Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-20 Thread Bob Friesenhahn
On Sat, 20 Mar 2010, Eric Andersen wrote: 2. Taking into account the above, it's a great deal easier on the pocket book to expand two drives at a time instead of four at a time. As bigger drives are always getting cheaper, I feel that I have a lot more flexibility with mirrors when it comes

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-20 Thread Eric Andersen
I went through this determination when setting up my pool. I decided to go with mirrors instead of raidz2 after considering the following: 1. Drive capacity in my box. At most, I can realistically cram 10 drives in my box and I am not interested in expanding outside of the box. I could go w

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread Edward Ned Harvey
> A pool with a 4-wide raidz2 is a completely nonsensical idea. It has > the same amount of accessible storage as two striped mirrors. And would > be slower in terms of IOPS, and be harder to upgrade in the future > (you'd need to keep adding four drives for every expansion with raidz2 > - with mir

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread Edward Ned Harvey
> I have noted there is now raidz2 and been thinking witch woul be > better. > A pool with 2 mirrors or one pool with 4 disks raidz2 If you use raidz2, made of 4 disks, you will have usable capacity of 2 disks, and you can tolerate any 2 disks failing. If you use 2 mirrors, you will have a total

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread David Dyer-Bennet
On Fri, March 19, 2010 02:28, homerun wrote: > Greetings > > I would like to get your recommendation how setup new pool. > > I have 4 new 1.5TB disks reserved to new zpool. > I planned to crow/replace existing small 4 disks ( raidz ) setup with new > bigger one. > > As new pool will be bigger and

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread homerun
Thanks !! I will go to raidz2 , seems to be best choise for me.. Data fault tolerance vs amont of space suite for me. Thanks all !!! -- This message posted from opensolaris.org ___ zfs-discuss mailing list zfs-discuss@opensolaris.org http://mail.openso

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread Daniel Carosone
On Fri, Mar 19, 2010 at 12:59:39AM -0700, homerun wrote: > Thanks for comments > > So possible choises are : > > 1) 2 2-way mirros > 2) 4 disks raidz2 > > BTW , can raidz have spare ? so is there one posible choise more : > 3 disks raidz with 1 spare ? raidz2 is basically this, with a pre-silve

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread homerun
Thanks for comments So possible choises are : 1) 2 2-way mirros 2) 4 disks raidz2 BTW , can raidz have spare ? so is there one posible choise more : 3 disks raidz with 1 spare ? Here i prefer data availibility not performance. And if need sometime to expand / change setup it is then that time p

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread Daniel Carosone
On Fri, Mar 19, 2010 at 06:34:50PM +1100, taemun wrote: > A pool with a 4-wide raidz2 is a completely nonsensical idea. No, it's not - not completely. > It has the same amount of accessible storage as two striped mirrors. And > would be slower in terms of IOPS, and be harder to upgrade in the fu

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread Edho P Arief
On Fri, Mar 19, 2010 at 2:34 PM, taemun wrote: > A pool with a 4-wide raidz2 is a completely nonsensical idea. It has the > same amount of accessible storage as two striped mirrors. And would be > slower in terms of IOPS, and be harder to upgrade in the future (you'd need > to keep adding four dri

Re: [zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread taemun
A pool with a 4-wide raidz2 is a completely nonsensical idea. It has the same amount of accessible storage as two striped mirrors. And would be slower in terms of IOPS, and be harder to upgrade in the future (you'd need to keep adding four drives for every expansion with raidz2 - with mirrors you o

[zfs-discuss] Q : recommendations for zpool configuration

2010-03-19 Thread homerun
Greetings I would like to get your recommendation how setup new pool. I have 4 new 1.5TB disks reserved to new zpool. I planned to crow/replace existing small 4 disks ( raidz ) setup with new bigger one. As new pool will be bigger and will have more personally important data to be stored long