Hi All, I think my opinion has been sorely misinterpreted. I support the sunshine law and I am always eager to hear what the public has to say about items on the agenda.
I do not support the proposal to have public testimony prior to and after the item. It goes against council meeting rules and Robert's Rules of Order. No wonder people always say "following county process is challenging because it's a moving target." I have thought about it and only come up with one good reason to have two testimony periods per person and per agenda item. It would be for the person who testifies prior to knowing what the discussion is about. Of course they would want an opportunity to amend what they said the first time. The steering committee, consultants or the county have always been able to call upon attending members for additional testimony, during steering committee discussion period. Changing the testimony period from before to after might be the answer we're all looking for. That way everyone hears the presentation first, and knows what the discussion is about, and provides testimony to that effect. [Another trick would be to provide a written testimony, and make the verbal testimony different if there's more to say that wasn't written down.] Then there could be a questions (Steering/Consultants/County) > answers (Attending Public) period. I fully support more of this, and I would hope that more working group members would attend meetings, to have more perspective. At the beginning of this process people were told to PICK a group, while being promised that they'd have the opportunity to participate in other group issues as well. Many people had interest in more than one group, but most have not reconnected with those issues, since finishing up recommendations reports. We need all those hundred or so people to start attending and participating in these meetings. And each one should bring one person who has not yet been involved. After the "cross examination" Q&A section, we could have a facilitated discussion between everybody. I like the microphone idea, that's brilliant! Then the consultant summarizes and steering committee votes on whether or not they agree with the summary. [Maybe this could be first agenda item for next meeting. The consultant could provide a written summary (one or two pages) that would be posted with the agenda of the next meeting. In this way, the public can comment one additional time, on whatever happened at the last prior meeting.] What do you think? Thanks, Kim --- "Dr. Keola G.A. Downing, Ph.D." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: --------------------------------- Aloha Larry, I am sorry to see that your good concept of having an opportunity at thebeginning and end of each agenda item has not quite yet gained a majorityapproval. I wish you could actually put that item on the agenda toprovide an opportunity for the public to give you their Mana`o concerningthe way in which the steering committee listens to the people ofPuna. You of course know that the Steering Committee is not anelected body and follows rules that perhaps many people do not fullyunderstand. If you are under sunshine as I think you are, everyeffort to insure an opportunity for the public to provide input to theSteering Committee should be followed. I like the ideas that youpresented and hope you can convince the members of the Steering Committeeto give a lot of thought to being open to every opportunity for helpincluding public input. Greg Braun stated it this way: This June 21 SC presentation by John W. on LU/GM is an importantmeeting for potential public as well as LU WG input. As long as themeeting is held to a strict time frame for Agenda items (inc. publictestimony) and we work towards an 8:30PM adjournment I see no problemwith additional public testimony as long as they follow the rules setforth. I have to agree with him that it could do verylittle harm to allow the public and certainly the authors of the WorkingGroup reports an opportunity to offer their supportive testimony whereneeded. I know that your meetings are not the County Council, butif you strive to follow their official way of actions, then you shouldalso insure that meeting notices are sent out 7 days before the meetingsand all of the other things that are done at official meetings undersunshine. I am very hopeful that the members of the SteeringCommittee error on the side of caution so that they don't even give theappearance of trying to hold back on the very important public testimonythat is required for them to fully attend to their duties. Many of us have continued to volunteer our efforts to aid the SteeringCommittee and the County Departments to follow through with thecompletion of the Puna CDP. This is not the right time to isolatethe Steering Committee from any public input offered. When meetings show up flaws in the group memory of the entire CDPprocess, the public can help to keep us on track. If the publictestimony starts to go into outer space, the Steering Committee can helpre-adjust their focus as well. By using time limits, the worst ofthe worst of non-factual or irrelevant testimony only takes aminute. Keep to the rules and we will finish the meetings ontime. If members of the Steering Committee themselves want to hearfrom a member of the public at the meetings, they can ask the chair tooffer them that opportunity. That is done at all official meetings,and gives each member a chance to call upon people with special knowledgeabout a subject or even expert testimony if that is needed. I urge all of the Steering Committee members to remember their outreachresponsibility to the people of Puna. Please do the very best thatyou can. Not everyone can address you by email as I am doing, andif your way of conducting the process of accepting input from the publicis not on the agenda how would someone else have had this opportunity toshare their Mana`o with you? Please accept the good ideas that Larry came up with as to how best toreceive public input at your meetings. If you someday have 30agenda items, adjustments can be made, but today your agenda has only afew items, and the public often wishes to give you feed back as aresponse to new information and testimony which can be brought up at themeetings themselves. That is the nature of public meetings. We will do ourselves a dis-service if there is any reduction to theopportunity for the public to share their input concerning thesedifficult issues that affect the future of every person in Puna. Mahalo, Keola Downing Coordinator New Alternative Corridors Task Partnership Transportation Working Group Puna Community Development Plan > _______________________________________________ > Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list > [email protected] > https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation > =--= From: "Larry Brown" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> View Contact Details View Contact Details Add Mobile Alert To: "'Puna Working Group report evaluation list'" <[email protected]> CC: "'Puna WG Members'" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, [EMAIL PROTECTED], "Self, Amy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Send an Instant Message "Barbara Lively" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Darren Ah Chong" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Eddie Alonzo" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Send an Instant Message "Gregory Braun" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jo Anne Backman" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Jon Olson " <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Kim Tavares" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Martha Lockwood" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Rick Warshauer" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, "Stephanie Bath" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: RE: [Puna-WG-eval] LU-GM: Consultant's Presentation - 21 Jun 2007:Managing Growth Date: Tue, 22 May 2007 08:37:25 -1000 Aloha Kakou, I intend to propose that the SC adopt the following policy for allowing public input at the remaining meetings. 1. Members of the public shall be allowed to testify on agenda matters at the start and at the end of each agenda item (Managing Growth Working Paper is one agenda item) for not more than one (1) minute each time. Up to three (3) minutes of testimony may be accepted upon agreement by the SC Members that it will not adversely impact the ability of the SC to complete its work in a timely manner. Written testimony of any length may be submitted by the public. A written public testimony request form must be completed and submitted to the Chair for pre-agenda item testimony. Requests for post-agenda item testimony shall be by recognition by the Chair/Facilitator of individuals raising their hands. 2. Members of the public wishing to speak during the course of discussion by the SC Members will not be recognized and should not raise their hands or otherwise seek recognition. SC Members, John Whalen and Larry Brown may call upon members of the public to provide additional clarification or to respond to specific questions that they feel an individual has specific knowledge and/or expertise. SC Members Please let me know how you feel about this suggestion regarding public input. I will defer to John W. on whether or not the public should be allowed to add topics to the Working Paper agenda. Personally, I dont think this is a very good idea. This is the time for the Consultant to present his initial findings and recommendations to the SC for their consideration and comment. The public and the WGs have had their initial input opportunities and will have additional opportunities to comment on the combined product of the Consultant and SC. In my opinion, the additions to the WP agenda that are recommended below should not be included in the LU-WP agenda. These are primarily transportation issues, which admittedly have significant relationships to land use policy, that can be just as adequately considered when the SC discusses the TR-WP later this summer. I also suspect that if we attempt a comprehensive analysis of the suggested transportation issues before the completion of Wayne s work it will be very difficult, if not impossible, to address such an extensive agenda topic in one meeting. Mahalo, Larry ____________________________________________________________________________________Choose the right car based on your needs. Check out Yahoo! Autos new Car Finder tool. http://autos.yahoo.com/carfinder/ _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
