Bret Hughes said: > > > On Sat, Jan 19, 2002 at 09:09:08AM -0500, Bob Staaf wrote: > > > > AOL/Time Warner buying Red Hat might be great for those who use Linux as a > > > > Desktop workstation but, anyone actually believe they care about competing > > > > in the server market? > > > > > > As a professional in the field, I'm afraid if that happens I'll not > > > only switch myself, I'll actively recommend against the "new" Redhat to > > > my clients. They're just the wrong player in this field. > > > > Here here! > > I'm not against making Linux a more popular alternative but AOL? Jeeez! > > - -- > > > I have never really USED another linux distro. I have installed and > dinked with several. Here are a couple of almost random (meaning not > really thought out) thoughts. > > Several years ago I was at the Linux Expo in Raleigh right after AOL > bought/bailed out Netscape. ( Does anyone think there would be a > netscpae if AOL had not stepped in?). One of the speakers at the expo > was the chief technology officer from netscape and a new AOL employee. > He said one thing that really made me think. I will paraphrase: > > " We have all laughed at AOL's technology and assumed that it was > substandard. Those of use who have run networks with thousands of users > think we are pretty good. Now consider running a network with 15 millon > simultaneous users world wide. Makes you think? AOL has this every day > of every week. These guys know what the are doing." > > It did make me think. I thought the work managment system I worked on > at a meduim sized utility that supported ~1500 users that was integrated > across os2, win 95, and HPUX, all talking to a faily good sized DB2 data > base on MVS through CICS and in turn talked to the inventory management, > customer service, time reporting, and property accounting systems was a > pretty big deal. It was. Now take that and increase it by 4 orders of > magnitude. Not four times butadd four zeros. Holy shit! Maybe those > guys do know what is going on.
While AOL is wildly successful, and I'm certain they know what they're doing, it still doesn't obliterate the means by which they became successful. Sure, Netscape may not exist if not for the buyout by AOL (something we'll never know for certain), but they haven't exactly been a great enhancement to Netscape's survival either. The only thing they did right, and the likely eventuality even if they hadn't bought Netscape, is that the source was opened to people that wanted to work on it. AOL hasn't contributed anything more than name since Netscape was absorbed. As I pointed out in another email, AOL became successful in a similar manner to a Washington state entity: by going for the low-end user (speaking of computer knowledge, not intellect). They didn't try to make a better product, they tried to make an easier product. They sold doodads, gizmos, eyecandy and convenience, not stability and configurability. The fear I have is that the same attitude will prevail if they enter the linux market. While I'm not going to predict that this _will_ happen, I still see a likelihood of that very thing. > Now I know that the end user of AOL is not the (current) typical linux > user, Red Hat or otherwise, but they were tageting an entirely different > market. That is a business model issue not a technical one. In fact I > think building a system that even the most braindead computer illiterate > user can sucessfully operate indicates a level of expertise that is way > beyond the norm. An AOL with all the resources it has to bear, buying a > big distro could be the best thing that ever happened to linux if the > goal is to get drivers that work on lots of hardware. After all they > have a vested interest in making it work on as many machines as > possible. They went after a different market. OK, since this contest will eventually boil down to numbers of users, because that is what will help determine the future directions of things, in what manner are they likely to proceed to raise the numbers? The easiest and fastest method is to make linux easier (not a bad idea in itself) and remove the mystique that many non-users believe surrounds linux. Using only the past few years as a guage to attempt to determine how they'll go about this, it's easy to reach the conclusion that they'll have to advertise it steadily (growing the market), and keep repeating over and over how easy it is to use. If they don't do that, and most people are already accustomed to windoze being easy (even if brain-dead), why would anybody want to switch? I'm convinced that if they want to really make a go of linux, they'll dumb things down in order to expand the market and continue claiming a larger and larger share for themselves. The alternative is to allow the market to continue as it has with little gain for themselves (and a scenario that is unlikely to make investors too happy). This couldn't/wouldn't happen right away. It would be over a period of months and/or years. But I can certainly seeing that happening. The only third way I can see is if they let Redhat whither away as they've done with Netscape (Netscape is now Mozilla, a contender in the linux market, but not a serious threat to anything in the windoze world, and little more than a splash in the MAC world; in essence Netscape is now dead and they just haven't gotten around to burying it). > Red Hat hs some really sharp folks and a demonstrated ability to bring a > good product to market using a constantly changing codebase. I would > make sense for AOL to try and purchase that expertise if they are > wanting to go after a non windows desktop for the masses. I agree that it would make good sense. Investors don't mind waiting a bit to see some results. But they aren't going to wait too long. And if they perceive a drain caused by linux, even if the perception isn't reality, the pressure will turn against what is a rational idea, or what _appears_ to be the weakest link in their eyes. Yes, the talent at RedHat is enormous. It wouldn't be the first time enormous talent was lost due to poor management or bad management decisions. > Steve Case and our friend Bill are not exactly best of friends you > know. Add to that AOLs relationship with Sun ( Sun bought the Netscape > server stuff IIRC) and you might have a force that could actually > compete with Microsoft for the desktop in a big way. Absolutely possible that AOL could actually do something smart in the end. I certainly hope that's the case. I hope any of the possible doom and gloom scenarios I envision are only unnessary worrying. But it still comes down to investors and what they'll take. They're going to want to see growth. AOL doesn't have the linux experience to produce that. RedHat has the experience, but are they going to be able to produce results fast enough? What about micromanagers? They exist everywhere, and you can count on there being several trying to shape linux in their own image before the ink, if any, is dry. If the intermediate executives can sell an idea as being better for producing higher and faster profits, which idea do think investors and planners are going to go with? I'll tell you which I think: they'll go with what increases the bottom line the fastest. They'll be willing to sell off or kill anything that they believe is not producing or is actually hurting that bottom line. I wouldn't go so far as to claim Steve Case is a friend. Maybe he's less of an enemy than the other guy. But I don't for a second believe he's a friend. > Of course there are many things that could go wrong, or rather, must go > right, in order for this to be a really GOOD THING for the current RHL > user but there are after all other disrtos that will benefit from at > least some of the work that AOL might do. > > >From Red Hat management standpoint lets remember that the primary > purpose of a corporation is to increase the wealth of its stockholders. > We do, after all, live in a capitalist economy and if I were a RH > stockholder I would be giddy right now at even hearing these kinds of > rumours. And no, I do not believe that because it is on the web it must > be true :) Sure, watch the value of your own stock holdings increase. Once they are absorbed (if it happens) it won't be RH stock any more, it'll be AOL stock. Then the interests start looking a little different. As a stockholder I want the value of my stock to increase. If I see this as an overall negative, I'd be wise to wait it out, get my stock increase, then sell it at a profit instead of waiting to see it fall back again. Even if I don't seel it, my interests go from watching AOL linux get bigger to watching AOL get bigger, with or without linux as part of the company. I'll still be here in a few months. If this happens, any negative effect (if any happens at all) won't be felt for some time. And I, for one, hope I'm absolutely wrong. I've tried others and none of the ones that would actually install for me felt quite right. But I have to stay with linux. I would never consider a windowized linux to be linux at all. Oh well, I doubt I can come up with more or better reasons to be concerned. I'll let the thread die as far as I'm concerned and worry about it all later. _______________________________________________ Redhat-list mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/redhat-list
