NR Response to comments by John Whalen, 
from Kim Tavares:

>>> re: Overall Comment / Comprehensive plant
inventories – 

You know how people always manage to complain the
loudest about things after the fact?  Here’s one
in-the-making.    I will compare it to the Coqui frog
invasion, for a sense of urgency.

Coqui frogs have been on this island for nearly a
decade.  The number of references to Coqui frogs in
the 3,394 comments is telltale of what people think
about frogs today.  Nobody thought much of them before
the year 2000, but that’s already six years gone.

A comprehensive plant inventory is an extremely
valuable, essential planning tool.  Planning should
not happen in spite of natural resources and the CDP
is a good opportunity to turn that self destructive
practice around.   There should be ordinances in place
today, or as soon as possible, to at least begin to
track land use to the tmk.   Yes there will be lots of
complaining of privacy invasions or the like, but
nobody is out to get anyone for what they do, unless
it’s something stupid anyway, like spontaneous junk
car / appliances dump areas, found throughout the
forest at a rate of at least one per five miles of
road, over 25,000 acres.  

We’re looking for plant community inventories first,
sorting out native habitat from important agriculture.
 There isn’t really much in-between, but there are
extremes on either end.  The best of the best are in
Open Space, and the most developed/disturbed are
urban, commercial and industrial.   Rural lands are
actually residential, and ag lands are actually
residential farms OR vacant, native habitat that has
not been disturbed by grading or grubbing, cattle or
cane, in the past.  Right?  Can’t we just require that
information be provided and confirmed, prior to
grading or grubbing, and start a new database?  We can
all contribute a great deal just from memory, and
before you know it, we’ve got a good idea of the lay
of the land, and new details keep coming up, and we’ve
begun to educate not only ourselves, but everyone who
plans to change the lay of the land in Puna.  That way
there will be no surprises when people in ag-farm or
native forest lands find themselves suddenly with more
development, when they become rural in the state land
use district, via current legislation unless it is
stopped.    The superferry is going to completely
destroy our environment if it is allowed to land
people and personal vehicles, pets, pests, etc. on
this island.  Our economy will not get better, it will
bomb out.  Development will continue to pick up speed.
 We’ll get SNAKES!  The impact on our infrastructure
will be heavily burdened, and I’d guess the ratio of
users to payors (residents) will be something like 3
or 5 to 1.  If people are going to continue to buy
dead trees for Christmas, the trees should be grown on
this island.  If wasps are killing honeybees, we
should stop importing Christmas trees and we should
clamp down on agricultural inspections at EVERY port. 
Until we can fund that, we should not have Superferry.
 So we need that database of what we’ve got, before
it’s gone!

Develop a property description process, and require
its completion and certification, prior to grading or
grubbing.

        Example: Applicant will know everything about their
land, prior to any major changes to it.   Several
contractors (*new economic opportunities*) will likely
be necessary to sign off on a “ready to grade” permit.
1.      Property boundary pins, boundary lines by certified
surveyor
2.      Current land cover types
3.      Current proximity to special management areas,
natural areas, national parks
4.      Location of cultural or hazardous features
5.      Location of largest native trees
6.      Water flow
7.      Current zoning and land use classifications
8.      Current use or if unused, most recent prior use
9.      Desired use / size of specific projects or phases 
10.     Size of development vs size of property
Maybe the short answer to this one is to make all of
Puna an SMA.   Or, at the very least, all parts of
Puna that are now native species habitat, never been
dozed, part of the Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zone.

>>> re:  Recommendations A & B - 

As I said to Land Use / Preserving Land, Air & Water,
the Steering Committee will send a letter to the
County Council for the same purpose, and so these are
currently being addressed.   I will send a draft
letter out to the lits(s) for comments etc., prior to
the next steering meeting where they will decide the
letter will include, when they agree to sign it..   

>>> re:  C, F & G:

1. BRBZ could be a subset of NFPO if there were one,
but since there’s not, then a stand-alone Special
Management Area would be a place to start.  

2. NFPO boundaries?   I think it would be clear, if
the above example land survey requirement is
implemented.  

3. As above, there are interim and long term
solutions.  The example would have an actions flow
chart attached.  Some formula to tell people what the
approved uses are on that land.  It should eventually
be computer generated and people could get the
information online, just by feeding in the data. 
There should be protections from people who might
falsify the data, say claiming they have a pasture
when in fact it’s lava field with native lowland
vegetation.   There are a good deal of aerial and
satellite images available to GIS users and so maybe
the GIS department could use more analysts that could
overlay tmk boundaries and confirm at least to the
data layer date, what was once there.   If the Council
grants a pause in up-zoning or subdividing until this
CDP process is complete and they like it, then we can
eliminate the case by case issue and chart the future
of this district methodically, in a sustainable way.  

re:  Recommendations E & H

Great suggestion.   I will follow up on that
(sometime), but if someone else would like to discuss
it further, please contact me.  It might take me too
long to get to it, and time will be lost!   

re:  Recommendation K

The basic tone across the Puna CDP is that many people
want to feel more involved.  The CDP brought out a lot
of people, but still not everyone.  Communities want
to be recognized for their commitment to whatever area
they are committed to, and in some way, that needs to
be acknowledged by the County.   Councils by
geographic boundary are the most popular, but other
councils are interested in self governance too, such
as the cultural group.   It is really important for
culture and historic preservation too because there is
such a lack of support even though it’s mandated by
the State.  Preventing the protection of cultural or
natural treasures of this district is bad legislation.
   I would rather see it as an outgrowth of the
working groups than the steering committee, but I’m
amenable to the quickest, easiest route or more
discussion.

re:  Recommendation M  

It would be great to explore whether it would hold up
or not.  There should be real good justification when
someone plans to move into and subsequently change the
forest.   I don’t believe that residency prior to
qualification for development is appropriate. 
Residency, the way I see it, is that you do all the
research necessary (as listed in the example above,
and more) so that you know everything about your land
before you develop it.  You know where schools,
hospitals, etc. are, and where new ones are proposed
for the future.  Then you make a commitment to live on
the property for x number of years  (the residency
test) before selling it.  The penalties for selling it
early should be stiff.   People really need to want to
be here, before they change things and then leave. 
It’s destroying all the native forests in Puna at a
rate of about 10% per decade.  Pretty soon there will
be no “new land” to develop, they’ll all have homes on
them, and then people will start thinking about
subdividing and putting a second home on them. 
Another downward spiral we should avoid.

re:  Recommendation N

Okay, I’ll go with the Planning/Forester.  Again, the
suggestion is to compensate where State or Fed
agencies are supposed to be, but are not.   So
whatever works.

Thank you John, All,
Kim










--- "John P. Whalen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> Overall comment:  This report contains a lot of
> useful information and good
> ideas.  The emphasis on public education,
> partnerships and property owner
> incentives is a strong point because it recognizes
> that it will take a lot
> more than regulatory enforcement to support
> effective forest management.
> There are also some evident linkages with
> recommendations of other WGs. My
> concern, however, is that some of the
> recommendations are quite ambitious -
> e.g., creation of comprehensive plant inventories
> and forest maps, a new
> County department, a new advisory council, and new
> technical staff
> positions.  While these may be desirable long-range
> goals, it would be
> useful to think of some interim steps that would be
> more likely to be
> implemented in a shorter term. I'm making
> suggestions along those lines in
> some of the specific comments below. 
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendations A & B:  I assume these
> recommendations are directed to the
> Planning Department and the County Council, since
> they precede the
> preparation and adoption of the CDP.
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendations C, F & G:  
> 
> 1.    The distinction between the proposed Native
> Forest Protection
> Ordinance and the Biosphere Reserve Buffer Zone is
> unclear to me.  I
> understand that the latter addresses the Volcano
> area, but is the former
> expected to have a broader geographic reach?  Could
> the BRBZ be considered a
> subset of the NFPO?  There are good reasons for
> combining these from an
> administrative point of view.  The boundary of the
> BRBZ could be delineated
> in the NFPO and special provisions (if any)
> pertaining to just that area
> could be incorporated into ordinance.  
> 2.    If the NFPO is larger, how would its boundary be
> determined?  If it
> depends on the compilation of the inventory and map
> described in
> Recommendation F, this could take a long time. 
> Could the Gap Analysis
> Project map (posted on the website) be used to
> identify the NFPO boundary?
> While I'm aware of the limitations of this map
> (reliance on high-altitude
> photography with no ground-truthing), it is unlikely
> that a more
> comprehensive forest inventory and map will be
> available for Puna any time
> soon.  
> 3.    I'd also suggest simplifying the administrative
> process (and
> enhancing political acceptability) by establishing
> some "allowed by right"
> standards in the ordinance rather than relying on
> case-by-case review for
> every land clearance permit.  It looks like
> Recommendation F heads that way
> by suggesting limitations on land clearance based on
> lot size, with some
> modifications possible for agricultural uses.   
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendations E & H:  These are all good
> suggestions for partnering and
> incentives.  With respect to H.3, I think it would
> be more practical to
> interest the existing Hawai'i Island Land Trust in
> getting active in Puna
> rather than establish a new organization.  As a
> veteran of many nonprofits,
> I am well aware of the challenges that these
> organizations face,
> particularly in the start-up period.  I highly
> recommend the Land Trust
> Alliance (www.lta.org <http://www.lta.org/> ) as a
> resource on this topic.
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendation J:  TDR is a mechanism that could
> work for large tracts of
> land.  Because of the prevalence of nonconforming
> subdivisions, I believe
> the "land pooling" approach would be more
> appropriate for Puna.  As you
> know, we will be doing a pilot study in Hawaiian
> Paradise Park to check this
> out.
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendation K:  Other WGs have recommended a
> "Puna Community Council" as
> well.  Are you seeing this as an outgrowth of the
> Steering Committee, which
> the Working Groups acting as the "special interest"
> councils?
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendation M:  I'm not sure that a residency
> requirement would withstand
> legal challenge, but it is possible to discourage
> speculation through tax
> policies.  As one example, the State Legislature has
> considered surcharges
> on short-term real estate transactions in previous
> sessions and is
> reportedly considering a similar measure this year. 
> 
>  
> 
> Recommendation N:  I don't think the creation of a
> County Natural Resources
> Department is likely, especially since there are
> state and federal agencies
> that are charged with this responsibility.  The
> problem is that these
> agencies are chronically underfunded.  At the County
> level, there is even
> greater competition for the allocation of resources
> from a much more limited
> tax base, so priority usually goes to the functions
> that are directly
> related to public health and safety - police and
> fire protection, public
> works, and civil defense.  As an alternative, a
> County Forester position
> could be created within an existing agency, such as
> the Planning Department.
> I would recommend at least two staff people, since
> it is desirable to have
> at least some redundancy in a specialty position.
> 
>  
> 
> PlanPacific, Inc.
> 
> 345 Queen Street, Suite 802
> 
> Honolulu, HI 96813
> 
> Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
> 
>  
> 
> > _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
>
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
> 



 
____________________________________________________________________________________
It's here! Your new message!  
Get new email alerts with the free Yahoo! Toolbar.
http://tools.search.yahoo.com/toolbar/features/mail/
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to