Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-04 Thread sriramvr_in
too insane and silly, boorish email to respond. you can move out of 
this forum if u want to. you need not comment on my credentials. I 
am one of the oldest members of the forum and responding to such 
inane emails from a newcomer doesnot make sense for me. silence is 
serene.



--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, $ Pavan Kumar $ 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 
group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any 
probs..Coz..once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping 
up..saying these kind of things..you are not new..so..dont feel 
lonely..
  
 But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If 
you expect perfection everytime..then the problem is with 
you..Rahman is under no obligation to make you happy or satisfy 
you..If you can take what he gives, accept it..or else..just move 
on..nobody is forcing you to hear his music..Hope..you follow the so 
called perfection in your life too..I am happy to have come across 
someone as perfect as you...
  
 Wah..guys...just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, 
yuvraaj release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...
  
 1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
 2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
 3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..
  
 Its going to be really tough..
 
 --- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
 From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
 To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people 
get 
 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 
songs 
 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
 everytime. 
 
 --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad 
naveenjn@ . 
 wrote:
 
  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but 
it
  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are 
rocking 
 and sadly
  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
 album like
  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
 enjoyable.
  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
 you like
  and don't listen to the rest.
  
  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
 prime then.
  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
 fluke. Today
  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
 anything to
  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
 kind. Let us
  live with it.
  
  Naveen
  
  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
 wrote:
  
   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
  
   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
 90's. the
   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
 could
   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
   completely missing. atrocious music.
  
   
  
 





Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-02 Thread parichay bhattacharya
I jus really dont understand that how come tags like his 90's touch, his 90's 
music, his magic of 90's can be associated with Rahman sir? Can some one talk 
sense?
Rahman sir has been special from his first musical venture till datethere 
cannot b any second thoughts to it

--- On Thu, 2/10/08, Jahanzeb Farooq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: Jahanzeb Farooq [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, 2 October, 2008, 3:29 AM











completely agree about the end three points!



--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ ... 

wrote:



 You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 

group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any 

probs..Coz.. once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping 

up..saying these kind of things..you are not new..so..dont feel 

lonely..

  

 But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you 

expect perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is 

under no obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take 

what he gives, accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you 

to hear his music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your 

life too..I am happy to have come across someone as perfect as you...

  

 Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, 

yuvraaj release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...

  

 1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.

 2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil

 3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..

  

 Its going to be really tough..

 

 --- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... wrote:

 

 From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ...

 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..

 To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com

 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM

 

 

 

 

 

 

 ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 

 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 

 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 

 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 

 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 

 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 

 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 

 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 

 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 

 everytime. 

 

 --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad naveenjn@ 

. 

 wrote:

 

  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it

  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 

 and sadly

  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 

 album like

  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 

 enjoyable.

  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 

 you like

  and don't listen to the rest.

  

  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 

 prime then.

  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 

 fluke. Today

  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 

 anything to

  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 

 kind. Let us

  live with it.

  

  Naveen

  

  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 

 wrote:

  

   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

  

   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 

 90's. the

   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is

   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 

 could

   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is

   completely missing. atrocious music.

  

   

  

 






  




 

















  Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to 
http://messenger.yahoo.com/invite/

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Naveen Naushad
Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking and sadly
that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an album like
Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is enjoyable.
Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs you like
and don't listen to the rest.

And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his prime then.
Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no fluke. Today
he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove anything to
anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured kind. Let us
live with it.

Naveen

On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
 completely missing. atrocious music.

  



Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Karthikeyan Rajendran
Are you kidding?

--- On Tue, 9/30/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Tuesday, September 30, 2008, 11:22 PM






has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the 
arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is 
nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could 
have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is 
completely missing. atrocious music.

 














  

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Mahima Sengupta
who are his servants? lol if that be the case let me search for their feet :P

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, Karthikeyan Rajendran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: Karthikeyan Rajendran [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 10:19 AM











Are you kidding?

--- On Tue, 9/30/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Tuesday, September 30, 2008, 11:22 PM




has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the 
arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is 
nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could 
have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is 
completely missing. atrocious music.




  
  




 

















  

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Mahima Sengupta

Why should we as fans break our heads about which  director  ARR choses? IS he 
not the best judge of the situation? What Knowledge do we have to make such 
accusations? As for Harris, he is a good singer who was nurtured by ARR. Am 
sure ARR n Harris share a good rapport so why don't we just sit back and enjoy  
ARR's music which is in tune with the times instead of being over critical 
about him. Healthy criticism is always welcome by all but pointing an accusing 
finger at some1 as great as ARR is simply not accepted..
--- On Wed, 10/1/08, Karthikeyan Rajendran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

From: Karthikeyan Rajendran [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 10:19 AM










Are you kidding?

--- On Tue, 9/30/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Tuesday, September 30, 2008, 11:22 PM




has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the 
arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is 
nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could 
have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is 
completely missing. atrocious music.


 














  

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread sriramvr_in
one has to recollect one's past when things were perfect in order to 
introspect


--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Mahima Sengupta 
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 
 Stop Living in the past!.
 --- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
 To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 3:22 AM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
 
 
 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. 
the 
 
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is 
 
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could 
 
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is 
 
 completely missing. atrocious music.





Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread sriramvr_in
ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime.  

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:
 
has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
   
 





Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread sriramvr_in
some people are not matured enough to accept even the slightest of 
constructive valid criticsm :)

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Thulasi Ram [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 LOLzzz... grow up... tune up...
 
 On Tue, Sep 30, 2008 at 8:22 PM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:
 
has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
   
 





Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread $ Pavan Kumar $
You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the group..and hey..u 
criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any probs..Coz..once in a blue 
moon we have guys of your type...popping up..saying these kind of things..you 
are not new..so..dont feel lonely..
 
But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect 
perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no 
obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives, 
accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his 
music..Hope..you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am happy 
to have come across someone as perfect as you...
 
Wah..guys...just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj 
release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...
 
1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..
 
Its going to be really tough..

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM






ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime. 

--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] . 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
wrote:
 
  has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
  
 


 














  

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Rachana Rehman





well said pavan..

these are mails aimed at shattering our unity.

let them know that till the world rotates rahman will rule..

i'm with u. 

let us join hands together to trash out these roootless members who are here to
find faults...


ella pugazhum iravanukke..

rachana rehman

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 5:45 PM











You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 
group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any 
probs..Coz... once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping 
up..saying these kind of things..you are not new..so..dont feel lonely..
 
But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect 
perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no 
obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives, 
accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his 
music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am happy 
to have come across someone as perfect as you...
 
Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj 
release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...
 
1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..
 
Its going to be really tough..

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM




ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime. 

--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] . 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are
 rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
wrote:
 
  has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days
 of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
  
 





  
  




 

















  

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Anil Nair
Dude hows does the usage of such language/words amount to constructive
criticism. .

has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants
or
nothing but pure jink
or
trashed out 
or
atrocious music

Your message without these words could have been considered some form of
feedback...but this to me does not seem like it

Its ur choice ...its ur liking ..u r welcome to express yourself (and people
will respond with their thoughts ...as you might have noticed by the number
of responses ...your mail has generated)

But please dont disguise it under the garb of constructive criticism or
whatever

-A


On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 9:13 AM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   some people are not matured enough to accept even the slightest of
 constructive valid criticsm :)

 --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
 Thulasi Ram [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
 
  LOLzzz... grow up... tune up...
 
  On Tue, Sep 30, 2008 at 8:22 PM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
 
   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
  
   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early
 90's. the
   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR
 could
   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
   completely missing. atrocious music.
  
  
  
 

 




-- 
-A
http://viewsnmuse.blogspot.com


Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread parichay bhattacharya
If some one says Marudani and Elay are atrocious compositions then I think, 
that person's music sense need to be seriously questioned...
And according to my perspective Rahman Sir has jus kept on excelling over the 
years...so tags like his 90's music and stuff does not make any sense..

--- On Wed, 1/10/08, Rachana Rehman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: Rachana Rehman [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, 1 October, 2008, 11:38 PM














well said pavan..

these are mails aimed at shattering our unity.

let them know that till the world rotates rahman will rule..

i'm with u. 

let us join hands together to trash out these roootless members who are here to
find faults...


ella pugazhum iravanukke..

rachana rehman

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ yahoo.com wrote:
From: $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 5:45 PM








You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 
group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any probs..Coz.. 
once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping up..saying these kind 
of things..you are not new..so..dont feel lonely..
 
But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect 
perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no 
obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives, 
accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his 
music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am happy 
to have come across someone as perfect as you...
 
Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj 
release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...
 
1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..
 
Its going to be really tough..

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM




ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime. 

--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] . 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers
 are
 rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
wrote:
 
  has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days
 of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
  
 





  
  


 




  
  




 

















  Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to 
http://messenger.yahoo.com/invite/

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Arijit Debnath
I would say if someone is not liking anything... we can reply to that
mail if we also don't like the same if we like that and someone
doesn't...leave that...ignore that

In this world somebody may not like Roja/Bombay/Dil se also.. we can't help
that.

Arijit




2008/10/1 Rachana Rehman [EMAIL PROTECTED]


 well said pavan..
 these are mails aimed at shattering our unity.
 let them know that till the world rotates rahman will rule..
 i'm with u.
 let us join hands together to trash out these roootless members who are
 here to find faults...

 ella pugazhum iravanukke..

 rachana rehman

 --- On *Wed, 10/1/08, $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED]* wrote:

 From: $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
 To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 5:45 PM


 You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the group..and
 hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any probs..Coz.. once in
 a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping up..saying these kind of
 things..you are not new..so..dont feel lonely..

 But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect
 perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no
 obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives,
 accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his
 music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am
 happy to have come across someone as perfect as you...

 Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj
 release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...

 1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
 2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
 3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..

 Its going to be really tough..

 --- On *Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com* wrote:

 From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
 To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM

  ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy
 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if
 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get
 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased
 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not
 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs
 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier.
 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent
 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection
 everytime.

 --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
 Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] .
 wrote:
 
  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking
 and sadly
  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an
 album like
  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is
 enjoyable.
  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs
 you like
  and don't listen to the rest.
 
  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his
 prime then.
  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no
 fluke. Today
  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove
 anything to
  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured
 kind. Let us
  live with it.
 
  Naveen
 
  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ...
 wrote:
 
   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
  
   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early
 90's. the
   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR
 could
   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
   completely missing. atrocious music.
  
  
  
 



 



Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Reformed Sinner
sriram - It all depends on your expectations. I guess you expect totally
out-of-the-world fresh music everytime an ARR album releases. Most of the
times that is not going to happen.

Things were different in the 90s. ARR's music and sound stood out among the
other music that was coming out then. But since 2000, if you notice, lots of
music composers are sounding more  more like ARR. They have incorporated
lots of Rahmantic sounds into their music. So the uniqueness of Rahman's 90s
music was diluted and Rahman was forced to change his style.

Just think from ARR's point of view. If he keeps giving 90s style of music,
people complain he is repetitive. If he changes his style to something
different, people say his style is gone and his quality has decreased.
Either way there are only complaints. He cannot satisfy all every time.

coming back to expectations, i guess if Sakkarakatti was composed by any
other MD, you would have probably called it good music. But since it is from
ARR, you are expecting much more. i wud say sakkarakatti is not that bad,
but it is not fair to compare it with ARR's previous works. It is good in
its own way.



On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 9:41 PM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy
 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if
 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get
 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased
 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not
 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs
 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier.
 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent
 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection
 everytime.

 --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
 Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:

 
  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking
 and sadly
  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an
 album like
  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is
 enjoyable.
  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs
 you like
  and don't listen to the rest.
 
  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his
 prime then.
  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no
 fluke. Today
  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove
 anything to
  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured
 kind. Let us
  live with it.
 
  Naveen
 
  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
 
   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
  
   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early
 90's. the
   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR
 could
   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
   completely missing. atrocious music.
  
  
  
 

  



Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Vishnu Ram Prasad
VISHNU,
 
 HEY IT'S A CRIME TO CALL ARR's MUSIC ATROCIOUS. YES, 
DEFINITELY ARR IN 90's WAS THE BEST, BUT ARR NOW IS 99.99 % THE SAME. THE 
90's ARR MUSIC IS BEING EASILY EMULATED TO SOME EXTENT BY HARRIS  YUVAN. NEED 
SOME CHANGE RIGHT ? BUT, YYAAA, ARR IN 90's HAD  SOME KINDA SOUL IN IT THAT'S 
DEFINITELY MISSING NOW. BUT NEVERTHELESS I LISTEN 2 ALL 6 SONGS IN SAKKARAKATTI 
AND EVRYTIME IT SOUNDS FRESH..

AR RAHMAN ROCKSSS



- Original Message 
From: parichay bhattacharya [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Thursday, 2 October, 2008 12:12:20 AM
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..


If some one says Marudani and Elay are atrocious compositions then I think, 
that person's music sense need to be seriously questioned... .
And according to my perspective Rahman Sir has jus kept on excelling over the 
years...so tags like his 90's music and stuff does not make any sense..

--- On Wed, 1/10/08, Rachana Rehman rachanarehman@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: Rachana Rehman rachanarehman@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, 1 October, 2008, 11:38 PM




well said pavan..
these are mails aimed at shattering our unity.
let them know that till the world rotates rahman will rule..
i'm with u. 
let us join hands together to trash out these roootless members who are here to 
find faults...
ella pugazhum iravanukke..

rachana rehman

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 5:45 PM


You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the group..and hey..u 
criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any probs..Coz.. once in a blue 
moon we have guys of your type...popping up..saying these kind of things..you 
are not new..so..dont feel lonely..

But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect 
perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no 
obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives, 
accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his 
music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am happy 
to have come across someone as perfect as you...

Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj 
release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...

1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..

Its going to be really tough..

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM


ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime. 

--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] . 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
wrote:
 
  has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
  
 


 
 
 


Add more friends to your messenger

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Jahanzeb Farooq
completely agree about the end three points!

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
wrote:

 You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 
group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any 
probs..Coz..once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping 
up..saying these kind of things..you are not new..so..dont feel 
lonely..
  
 But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you 
expect perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is 
under no obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take 
what he gives, accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you 
to hear his music..Hope..you follow the so called perfection in your 
life too..I am happy to have come across someone as perfect as you...
  
 Wah..guys...just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, 
yuvraaj release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...
  
 1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
 2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
 3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..
  
 Its going to be really tough..
 
 --- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
 From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
 To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM
 
 
 
 
 
 
 ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
 everytime. 
 
 --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad naveenjn@ 
. 
 wrote:
 
  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 
 and sadly
  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
 album like
  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
 enjoyable.
  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
 you like
  and don't listen to the rest.
  
  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
 prime then.
  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
 fluke. Today
  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
 anything to
  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
 kind. Let us
  live with it.
  
  Naveen
  
  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
 wrote:
  
   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
  
   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
 90's. the
   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
 could
   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
   completely missing. atrocious music.
  
   
  
 






Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Praveen
i think its better we do no reply to these kind of mails..lets take positive 
ones as ARR always says..we know that there is no sense in what he is talking 
abt..and there is no need to pacify him ..lets enjoy 



- Original Message 
From: $ Pavan Kumar $ [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Wednesday, 1 October, 2008 11:15:51 PM
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..


You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the group..and hey..u 
criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any probs..Coz.. once in a blue 
moon we have guys of your type...popping up..saying these kind of things..you 
are not new..so..dont feel lonely..

But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you expect 
perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is under no 
obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take what he gives, 
accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you to hear his 
music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your life too..I am happy 
to have come across someone as perfect as you...

Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, yuvraaj 
release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...

1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.
2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil
3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..

Its going to be really tough..

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com wrote:

From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ yahoo.com
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM


ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 
schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 
there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 
VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 
sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 
anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 
in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 
there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 
works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 
everytime. 

--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad [EMAIL PROTECTED] . 
wrote:

 Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it
 definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 
and sadly
 that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 
album like
 Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 
enjoyable.
 Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 
you like
 and don't listen to the rest.
 
 And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 
prime then.
 Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 
fluke. Today
 he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 
anything to
 anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 
kind. Let us
 live with it.
 
 Naveen
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 
wrote:
 
  has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?
 
  High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 
90's. the
  arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
  nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 
could
  have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
  completely missing. atrocious music.
 
  
 


 
 


  Cricket on your mind? Visit the ultimate cricket website. Enter 
http://beta.cricket.yahoo.com

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread rivjot
I truly stand by your point of view. Very well said Reformed Sinner.

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Reformed Sinner
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 sriram - It all depends on your expectations. I guess you expect totally
 out-of-the-world fresh music everytime an ARR album releases. Most
of the
 times that is not going to happen.
 
 Things were different in the 90s. ARR's music and sound stood out
among the
 other music that was coming out then. But since 2000, if you notice,
lots of
 music composers are sounding more  more like ARR. They have
incorporated
 lots of Rahmantic sounds into their music. So the uniqueness of
Rahman's 90s
 music was diluted and Rahman was forced to change his style.
 
 Just think from ARR's point of view. If he keeps giving 90s style of
music,
 people complain he is repetitive. If he changes his style to something
 different, people say his style is gone and his quality has decreased.
 Either way there are only complaints. He cannot satisfy all every time.
 
 coming back to expectations, i guess if Sakkarakatti was composed by any
 other MD, you would have probably called it good music. But since it
is from
 ARR, you are expecting much more. i wud say sakkarakatti is not that
bad,
 but it is not fair to compare it with ARR's previous works. It is
good in
 its own way.
 
 
 
 On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 9:41 PM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 
ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy
  schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if
  there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get
  VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased
  sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not
  anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs
  in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier.
  there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent
  works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection
  everytime.
 





Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-10-01 Thread Guru Karthik


some of the recent compositions by ARR could
have been trashed out by anybody??

I
am sorry,no one wld have dared to do that...what do you think of
him...d little HJ r YSR who copy frm all dose boy bands??..wake up
man,hes ARRhe has proved dat hes a genius some 15 yrs ago when no
one had ne idea abt wats a reggae r a rap ishe still cant be like
dat...hes not a machine..he has reached a status where other indian
composers has not evn dreamt ofdoin tamil,hindi,n inter. at the
same time.n wat other composers hav done??not evn 1% of our
god..n if ur an ARR fan u wld love wateve he does...
       

--- On Thu, 2/10/08, Jahanzeb Farooq [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: Jahanzeb Farooq [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, 2 October, 2008, 3:29 AM











completely agree about the end three points!



--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, $ Pavan Kumar $ pawancumarr@ ... 

wrote:



 You go on criticising anyone u wish..the old members of the 

group..and hey..u criticise rahman himself too ...We dont have any 

probs..Coz.. once in a blue moon we have guys of your type...popping 

up..saying these kind of things..you are not new..so..dont feel 

lonely..

  

 But But..dont call yourself as a Rahman fan..You are not one..If you 

expect perfection everytime..then the problem is with you..Rahman is 

under no obligation to make you happy or satisfy you..If you can take 

what he gives, accept it..or else..just move on..nobody is forcing you 

to hear his music..Hope. .you follow the so called perfection in your 

life too..I am happy to have come across someone as perfect as you...

  

 Wah..guys... just imagine..what will happen when ghajini,dilli 6, 

yuvraaj release..its going to be really horrible here..Lets guess...

  

 1.Yuvraj is not as good as taal.

 2.Tamil ghajini is better...harris did a better job in tamil

 3. Dilli 6 is a huge let down..no where near Rang De Basanti..

  

 Its going to be really tough..

 

 --- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... wrote:

 

 From: sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ...

 Subject: Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti. . one of ARR's worst..

 To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com

 Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 9:11 AM

 

 

 

 

 

 

 ARR gave value for money earlier but it is not the case now. Busy 

 schedule is taking toll on him. ARR had earlier mentioned that if 

 there are 4 songs, he would give 4 perfect songs so that people get 

 VFM. Is that the case now? His quaility of output has decreased 

 sometimes and it is only because of his limited time and not 

 anything else. the arrangements are become stale. say out of 6 songs 

 in an album, only 2-3 are ok now which was not the case earlier. 

 there is nothing significantly refreshing in some of his recent 

 works. And being one of the ARR's oldest fans, I expect perfection 

 everytime. 

 

 --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Naveen Naushad naveenjn@ 

. 

 wrote:

 

  Sakkarakatti may not be a classic like his works in the 90s but it

  definitely is not bad like you said. Couple of numbers are rocking 

 and sadly

  that is all you get from ARR's recent works. Once in a while an 

 album like

  Jaane Tu or Ada comes from ARR where every single song is 

 enjoyable.

  Otherwise it is mostly just 2 or 3 numbers. Just enjoy the songs 

 you like

  and don't listen to the rest.

  

  And don't ever hope for another 90s kind of album. He was at his 

 prime then.

  Back then he had to prove to the world that his success was no 

 fluke. Today

  he is the greatest composer in Asia. He doesn't have to prove 

 anything to

  anyone. After Lagaan, his style has changed to a more matured 

 kind. Let us

  live with it.

  

  Naveen

  

  On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in sriramvr_in@ ... 

 wrote:

  

   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

  

   High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 

 90's. the

   arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is

   nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR 

 could

   have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is

   completely missing. atrocious music.

  

   

  

 






  




 

















  Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to 
http://messenger.yahoo.com/invite/

Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-09-30 Thread ali ahad
He can generate all kind of music...i don't understand tamil...butt i keep 
listening SIVAJI,ATM,SOK and sakkarakatti songs...even my sister and friends 
listen to them in pakistan...thats the power of his music

--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 8:22 AM

has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
 completely missing. atrocious music.







Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-09-30 Thread Thulasi Ram
LOLzzz... grow up... tune up...

On Tue, Sep 30, 2008 at 8:22 PM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
 completely missing. atrocious music.

  



Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-09-30 Thread Srini Santhanam
so what are you doing here still?

hurry leave this place and dont waste your precious time.. 

On Oct 1, 2008, at 11:22 AM, sriramvr_in wrote:

 has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
 completely missing. atrocious music.


 




Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-09-30 Thread Vithur
Music done by ARR's servants ???. That is a big LOL.

Who are the servants of ARR ?. Sakkarakatti is atrocious music ??!!!




On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 8:52 AM, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

   has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?

 High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the
 arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is
 nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could
 have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is
 completely missing. atrocious music.

 




-- 
regards,
Vithur

ARR in my Heart;
His Music in my Blood;


Re: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..

2008-09-30 Thread Mahima Sengupta

Stop Living in the past!.
--- On Wed, 10/1/08, sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: sriramvr_in [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [arr] Sakkarakatti.. one of ARR's worst..
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Date: Wednesday, October 1, 2008, 3:22 AM











has ARR scored the music or one of ARR's servants?



High time ARR changed his music to the golden days of early 90's. the 

arguments that he is composing according to to today's trend is 

nothing but pure jink. some of the recent compositions by ARR could 

have been trashed out by anybody. The spirit and soul of ARR is 

completely missing. atrocious music.