The first set of comments concern the Transportation Working Group (TRWG) report - starting with the overview and existing roadway sections. This is will be followed by comments on the two other sections of the TRWG report. I'm starting with these because we have a subconsultant working on the follow-up to the TRWG recommendations.
Comments below are organized according to section headings: Comments re TR overview: The breakdown of Small Group Meeting responses in the overview section among the three Task Partnerships - showing that 54% of the comments related to Existing Roadways, 27% related to New Alternative Corridors, and 19% related to Mass Transit - is a useful way to establish priorities for a transportation strategy. I am a little unclear about whether the priorities identified within the Task Partnerships were based on the Small Group Meeting results or just the views of those who participated in the Task Partnerships. Would you please clarify this? I'm not suggesting that the latter is "bad", only that it may not be as reflective of broad community sentiment as the former. The overview section and the executive summaries of the task partnerships emphasize highway intersection controls (especially the use of roundabouts as an alternative to signalization) and connectivity in the circulation system. These are fundamental needs for improving transportation safety and convenience for all modes of travel, and for providing emergency access and evacuation routes, so the emphasis is appropriate. There are also many recommendations for enhancing multi-modal travel, including transit, bicycling and walking. These are all good objectives, but changes to the land development pattern in Puna - particularly to create walkable "village centers" - will be key to making these ideas a reality. The Land Use Working Group report addresses this issue, and we will be following up with a pilot study of a portion of Hawaiian Paradise Park to look at the feasibility of applying "land pooling" as a method to create village centers within existing, nonconforming subdivisions. Also, between the Puna Regional Circulation Study and the County's recent paratransit study there are already significant proposed initiatives for multi-modal transportation that have yet to be implemented, so it would be good to start with those. Given the above observations, I think it is important for the transportation subconsultant to focus on the core issues of highway intersections, alternative corridors and interconnectivity, which are the priorities identified by both the Small Group Meetings and the Working Group. Also, it seems apparent that this will probably require more than the two community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant. Therefore, to keep within the budget allotted for this consultant, we have revised the scope as follows (with additions underscored and deletions noted in brackets): I. Highway 130 and Puna Makai Alternate Route A. Conduct traffic analyses to recommend: 1. Whether widening Highway 130 from two to four lanes obviates the need for the Puna makai alternate route; 2. If needed, the number of lanes for the Puna makai alternate route and whether the Puna makai alternate route should continue through Hawaiian Paradise Park; 3. Evaluate the need and optimal location for traffic signals and/or roundabouts along Highway 130 to enable turning movements from intersecting streets; 4. If the Puna makai alternate route must traverse Hawaiian Paradise Park, recommend alignment and context-sensitive design. B. Attend at least two public meetings to present findings. II. Highway 11 A. Evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of alternative connectors between Highway 11 and Highway 130 to alleviate congestion going to Keaau High School and Pahoa; B. Recommended mitigation measures to ease existing and future congestion. III. Interconnectivity A. Evaluate existing street network and recommend interconnectivity system and standards. [Multi-modal and commercial center analyses are omitted.] The transportation subconsultant will have additional comments and suggestions on the recommendations contained in the task group reports, but below are my observations and questions on the Existing Roadways section. Comments re TR-ER: INTERSECTION SAFETY Issue #1: Up to 16 intersections are listed as candidates for roundabouts (preferably) or other form of intersection control. That's a lot of locations, and the treatment may vary according to the conditions and opportunities at each intersection. It will probably be necessary to set some priorities among the intersections. Also, it would be necessary to build a strong case for roundabouts on Highway 130 to overcome DOT's resistance to them (see attached letter.) This is a major reason for re-focusing the transportation subconsultant's scope of work. Issue #2: For clarification, was this recommendation meant to refer to the entrance to Nanawale Estates from Highway 132? ROADWAY SAFETY Issue #1: If a vendor is located in a State right-of-way, it's my understanding County zoning officials lack jurisdiction; however, it is probably a violation of the traffic code for State highways, so police officers can issue a summons. I will ask the County to comment on this. ROADWAY DESIGN Issue #1: The recommendations in this section have statewide significance and are not likely to get appropriate attention if included in the CDP. I understand the frustration about lack of access to data, since I have faced this problem myself in working on neighborhood plans. I also agree that more study is needed to identify how hazards associated with roadway design can be mitigated. However, these suggestions need to be raised in another type of forum; namely, the State Legislature. These are ideas that you could bring to your elected State representatives. From an institutional standpoint, I believe Recommendation #1 refers to the State of Hawai'i Department of Health, since there is no County agency with this type of responsibility of title. Issue #2: Do these recommendations refer to public roadways only or to private roadways, as well? If the latter, neither the County nor the State have the legal authority to make these improvements or even mandate that they be made. TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY Recommendations ii and iii: I believe that elsewhere it has been recommended that no new commercial uses be permitted direct access to Highways 11 and 130. Do these recommendations refer to new developments that are using existing access driveways or roads? Would a roadway impact fee system fulfill the intent of these recommendations? TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO ROADWAY DESIGN I'm not sure how these recommendations would work, in practice. At present, the STIP is supposed to be based on County land use plans and is reviewed by the County. What County agency would have this oversight authority, and would it necessarily result in better highway planning? County engineers may be just as resistant to roundabouts as the DOT engineers, for example. ROADSIDE AMENITIES These suggestions would likely need to be part of a statewide highway program, but I believe their implementation in Puna would get very low priority compared to the need for highway intersection improvements and the creation of alternate routes, which have high capital costs. Among these suggestions, I would guess that emergency phones in remote stretches of highway, especially in high hazard areas, would be most likely to get priority. Recommendation ii is missing; was this a typo? Where would the lockable bike racks and pumping stations be located? Why would they be located along the highway instead of, say, in a village center? ROADWAY AESTHETICS DOT has an "Adopt-a-Highway" program for public-private partnerships to beautify highways. Unfortunately, DOT has lagged behind most other states in getting a Scenic Byways program off the ground. Once implemented, this would make designated scenic roadways eligible for aesthetic enhancement funds. What particular stretches of roadways in Puna do you think would be the best candidates for Scenic Byway designation? The Cultural Resources Working Group report contains documentation and recommendations for the Puna Trail Historic Corridor. Would this be the leading candidate? A hui hou, John PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
