-------------------------------------------------------- Subject was: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] LU-GM: Consultant's Presentation - 21 Jun 2007:Managing Growth --------------------------------------------------------
>At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >I do not support the proposal to have public testimony prior to and >after the item. It goes against council meeting rules and Robert's >Rules of Order. No wonder people always say "following county >process is challenging because it's a moving target." Aloha Kim, The difference between how the County Council functions and how the Puna CDP Steering Committee functions is that the County Council provides full disclosure of agenda items 7 days prior to their meetings. As one who frequently testifies at County Council meetings, surely you can appreciate this difference. In the absence of full disclosure, the public should have an opportunity to give testimony AFTER an issue is discussed by the steering committee. Would you consent to eliminating public input at the beginning of your meetings and allowing public input following an issue? >At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >I have thought about it and only come up with one good reason to >have two testimony periods per person and per agenda item. It would >be for the person who testifies prior to knowing what the discussion >is about. Of course they would want an opportunity to amend what >they said the first time. Amendments become necessary when additional information is provided. This is understandable. For example, when we (the public and the steering committee members) arrived at the steering committee meeting NONE of us, including you, had any idea about the content of the slideshow. Since the content of the slideshow related to the issues addressed in the Puna CDP Transportation WG Report, it was obvious to the Transportation WG Coordinators where there were problems with the presentation. If the Transportation WG Coordinators had seen the PowerPoint presentation before the steering committee meeting, we could have commented directly to the consultant. We were not given that privilege, therefore, we attempted to voice our concerns at your meeting. I mean, come on now, what would you do if you the County Council wrote a bill/resolution that you know nothing about, discuss it among themselves and tell you that you are not allowed to speak? >At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >Changing the testimony period from before to after might be the >answer we're all looking for. That way everyone hears the >presentation first, and knows what the discussion is about, and >provides testimony to that effect. I can live with this. >At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >[Another trick would be to provide a written testimony, and make the >verbal testimony different if there's more to say that wasn't written down.] At your last meeting, there was NO way that anyone could have presented written testimony on the consultant's presentation because (1) none of us knew the content of the slideshow and (2) the slideshow was being presented the night (Friday) and day ( Saturday) following the steering Thursday evening steering committee meeting. >At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >Then there could be a questions (Steering/Consultants/County) > >answers (Attending Public) period. > >I fully support more of this, and I would hope that more working >group members would attend meetings, to have more perspective. At >the beginning of this process people were told to PICK a group, >while being promised that they'd have the opportunity to participate >in other group issues as well. Many people had interest in more than >one group, but most have not reconnected with those issues, since >finishing up recommendations reports. We need all those hundred or >so people to start attending and participating in these >meetings. And each one should bring one person who has not yet been >involved. If this is what you want, then I will attempt to get more Puna residents to attend the steering committee meetings. >At 08:26 PM 5/23/2007, Kim Tavares wrote: > >After the "cross examination" Q&A section, we could have a >facilitated discussion between everybody. I like the microphone >idea, that's brilliant! > >Then the consultant summarizes and steering committee votes on >whether or not they agree with the summary. >[Maybe this could be first agenda item for next meeting. The >consultant could provide a written summary (one or two pages) that >would be posted with the agenda of the next meeting. In this way, >the public can comment one additional time, on whatever happened at >the last prior meeting.] > >What do you think? I appreciate you attempting to produce justice. That is all we need and want. Thank you, very much! forward! devotion, prema _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
