[Talk-GB] A way of getting more footpaths done? - tagged track segments

2011-02-15 Thread Nick Whitelegg
Some of the comments on the Android apps thread over on talk got me thinking 
about approaches to try and get more of the UK rights of way network done, 
particularly by contributors who may not wish to use a full scale editor.

Was thinking of a two stage approach, involving a relatively non techie 
person with a smartphone app, and an expert OSM editor with a JOSM plugin. It 
could work something like this. Someone could go out for a walk, fire up a 
smartphone app, and each time they start walking along a new right of way, 
select the right of way type using a simple interface. Their route would be 
recorded as a GPX track, and each time they change the current right of way 
type, a new trkseg is created, tagged with the right of way type. On 
completing their walk they could upload this track to a server.

Then, an expert OSM editor could do the actual data editing, using a JOSM 
plugin which downloads these tagged GPX tracks and renders each trkseg in a 
different colour depending on the right of way represented by that trkseg. 
Expert editors willing to be part of this system could subscribe to an RSS feed 
of new GPX uploads in their area.

Any feelings on this?

Nick

___
Talk-GB mailing list
Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb


Re: [Talk-GB] A way of getting more footpaths done? - tagged track segments

2011-02-15 Thread SomeoneElse

On 15/02/2011 20:28, Nick Whitelegg wrote:


Any feelings on this?

First things first, more GPS tracks are definitely useful, even if 
there's no other information recorded.  For example, if I've walked from 
A to B and recorded one GPS track, and no-one else has been there (which 
is true a lot of the time) then anything that I plot is going to be 
iffy.  More traces automatically uploaded (to somewhere, somehow) from 
more people would be really useful.


However, even when you've only recently been somewhere it's sometimes 
difficult to decide how to record something properly (i.e. 
footway/bridleway/cycleway/path vs track, surface, etc.).  Obviously any 
extra information is useful to add to yours if you've been there, but 
I'm not sure that I'd want to add data for places that I hadn't been to 
based on someone else's track recording.


Besides (notwithstanding the rubbish weather of the last couple of days) 
the nights are getting lighter and I don't fancy spending more time in 
front of a keyboard than I need to!


Cheers,
Andy

___
Talk-GB mailing list
Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb