Re: [Repeater-Builder] coordination question for the seasoned owners
Does your coordinator have the access info to try it for themselves? What are they basing the decoordination on? Not on the air? Joe M. Coy Hilton wrote: > > HI Gang > I have had one of my 2 meter repeaters coordinated as a closed > repeater for at least two years. Three times last year I was sent a > email asking if the repeater was on the air and three times I > answered "yes" each time. I had even had a on going discussion about > having multiple transmitters on the same pair coordinated. I was never > asked to prove the repeater existed or even to "prove it" in any other > way. They are trying to de-coordinate me on this pair using this > reason. when it has been coordinated as a CLOSED machine for 2 years. > > My question to you is have any of you guys have ever heard of having a > repeater coordination recinded because of this. I know that the FCC > rules say that Closed repeaters are allowed and the coordinators will > allow coordinating a repeater as closed. I'm looking for further > replies or suggestions as how to handle this. > > The local director and vice-director are actually the ones behind this. > > > > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > >
Re: [Repeater-Builder] coordination question for the seasoned owners
In congested areas this is going to be a fact of life. All your coordinator wants probably is a quick on air demo. Is the guy local? He should already know the PL tones etc. Coy Hilton wrote: > > > HI Gang > I have had one of my 2 meter repeaters coordinated as a closed > repeater for at least two years. Three times last year I was sent a > email asking if the repeater was on the air and three times I > answered "yes" each time. I had even had a on going discussion about > having multiple transmitters on the same pair coordinated. I was never > asked to prove the repeater existed or even to "prove it" in any other > way. They are trying to de-coordinate me on this pair using this > reason. when it has been coordinated as a CLOSED machine for 2 years. > > My question to you is have any of you guys have ever heard of having a > repeater coordination recinded because of this. I know that the FCC > rules say that Closed repeaters are allowed and the coordinators will > allow coordinating a repeater as closed. I'm looking for further > replies or suggestions as how to handle this. > > The local director and vice-director are actually the ones behind this. > -- Jay Urish W5GM ARRL Life MemberDenton County ARRL VEC N5ERS VP/Trustee Monitoring 444.850 PL-88.5
[Repeater-Builder] coordination question for the seasoned owners
HI Gang I have had one of my 2 meter repeaters coordinated as a closed repeater for at least two years. Three times last year I was sent a email asking if the repeater was on the air and three times I answered "yes" each time. I had even had a on going discussion about having multiple transmitters on the same pair coordinated. I was never asked to prove the repeater existed or even to "prove it" in any other way. They are trying to de-coordinate me on this pair using this reason. when it has been coordinated as a CLOSED machine for 2 years. My question to you is have any of you guys have ever heard of having a repeater coordination recinded because of this. I know that the FCC rules say that Closed repeaters are allowed and the coordinators will allow coordinating a repeater as closed. I'm looking for further replies or suggestions as how to handle this. The local director and vice-director are actually the ones behind this.
