I agree with Bett on all of these responses. Thank you Bett for taking time to really think these out.
I especially agree on comments to comment #3, that it's time to do this through regulation. It would create an economic opportunity too, by establishing a need for certain skilled building site inspectors. I have some of my own comments too, and hope to get them out to all very soon. (over the weekend) Kim --- "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > The following is a response to some of John Whalen's > comments and questions > on the Natural Resources Working Group Report. I > forwarded John's comments > to other working group members and hope that they > will respond as well. > > > > > > Response to John's comments on Natural Resources > Recommendations C, F & G > > > > Comment #1: > > John asked if the Native Forest Protection Ordinance > (NFPO) was "expected to > have a broader geographic reach" than the Biosphere > Reserve Buffer Zone > (BRBZ) and, if so, could the BRBZ become a subset of > the NFPO. > > > > My Response: > > The scope of our working group assignment was > confined to natural resource > issues in the Puna district of Hawai'i County. The > NFPO is a recommendation > for managing native forest on ALL Puna District land > within the County's > jurisdiction. However, we also recommend that the > County apply the > ordinance to other districts, realizing that interim > steps may be necessary > to achieve countywide application. > > > > The NFPO is primarily a regulatory tool for > controlling the impact of future > development on native forest. The purpose of its > educational component is > to create a positive environment for enforcement of > the ordinance. The NFPO > can be adopted by the County through its normal > legal process of > implementing local ordinances. The BRBZ, on the > other hand, requires > official recognition of a scientific endeavor, with > research and monitoring > goals that will require a vastly new approach for > the County. Before > recognizing the BRBZ, The County may require that > the state and federal > governments support and promote the concept of the > Volcano area as a buffer > zone to a federal park. Although the BRBZ would > strengthen the NFPO by > supporting sustainable development in one of our > Puna communities, the BRBZ > will likely require involvement of other agencies > outside the county's > jurisdiction and could hold up implementation of the > NFPO. The BRBZ could > be incorporated into the NFPO at a later date after > the County has > officially recognized BRBZ status. > > > > > > Comment #2: > > John asked how the boundary would be determined for > the NFPO. > > > > My Response: > > At an interim stage, the ordinance could be > restricted to areas in Puna with > large tracts of undeveloped native forest land where > less than 50% of the > forest has been inundated by strawberry guava and > other invasive tree > species. The Volcano area would be ideal as one of > those areas, both > because of its prime forests and because the > educational component of the > ordinance would be supported by its active > environmentalist groups. The > ordinance would eventually be applied district-wide, > and, hopefully, > countywide. The Gap Analysis Project map John > mentioned could be used as > one tool for selecting interim-stage model > communities where the ordinance > would first be implemented. > > > > > > COMMENT #3: John suggested "establishing some > 'allowed by right' standards > in the ordinance rather than relying on case-by-case > review for every land > clearance permit." He provides Recommendation F as > an example, which > suggests limitations on land clearance based on lot > size, with modifications > possible for agricultural use. > > > > My Response: > > The intent of the "checklist" mentioned in the NFPO > recommendation ["The > County will provide a checklist to developers on > factors to be considered > (e.g., flood protection, selection of building sites > to minimize destruction > of native forest; restrictions on clearing of land > within building > setbacks").] is to do just that: provide a mechanism > to assist both > landowners and the County in determining how to > protect native forest on any > given lot. Few specific details were given in the > NFPO primarily because > those decisions should be made by qualified > foresters, and because > allowances must be made for the wide variation in > individual parcels. For > example, many one-acre parcels have ample stands of > ohia, kolea, and hapu'u, > but only invasive species in their setbacks; > therefore, disallowing > land-clearing in their setbacks would do nothing to > preserve native forest. > > > > > However, considering the plethora of recommendations > from the various > working groups on preserving native forest, I > welcome John Whalen's efforts > to consolidate our proposals and to establish > interim steps we might take to > implement our plans. I do see the NFPO as an > umbrella recommendation, with > other, more specific yet compatible recommendations > which could be > incorporated within it. The objective of preserving > native forest is what > unifies us all. > > > > Bett Bidleman > > Native Forest coordinator > > Natural Resources Working Group > > _____ > > ____________________________________________________________________________________ Now that's room service! Choose from over 150,000 hotels in 45,000 destinations on Yahoo! Travel to find your fit. http://farechase.yahoo.com/promo-generic-14795097 _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
