the sake of many blind musicians who needed a unified 
>> voice representing the immediate concerns for an accessible Pro Tools 
>> platform. I've spent enormous sums of money and countless hours on this 
>> project. I never asked for a dime, mostly because of my personal interest in 
>> the outcome but also because I never wanted to feel like I was beholden to 
>> anybody in any way. There were times, sometimes huge swaths of time, that 
>> often passed with no visible results but I knew it was time well spent 
>> because of the quality of the relationships I've built and the results we've 
>> gotten so far.
>> 
>> I now know what it probably feels like to be a politician. Let me assure you 
>> that it's no stroll in the park. Sometimes, you are not at liberty to 
>> discuss certain details openly for any number of reasons. I have a new 
>> appreciation for executive privilege and classified information. That said, 
>> I've been as open as I could possibly be with both the list and the periodic 
>> updates on the petition site. I also have a new appreciation for how one 
>> cannot satisfy the desires of everyone. I can also appreciate that old 
>> saying about walking a mile in someone's shoes.
>> 
>> Although, as I've said, I've never campaigned for this, I've also fallen 
>> into this situation by default. I never asked for this and I only agreed to 
>> it, at least in my mind, because I honestly felt responsible and I also felt 
>> that I was the right person for the job.
>> 
>> Every so often, it seems, I find the need to defend myself against what I 
>> essentially find to be restlessness on the part of some people. I don't take 
>> it personally because I understand that it comes from a frustration with the 
>> status quo or, more accurately, a perceived lack of progress. I, too, feel 
>> frustrated some of the time and I share many of the concerns of others on 
>> this list. I agree with many ideas and I categorically disagree with other 
>> ideas or at least their implementation and timing. I realize that, when I 
>> happen to disagree with an approach, I probably lose the confidence of those 
>> who see things differently. That's OK. As I said earlier, I accept the fact 
>> that I can't satisfy everybody's wishes—it's impossible. What I do feel that 
>> I have is the support of the majority of our community and I do appreciate 
>> that.
>> 
>> As I stated earlier, I feel like a politician and I don't particularly enjoy 
>> it. My commitment to the issue of Pro Tools accessibility and to this 
>> community are as follows:
>> 
>> I will continue my relationship with several key individuals at Avid in the 
>> interest of ensuring a future for Pro Tools accessibility. There are a 
>> couple of things we're waiting for at the moment that will determine how I 
>> feel we should proceed. Pending that initial outcome, I will make a personal 
>> decision whether to continue the work I've been doing. Even if the outcome 
>> is favorable, I'm not sure that I'll take on any responsibility other than 
>> beta testing, as I've done on and off over the years. If the outcome is less 
>> favorable, I'll offer my suggestions for a path toward a goal but I won't 
>> take on any responsibilities unless an explicit majority of this community 
>> give me mandate to move forward with a plan. To put a timeframe on it, 
>> essentially, I'll probably have some feeling for which way this will likely 
>> go in a few days, maybe a week.
>> 
>> In a separate email, I will discuss some more details of my meeting at Avid. 
>> Please be aware that I won't engage in a debate on the merits of any given 
>> approach. I'm tired of defending and explaining things. Politicians usually 
>> have a staff to handle such things. Please don't occupy my bandwidth with a 
>> whole bunch of suggestions that will require loads of my time to respond to. 
>> This is a public forum and everybody's entitled to express themselves but, 
>> just as I am required not to take things personally, don't take it 
>> personally if I don't engage in a debate about the merits of a particular 
>> approach. I believe what I'm doing is right and that, every step of the way, 
>> I've made good choices.
>> 
>> I have a short session in about a half hour so the email about the meeting 
>> will follow in the afternoon.
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> 
>> Slau
>> 
> 

Reply via email to