---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ----------------------------------------------------
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >The first set of comments concern the >Transportation Working Group (TRWG) report >starting with the overview and existing roadway >sections. This is will be followed by comments >on the two other sections of the TRWG >report. Im starting with these because we have >a subconsultant working on the follow-up to the TRWG recommendations. > >Comments below are organized according to section headings: > >Comments re TR overview: > >The breakdown of Small Group Meeting responses >in the overview section among the three Task >Partnerships showing that 54% of the comments >related to Existing Roadways, 27% related to New >Alternative Corridors, and 19% related to Mass >Transit is a useful way to establish >priorities for a transportation strategy. > >I am a little unclear about whether the >priorities identified within the Task >Partnerships were based on the Small Group >Meeting results or just the views of those who >participated in the Task Partnerships. Would >you please clarify this? Im not suggesting >that the latter is bad, only that it may not >be as reflective of broad community sentiment as the former. . Aloha John W, The priorities identified within the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group (WG) Task Partnerships were based on the following: 1) 680 transportation ideas, which are documented in the "3,394 Ideas from 130 Small Group Meetings" report* 2) previous development plans (including the Puna Regional Circulation Plan) 3) informal and formal consultations with residents of Puna 4) personal experience as residents of Puna References: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: IV. Background: Community Issues, Table 4.1, Page 6 of 47 Section: VI. Previous Development Plans, Table 6.1, Page 8 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-overview.pdf/view Background: At our October 10, 2006 working group meeting, James Weatherford (our coordinator at that time) presented the enclosed rationale (see enclosure) for our working group breaking up into 5 subgroups, which were named task partnerships, as follows: 1. Existing Roads 2. Non-Motorized Modes 3. Mass Transit: Current Services 4. Mass Transit: New Initiatives 5. New Corridors In November 2006, we re-grouped into the current 3 task partnerships by folding the Non-motorized Modes [2] subgroup into the New Corridors Task Partnership [5] and combining the Mass Transit: Current Services [3] and Mass Transit: New Initiatives [4] into one subgroup, i.e. the Mass Transit Task Partnership. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: III. Task Partnership Mission Statements, Page 5 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-overview.pdf/view In November 2006, each of our 3 subgroups was assigned the task of prioritizing the transportation themes within each task partnership (see enclosed), i.e. 367 Existing Roadways ideas; 182 New Alternative Corridors ideas and 131 Mass Transit ideas. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: V. Background: Transportation Issues, Table 5.1, Page 7 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-overview.pdf/view Each of the Puna CDP Transportation WG task partnerships engaged in a formal facilitated process to categorize and prioritize the transportation themes. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: VII. Transportation Task Partnership Themes, Table 7.1, Page 9 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-overview.pdf/view forward! devotion, prema ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Puna CDP Transportation Working Group October 10, 2006 ADOPTED RATIONALE FOR ORGANIZING INTO TASK PARTNERSHIPS Presented by James Weatherford, Puna CDP Transportation WG Coordinator [Oct. 2006 thru Dec. 2007] THEMES (original) o Safer Roads (paved, roundabouts, speed bumps, reflectors) o Alternate Route for Lower Puna o Widening of Highway 130 to 4 lanes o Alternate Route for Lower Puna o More Traffic Lights o Better Public Transportation Systems o Improved Bus Schedule with More Frequent Stops o Availability of Bus Stops/Shelters o Mini Shuttle Service o Availability of Park & Ride Service o More Sidewalks o Safe Bike Lane/Paths and Multi-mode Trails TASK PARTNERSHIPS (proposed) 1. Existing Roads + Upgrade: paving, speed bumps, reflectors, lines + Intersections: turn and merge lanes, roundabouts, signal lights + Highway Capacity (of 11 and 130): width of corridor and number of lanes + Street Lights 2. Non-Motorized Modes + Bicycle + Walking 3. Mass Transit: Current Services + Scheduling: times, routes + Accessibility: bus stops, shelters, information 4. Mass Transit: New Initiatives + Local and Special Services: feeder bus routes, paratransit + High-Capacity Rapid Transit: busway or rail + High Occupancy Vehicles: ride sharing, van pools + Park and Ride: for users of all categories of mass transit 5. New Corridors + Ala Puna Makai: Pahoa to Hilo + Connectivity: links mauka-makai, subdivisions and towns Notes: 1. The need for, and the Countys role in, maintenance, including paving, of roads in private subdivisions, is frequently mentioned. (There are a few mentions that cinder roads in subdivisions should not be paved so as to limit traffic and speeding). 2. Identification of specific issues regarding the need for more lanes, turn lanes, and better intersections, as well as interest in non-motorized transport, are overwhelmingly focused on Highway 130, emphasizing the critical role of this single corridor in mobility for the Puna District. 3. Emergency access on roads and emergency phones is an issue that occurred within comments on upgrade of existing roads, as well as comments about a new corridor in Puna makai and interconnectivity between subdivisions. 4. Decentralization of public and social services, commercial and cultural activities, and employment, so as to reduce the need for longer distance travel, are not considered here. These may be addressed by the Land Use and Economic Opportunity Working Groups. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Puna CDP Transportation Working Group October 15, 2006 TASK PARTNERSHIP METHODOLOGY Presented by James Weatherford, Puna CDP Transportation WG Coordinator [Oct. 2006 thru Dec. 2007] Below are the proposed Task Partnerships, with the original Themes provided by the County in brackets below. Note that points given in Theme #1, Safer Roads, are divided between two different Task Partnerships. The objective was to consolidate the twelve Themes in the working group document into subgroups with commonality, as discussed at the working group meeting October 7. The sources used were: + The transportation section of the on-line document with the 3,394 ideas from 130+ small group meetings; + the spreadsheet, Themes from 130 Small Group Meetings; and + the document distributed at the meeting, Working Group: Transportation" [Guidelines] First, the Task Partnerships (e.g., Existing Roads and New Corridors) were written to provide more uniform physical descriptions, with initiatives that are new and those for current or existing infrastructure in separate tasks.. The original wording for the Themes was a mixture of physical descriptions, actions (e.g., widening) and descriptions of needs (e.g., availability of bus stops.) Second, the points under each of the five Task Partnerships is drawn substantially from the 679 transportation ideas that came directly out of the small group meetings (e.g., connectivity and intersections), as well as from common and practical terminology used in transportation planning (e.g., highway capacity, upgrade, accessibility, feeder routes, and high occupancy vehicles). Third, the 679 transportation ideas from the small group meetings were carefully reviewed and compared with the Preliminary Themes. Some resorting was done based on this review. Notably, among the ideas that had been categorized as Widening of Highway 130 to 4 lanes, almost half proposed turn and merge lanes at intersections. Also, traffic lights and street lights, which serve entirely different purposes, had been grouped together as lights. Finally, there is no prioritization applied. _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
