The following is a response to some of John Whalen's comments and questions on the Natural Resources Working Group Report. I forwarded John's comments to other working group members and hope that they will respond as well.
Response to John's comments on Natural Resources Recommendations C, F & G Comment #1: John asked if the Native Forest Protection Ordinance (NFPO) was "expected to have a broader geographic reach" than the Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zone (BRBZ) and, if so, could the BRBZ become a subset of the NFPO. My Response: The scope of our working group assignment was confined to natural resource issues in the Puna district of Hawai'i County. The NFPO is a recommendation for managing native forest on ALL Puna District land within the County's jurisdiction. However, we also recommend that the County apply the ordinance to other districts, realizing that interim steps may be necessary to achieve countywide application. The NFPO is primarily a regulatory tool for controlling the impact of future development on native forest. The purpose of its educational component is to create a positive environment for enforcement of the ordinance. The NFPO can be adopted by the County through its normal legal process of implementing local ordinances. The BRBZ, on the other hand, requires official recognition of a scientific endeavor, with research and monitoring goals that will require a vastly new approach for the County. Before recognizing the BRBZ, The County may require that the state and federal governments support and promote the concept of the Volcano area as a buffer zone to a federal park. Although the BRBZ would strengthen the NFPO by supporting sustainable development in one of our Puna communities, the BRBZ will likely require involvement of other agencies outside the county's jurisdiction and could hold up implementation of the NFPO. The BRBZ could be incorporated into the NFPO at a later date after the County has officially recognized BRBZ status. Comment #2: John asked how the boundary would be determined for the NFPO. My Response: At an interim stage, the ordinance could be restricted to areas in Puna with large tracts of undeveloped native forest land where less than 50% of the forest has been inundated by strawberry guava and other invasive tree species. The Volcano area would be ideal as one of those areas, both because of its prime forests and because the educational component of the ordinance would be supported by its active environmentalist groups. The ordinance would eventually be applied district-wide, and, hopefully, countywide. The Gap Analysis Project map John mentioned could be used as one tool for selecting interim-stage model communities where the ordinance would first be implemented. COMMENT #3: John suggested "establishing some 'allowed by right' standards in the ordinance rather than relying on case-by-case review for every land clearance permit." He provides Recommendation F as an example, which suggests limitations on land clearance based on lot size, with modifications possible for agricultural use. My Response: The intent of the "checklist" mentioned in the NFPO recommendation ["The County will provide a checklist to developers on factors to be considered (e.g., flood protection, selection of building sites to minimize destruction of native forest; restrictions on clearing of land within building setbacks").] is to do just that: provide a mechanism to assist both landowners and the County in determining how to protect native forest on any given lot. Few specific details were given in the NFPO primarily because those decisions should be made by qualified foresters, and because allowances must be made for the wide variation in individual parcels. For example, many one-acre parcels have ample stands of ohia, kolea, and hapu'u, but only invasive species in their setbacks; therefore, disallowing land-clearing in their setbacks would do nothing to preserve native forest. However, considering the plethora of recommendations from the various working groups on preserving native forest, I welcome John Whalen's efforts to consolidate our proposals and to establish interim steps we might take to implement our plans. I do see the NFPO as an umbrella recommendation, with other, more specific yet compatible recommendations which could be incorporated within it. The objective of preserving native forest is what unifies us all. Bett Bidleman Native Forest coordinator Natural Resources Working Group _____ From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of John P. Whalen Sent: Wednesday, March 21, 2007 4:17 PM To: Puna CDP listserve Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] NR Overall comment: This report contains a lot of useful information and good ideas. The emphasis on public education, partnerships and property owner incentives is a strong point because it recognizes that it will take a lot more than regulatory enforcement to support effective forest management. There are also some evident linkages with recommendations of other WGs. My concern, however, is that some of the recommendations are quite ambitious - e.g., creation of comprehensive plant inventories and forest maps, a new County department, a new advisory council, and new technical staff positions. While these may be desirable long-range goals, it would be useful to think of some interim steps that would be more likely to be implemented in a shorter term. I'm making suggestions along those lines in some of the specific comments below. Recommendations A & B: I assume these recommendations are directed to the Planning Department and the County Council, since they precede the preparation and adoption of the CDP. Recommendations C, F & G: 1. The distinction between the proposed Native Forest Protection Ordinance and the Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zone is unclear to me. I understand that the latter addresses the Volcano area, but is the former expected to have a broader geographic reach? Could the BRBZ be considered a subset of the NFPO? There are good reasons for combining these from an administrative point of view. The boundary of the BRBZ could be delineated in the NFPO and special provisions (if any) pertaining to just that area could be incorporated into ordinance. 2. If the NFPO is larger, how would its boundary be determined? If it depends on the compilation of the inventory and map described in Recommendation F, this could take a long time. Could the Gap Analysis Project map (posted on the website) be used to identify the NFPO boundary? While I'm aware of the limitations of this map (reliance on high-altitude photography with no ground-truthing), it is unlikely that a more comprehensive forest inventory and map will be available for Puna any time soon. 3. I'd also suggest simplifying the administrative process (and enhancing political acceptability) by establishing some "allowed by right" standards in the ordinance rather than relying on case-by-case review for every land clearance permit. It looks like Recommendation F heads that way by suggesting limitations on land clearance based on lot size, with some modifications possible for agricultural uses. Recommendations E & H: These are all good suggestions for partnering and incentives. With respect to H.3, I think it would be more practical to interest the existing Hawai'i Island Land Trust in getting active in Puna rather than establish a new organization. As a veteran of many nonprofits, I am well aware of the challenges that these organizations face, particularly in the start-up period. I highly recommend the Land Trust Alliance (www.lta.org <http://www.lta.org/> ) as a resource on this topic. Recommendation J: TDR is a mechanism that could work for large tracts of land. Because of the prevalence of nonconforming subdivisions, I believe the "land pooling" approach would be more appropriate for Puna. As you know, we will be doing a pilot study in Hawaiian Paradise Park to check this out. Recommendation K: Other WGs have recommended a "Puna Community Council" as well. Are you seeing this as an outgrowth of the Steering Committee, which the Working Groups acting as the "special interest" councils? Recommendation M: I'm not sure that a residency requirement would withstand legal challenge, but it is possible to discourage speculation through tax policies. As one example, the State Legislature has considered surcharges on short-term real estate transactions in previous sessions and is reportedly considering a similar measure this year. Recommendation N: I don't think the creation of a County Natural Resources Department is likely, especially since there are state and federal agencies that are charged with this responsibility. The problem is that these agencies are chronically underfunded. At the County level, there is even greater competition for the allocation of resources from a much more limited tax base, so priority usually goes to the functions that are directly related to public health and safety - police and fire protection, public works, and civil defense. As an alternative, a County Forester position could be created within an existing agency, such as the Planning Department. I would recommend at least two staff people, since it is desirable to have at least some redundancy in a specialty position. PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
