-------------------------------------------------------------
Subject was:
Re: [Puna-WG-eval] LU-GM: Consultant's Presentation - 21 Jun 
2007:Managing Growth
-------------------------------------------------------------



>At 10:31 AM 5/22/2007, Kim Tavares wrote:
>
>I guess I don't get "follow up testimony".


Aloha Kim,

I can explain the rationale for "follow-up testimony" by example.

I know that you are a community activist.  You frequently give 
testimony at County Council meetings.  You are good at what you do.

Imagine being given time to testify on a bill or resolution that 
you've never seen.  This is unthinkable because the County Council 
guarantees that all bills and resolutions advance through a process 
by which the public is fully informed.

We are not always fully informed when we arrive at Puna CDP Steering 
Committee meetings.  Sometimes, we don't know what you will be 
discussing until after the public testimony portion of the meeting.

For example, at the last steering committee meeting the consultant 
presented his slide presentation for the FIRST time on the Big 
Island, AFTER public testimony was heard.

Stephanie Bath, Keola Downing and myself knew about the slide 
presentation weeks before the steering committee meeting, however, we 
had no idea about the content of the slide presentation.  When I 
asked if I could review the slide presentation before the 3 public 
meetings, I was told that that would not be possible.

When the slide presentation was presented at the steering committee 
meeting, the Puna CDP Transportation WG Coordinators saw several 
problems, including:

    +  a reference to "Puna Mauaka" which should have been "Puna Makai"

    +  shading of areas of PRCP maps to micromanage coverage of Puna 
transportation issues

    +  references to recommendations from the PRCP and the State DOT, 
while omitting recommendations of the Puna CDP with regards to 
widening Highway 130

Frankie, Keola and I were prevented from further comment on other 
issues, as the steering committee continued to discuss the slide show 
presentation.

At each of the public meetings, the Puna CDP recommendations were not 
fully disclosed.  For example, the "public" was told that the PRCP 
and the State DOT recommend widening Highway 130.  There was no 
mention of what the Puna CDP recommends, in this regard.  For those 
steering committee members who reside in Upper Puna, this may seem 
like a small thing.  However, I can assure you that based on our 
research, the Puna CDP Transportation WG found that the widening of 
Highway 130 is the single most important issue facing residents of 
Lower Puna.

At the Maku`u Farmers Market presentation, for which you were not 
present, the residents of Lower Puna (where you do not reside) were 
frustrated because they already knew what the PRCP and the State DOT 
want.  They were led to believe that the consultant would be 
presenting the recommendations from the Puna CDP.  Even Stephanie had 
to admit to the people who attended the Maku`u Farmers Market 
presentation that she was confused about the purpose of the 
consultant's presentation.

If the County Council treated you like you are advocating treating 
the residents of Puna, I seriously doubt that you would accept 
it.  As an activist, you should empathize with the so-called public.

The so-called "public" has a right to full disclosure of 
information.  If we are restricted to testifying at the beginning of 
your meetings on issues for which we do not have full disclosure, 
then our interests are not being served.

The consultant has presented an outline of what he is going to 
present at your next steering committee meeting.  How can the 
so-called public give testimony when we don't know the details of 
this upcoming presentation?

It was gracious of Larry Brown to offer public testimony at the start 
of each meeting and then after discussion of issues.  If it is a 
burden to do both, then I would suggest a modification.

As I sit here typing, Madam Pele is shaking the ground beneath me (a 
subtle earthquake down here at the bottom of Kahakai Blvd.), 
reminding me just how important the Puna CDP is for the people of 
Puna, who have only one way in and out of Lower Puna.


SUGGESTION:

Allow the public to give testimony AFTER discussion of issues for 
which we are denied full disclosure 7 days prior to the meeting date.


forward!
devotion, prema

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to