Pam-- I asked this question before, and received a helpful response from Dave Reser of LC, that using terms in common usage (see 3.4.1.5) in the 300 $a is allowable.
He forwarded me these examples: 2011311037 (CD-ROM as accompanying material in 300 $e) 2012408410 (DVD-ROM as accompanying material in separate 300$a) 2010615056 (compact discs in 300 $a) 2010450160 (CD as accompanying material-- spoken word in 300$e) Certainly, I would argue that using "1 videodisc" instead of 1 DVD would be less helpful to patrons, as there is more than one type of videodisc out there. (Note--the 338 carrier type would still be videodisc.) b Benjamin Abrahamse Cataloging Coordinator Acquisitions, Metadata and Enterprise Systems MIT Libraries 617-253-7137 From: Resource Description and Access / Resource Description and Access [mailto:RDA-L@listserv.lac-bac.gc.ca] On Behalf Of Pam Withrow Sent: Monday, March 18, 2013 12:53 PM To: RDA-L@listserv.lac-bac.gc.ca Subject: Re: [RDA-L] Corrected DVD sample I have a question about the DVD examples, and would appreciate some clarification, please. The Toolkit states "Record the extent of the resource by giving the number of units and an appropriate term for the type of carrier as listed under 3.3.1.3." Therefore, wouldn't we use "1 videodisc" rather than "1 DVD"? Thank you in advance, Pam On Mon, Mar 18, 2013 at 11:28 AM, Kadri, Carolyn J <ka...@uta.edu<mailto:ka...@uta.edu>> wrote: The link you provided to sample RDA records isn't working for me. When I click it on I get the report "page not found". Any ideas? Carolyn -----Original Message----- From: Resource Description and Access / Resource Description and Access [mailto:RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA<mailto:RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA>] On Behalf Of J. McRee Elrod Sent: Sunday, March 17, 2013 5:08 PM To: RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA<mailto:RDA-L@LISTSERV.LAC-BAC.GC.CA> Subject: [RDA-L] Corrected DVD sample Thanks to the Autocat poster who pointed out the typo in the DLC sample imprint, and the New York branch location of Planet Group. Sometimes it does take a village, and Autocat is one of the best villgages. Sample RDA records may be seen here: http://www.loc.gov/catworkshop/RDA%20training%20materials/SCT%20RDA%20Re... This is a sample DVD record: 007 v $b d $d c $e v $f a $g i $h z $i u 040 ___ $e rda $b eng $c ___ 042 pcc 046 $k 2000 130 0 Meurtre ... Hollywood, l'affaire Phil Spector. $l English. 245 1 0 Guilty of being me : $b the Phil Spector story / $c Planet Group Entertainment with Pierre Antoine Capton, 3E Oeil productions, Panda Films in association with Sarasota Fringe Films LLC ; a documentary by Alex Jordanov. 246 3 0 Phil Spector story 525 France $2 naf 264 1 [United States] : $b Plant Group Entertainment, $c[2011] 264 4 $c c2011 300 1 videodisc (NTSC, 70 min.) : $b DVD video, sound, color ; $c 4 3/4 in. 336 two-dimensional moving image $2 rdacontent 337 video $2 rdamedia 338 videodisc $2 rdacarrier 380 Television program.. 538 All regions. 518 Originally produced in France as a television program in 2009, reedited and released in the United States. 508 Director, Alex Jordanov; reedited by Melissa Matisko; photography, Guillaume Tunzini, Claude Budin-Juteau. 500 Wide screen 1.78:1. 520 "'Guilty of Being Me'tells the story of Phil Spector, legendary creator of "The Wall of Sound", his rise to and prowess in the recording studio, and final demise as the convicted murderer of Lana Clarkson, a Hollywood actress down on her luck, working as a "waitress" at the House of Blues on Sunset Strip. Phil Spector, The District Attorney, The Lead Detective, and others relevant to the killing tell their story. Extensive courtroom coverage follows the first trial from beginning to end."--Planet Group Ent website. The typo "Plant" for Planet is in the sample. [SLC clients would not be very happy with this record. They would expect us to do a Web search rather than guess the place of production, in this case New York although Plante Group is registered in Ireland.] [They would expect a leader, and an 008 with at least the year, language, and country. The would prefer 655 genre divided geographically, to 256 (DLC to the contrary notwithstanding). ] [The would expect both subject and genre headings, and an added entry for the director at least.] 130 0 $aMeurtre ... Hollywood, l'affaire Phil Spector.$lEnglish.* 245 1 0 $aGuilty of being me :$bthe Phil Spector story /$ca documentary by Alex Jordanov. 246 3 0 $aPhil Spector story 264 1 $a[New York, N.Y.] :$bPlanet Group Entertainment,$c[2011] 264 4 $cc2011** 300 1 DVD (70 min.) :$bsound, colour ;$4 3/4 in. 336 $atwo-dimensional moving image$2rdacontent*** 337 $avideo$2rdamedia 338 $avideodisc$2rdacarrier**** 508 $aPlanet Group Entertainment with Pierre Antoine Capton, 3E Oeil productions, Panda Films in association with Sarasota Fringe Films LLC ; director, Alex Jordanov; reedited by Melissa Matisko ; photography, Guillaume Tunzini, Claude Budin-Juteau. 518 $aOriginally produced in France as a television program in 2009, reedited and released in the United States.***** 520 $a"'Guilty of Being Me'tells the story of Phil Spector, legendary creator of "The Wall of Sound", his rise to and prowess in the recording studio, and final demise as the convicted murderer of Lana Clarkson, a Hollywood actress down on her luck, working as a "waitress" at the House of Blues on Sunset Strip. Phil Spector, The District Attorney, The Lead Detective, and others relevant to the killing tell their story. Extensive courtroom coverage follows the first trial from beginning to end."--Planet Group Ent website. 538 $aAll regions; NTSC; Wide screen 1.78:1. 600 10 $aPhil,$d1940$vDrama. 600 10 $aClarkson, Lana$vDrama. 650 0 $aSound recording executives and producers$vDrama. 655 0 $aDocumentary televisions programs$zFrance. 700 1 $aJordanov, Alex. [*If they do not own the French, they would want this as: 264 1 $iOriginal title:$aMeurtre ... Hollywood, l'affaire Phil Spector.] [** They would not want 264 4 if the same year as 264 1.] [***Some would prefer: 336 $aimage (moving)$2isbdcontent, as shorter and better for display.] [****Since "videodisc" is here, repeating it in 300 is redundant, if there is a more specific unit name available.] [*****The now obsolete 503 had as deffinition cloer to this usage than 518.] __ __ J. McRee (Mac) Elrod (m...@slc.bc.ca<mailto:m...@slc.bc.ca>) {__ | / Special Libraries Cataloguing HTTP://www.slc.bc.ca/ ___} |__ \__________________________________________________________ -- Pamela Withrow, MLIS Cataloger Perma-Bound 217-291-1144
