From: frances stapleton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: March 5, 2007 12:05:26 AM HST
To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <puna-wg-
[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-evaluation] TR overview, TR-ER
Greetings, Mr. Whalen...
In response to your inquiries of March 3, I would like to respond
to the first two paragraphs in your Comments re TR overview:
On Mar 3, 2007, at 2:30 PM, John P. Whalen wrote:
Comments re TR overview:
The breakdown of Small Group Meeting responses in the overview
section among the three Task Partnerships – showing that 54% of
the comments related to Existing Roadways, 27% related to New
Alternative Corridors, and 19% related to Mass Transit – is a
useful way to establish priorities for a transportation strategy.
I am a little unclear about whether the priorities identified
within the Task Partnerships were based on the Small Group Meeting
results or just the views of those who participated in the Task
Partnerships. Would you please clarify this? I’m not suggesting
that the latter is “bad”, only that it may not be as reflective of
broad community sentiment as the former.
We in the Transportation Working Group were very dedicated to
making sure every citizen's recorded input on Transportation
related issues was taken into account. We started with studying
the Small Group Meeting responses but felt other previous studies
and sources of information were also important. So we worked quite
diligently at rounding up, soliciting, summarizing, and
prioritizing comments from every source we could find, including
the commentary found in previously funded County studies.
Re: the Small Group Meetings, we inquired as to the nature of
those meetings and learned that the input from those participants
was not molded or guided or coordinated or discussed in any manner
that would have elicited clearer understanding of precisely what
the individual commentators meant in their comments or followed up
with discussion to allow the Small Group participants to refine
precisely what their desires were. So our WG members reviewed all
the public comments and prioritized them in categories
approximating the Transit Goals and Objectives that were graphed
on Section 7-1 in the November 2005 Puna Regional Circulation
Plan. The prioritizing by the WG took into account the numbers of
times issues were noted in the various public records we reviewed,
including the Small Group Meetings. (We have our charts and work
sheets from those meetings as documentation of this effort.) So we
tried to give as accurate and objective a representation of public
input as we possibly could.
NO PUBLIC OFFICIALS SEEM TO RECOGNIZE OR COMPREHEND HOW MANY
CITIZENS -- RESIDENTS AND VISITORS (and not just poor folk) -- WANT
A TRUE MASS TRANSIT SYSTEM HERE! Additionally, better utilization
of mass transit IMMEDIATELY would alleviate some of the pressure
for immediate solutions to our traffic problems and crowded roads!
...
Also, between the Puna Regional Circulation Study and the
County’s recent paratransit study there are already significant
proposed initiatives for multi-modal transportation that have yet
to be implemented, so it would be good to start with those.
Yes, we agree. But we do not feel those studies stated strongly
enough how necessary it was to COORDINATE this whole effort and an
immediate inventory of exactly how many vehicles, in what
condition, and where they can be accessed for public use needs to
be done as information coming from Mass Transit is given piecemeal
and it's often in the form of politically expedient lip service
with no followup. You will get different figures from our Mass
Transit director every time you ask, and never a true inventory.
Vehicles bought with Mass Transit funds are turned over to private
taxi companies, non-profit organizations, etc. with very little
followup accountability. It's totally hit and miss trying to tap
into Senior transportation services, VanPool or the like. I think
HCEOC alone has as many as 100 taxpayer-funded vans and shuttle
buses but we couldn't get an accounting
For me, one of the biggest revelations of our research into
transportation issues was the discovery that we have a citizens'
advisory Transportation Commission in this county (and I've been a
member of the news media here for 20 years). We were going to
recommend such an advisory board be set up only to learn there is
already one in existence. However, it hasn't been able to
establish a quorum for more than 2 years because there were only 4
appointees to the 9-member board! That should be indicative of how
our Mass Transit system functions here.
Additionally, we were told our reports could and should include
recommendations that had already been stated in other studies if
those issues were still of concern, and to be specific and detailed
in our recommendations. So we did.
I hope this helps you understand better the tack taken by the Mass
Transit subgroup. Thanks for the opportunity to respond. Aloha,
Frankie Stapleton
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation