[DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
Hello, Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under the respective JIRA ticket. For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email notification usually appear messy. Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. Finally, the PR notification is also going to comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list will get the same notification three times. Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely prefer those from notificati...@github.com. How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming from GitHub PRs? For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on our inboxes. Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 Best, Stamatis
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
Hi Stamatis, +1000 on this, thanks for starting this discussion! Best regards, Alessandro On Wed 19 Apr 2023, 10:19 Stamatis Zampetakis, wrote: > Hello, > > Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > the respective JIRA ticket. > For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > notification usually appear messy. > > Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > > Finally, the PR notification is also going to > comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > will get the same notification three times. > > Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > > How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > from GitHub PRs? > > For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > our inboxes. > > Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > > Best, > Stamatis >
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
+1 for this. Also noticed this and found it to be annoying. On 19/04/2023 6:22 pm, Alessandro Solimando wrote: Hi Stamatis, +1000 on this, thanks for starting this discussion! Best regards, Alessandro On Wed 19 Apr 2023, 10:19 Stamatis Zampetakis, wrote: Hello, Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under the respective JIRA ticket. For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email notification usually appear messy. Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. Finally, the PR notification is also going to comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list will get the same notification three times. Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely prefer those from notificati...@github.com. How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming from GitHub PRs? For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on our inboxes. Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 Best, Stamatis
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
+1 On Wed, Apr 19, 2023 at 9:33 AM Francis Chuang wrote: > +1 for this. > > Also noticed this and found it to be annoying. > > On 19/04/2023 6:22 pm, Alessandro Solimando wrote: > > Hi Stamatis, > > +1000 on this, thanks for starting this discussion! > > > > Best regards, > > Alessandro > > > > On Wed 19 Apr 2023, 10:19 Stamatis Zampetakis, > wrote: > > > >> Hello, > >> > >> Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > >> the respective JIRA ticket. > >> For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > >> when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > >> notification usually appear messy. > >> > >> Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > >> notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > >> with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > >> > >> Finally, the PR notification is also going to > >> comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > >> will get the same notification three times. > >> > >> Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > >> prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > >> > >> How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > >> from GitHub PRs? > >> > >> For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > >> don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > >> contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > >> our inboxes. > >> > >> Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > >> https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > >> > >> Best, > >> Stamatis > >> > > >
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
+1 from me as well On Wed, Apr 19, 2023, 04:19 Stamatis Zampetakis wrote: > Hello, > > Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > the respective JIRA ticket. > For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > notification usually appear messy. > > Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > > Finally, the PR notification is also going to > comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > will get the same notification three times. > > Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > > How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > from GitHub PRs? > > For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > our inboxes. > > Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > > Best, > Stamatis >
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
+1, One thing that may affect current workflow is sometimes I only watch the Jira, and will get notified from the PR notification. If we are going to disable it, I need to watch the PR too to get the notification for cases that I'm interested in both the Jira discussion and PR comments. But that won't be a big problem for me. Michael Mior 于2023年4月19日周三 18:43写道： > +1 from me as well > > On Wed, Apr 19, 2023, 04:19 Stamatis Zampetakis wrote: > > > Hello, > > > > Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > > the respective JIRA ticket. > > For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > > when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > > notification usually appear messy. > > > > Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > > notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > > with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > > > > Finally, the PR notification is also going to > > comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > > will get the same notification three times. > > > > Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > > prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > > > > How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > > from GitHub PRs? > > > > For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > > don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > > contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > > our inboxes. > > > > Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > > https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > > > > Best, > > Stamatis > > > -- Best, Benchao Li
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
+1, it would reduce a lot of noise. Best, Dan Zou > 2023年4月19日 19:37，Benchao Li 写道： > > +1, > > One thing that may affect current workflow is sometimes I only watch the > Jira, and will get notified from the PR notification. If we are going to > disable it, I need to watch the PR too to get the notification for cases > that I'm interested in both the Jira discussion and PR comments. But that > won't be a big problem for me. > > Michael Mior 于2023年4月19日周三 18:43写道： > >> +1 from me as well >> >> On Wed, Apr 19, 2023, 04:19 Stamatis Zampetakis wrote: >> >>> Hello, >>> >>> Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under >>> the respective JIRA ticket. >>> For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org >>> when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email >>> notification usually appear messy. >>> >>> Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a >>> notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content >>> with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. >>> >>> Finally, the PR notification is also going to >>> comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list >>> will get the same notification three times. >>> >>> Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely >>> prefer those from notificati...@github.com. >>> >>> How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming >>> from GitHub PRs? >>> >>> For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we >>> don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the >>> contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on >>> our inboxes. >>> >>> Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: >>> https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 >>> >>> Best, >>> Stamatis >>> >> > > > -- > > Best, > Benchao Li
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
Thanks everyone for the feedback. The change is now merged! On Wed, Apr 19, 2023 at 4:59 PM Dan Zou wrote: > > +1, it would reduce a lot of noise. > > Best, > Dan Zou > > > > > > > 2023年4月19日 19:37，Benchao Li 写道： > > > > +1, > > > > One thing that may affect current workflow is sometimes I only watch the > > Jira, and will get notified from the PR notification. If we are going to > > disable it, I need to watch the PR too to get the notification for cases > > that I'm interested in both the Jira discussion and PR comments. But that > > won't be a big problem for me. > > > > Michael Mior 于2023年4月19日周三 18:43写道： > > > >> +1 from me as well > >> > >> On Wed, Apr 19, 2023, 04:19 Stamatis Zampetakis wrote: > >> > >>> Hello, > >>> > >>> Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > >>> the respective JIRA ticket. > >>> For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > >>> when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > >>> notification usually appear messy. > >>> > >>> Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > >>> notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > >>> with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > >>> > >>> Finally, the PR notification is also going to > >>> comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > >>> will get the same notification three times. > >>> > >>> Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > >>> prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > >>> > >>> How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > >>> from GitHub PRs? > >>> > >>> For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > >>> don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > >>> contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > >>> our inboxes. > >>> > >>> Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > >>> https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > >>> > >>> Best, > >>> Stamatis > >>> > >> > > > > > > -- > > > > Best, > > Benchao Li >
Re: [DISCUSS] Disable JIRA worklog for GitHub PRs
I noticed that calcite-avatica repo still sends the worklog comments, and I opened a PR[1] to disable it. [1] https://github.com/apache/calcite-avatica/pull/240 Stamatis Zampetakis 于2023年4月21日周五 17:18写道： > > Thanks everyone for the feedback. The change is now merged! > > On Wed, Apr 19, 2023 at 4:59 PM Dan Zou wrote: > > > > +1, it would reduce a lot of noise. > > > > Best, > > Dan Zou > > > > > > > > > > > > > 2023年4月19日 19:37，Benchao Li 写道： > > > > > > +1, > > > > > > One thing that may affect current workflow is sometimes I only watch the > > > Jira, and will get notified from the PR notification. If we are going to > > > disable it, I need to watch the PR too to get the notification for cases > > > that I'm interested in both the Jira discussion and PR comments. But that > > > won't be a big problem for me. > > > > > > Michael Mior 于2023年4月19日周三 18:43写道： > > > > > >> +1 from me as well > > >> > > >> On Wed, Apr 19, 2023, 04:19 Stamatis Zampetakis > > >> wrote: > > >> > > >>> Hello, > > >>> > > >>> Everything that happens in a GitHub PR creates a worklog entry under > > >>> the respective JIRA ticket. > > >>> For every worklog entry we receive a notification from j...@apache.org > > >>> when we are watching an issue. The worklog entry and email > > >>> notification usually appear messy. > > >>> > > >>> Moreover, if we are watching the GitHub PR we are going to get a > > >>> notification from notificati...@github.com which has the same content > > >>> with the JIRA worklog entry and is much more readable. > > >>> > > >>> Finally, the PR notification is also going to > > >>> comm...@calcite.apache.org so those who are subscribed to that list > > >>> will get the same notification three times. > > >>> > > >>> Personally, I never read the JIRA worklog notifications and I largely > > >>> prefer those from notificati...@github.com. > > >>> > > >>> How do you feel about disabling the worklog entries in JIRA coming > > >>> from GitHub PRs? > > >>> > > >>> For archiving purposes, the notifications already go to commits@ so we > > >>> don't lose anything from disabling the worklog entries. On the > > >>> contrary, I find that this would reduce the noise and redundancy on > > >>> our inboxes. > > >>> > > >>> Concretely this is what I have in mind in terms of change: > > >>> https://github.com/apache/calcite/pull/3166 > > >>> > > >>> Best, > > >>> Stamatis > > >>> > > >> > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > > Best, > > > Benchao Li > > -- Best, Benchao Li
