Re: [basex-talk] Function must not be updating error in 8.4.3 (not in 8.4.2)
Hi Marc, Sounds good; it seems that the update that has been triggered by your post [1] has solved the problem. Sorry for all the flip-flopping reg. the MIXUPDATE option. This is the one of the drawbacks of having custom features that haven't been signed off by the splendid W3 XQuery team. But I think we are very close now. Christian [1] https://github.com/BaseXdb/basex/commit/6f05242fc5a1956e9377a53cf46e1367d41ac000 Am 26.04.2016 08:54 schrieb "Marc van Grootel" : > Hi Christian, > > This morning wanted to get to the bottom of this but found that with > the latest snapshot (23/4) it is fixed (can still repro with 8.4.3 and > older snapshots like the 22/4 snapshot). > > Unless you think it's worthwhile to try and get a minimal reproducible > case for 8.4.3 I can try but as far as this issue goes it seems to be > gone now. > > Thanks, > --Marc > > > On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 3:36 PM, Marc van Grootel > wrote: > > Checked with this new snapshot. It's still occurring. > > Will do some more digging on monday. > > > > Thanks, > > --Marc > > > > On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 3:21 PM, Christian Grün > > wrote: > >> Difficult to tell ;) I checked the places where your error message is > >> triggered. Did you use updating functions in built-in XQuery functions > >> (for-each, apply, ...)? Does your query run through with the new > >> snapshot [1]? > >> > >> [1] http://files.basex.org/releases/latest/ > >> > >> > >> > >> > >> On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 2:03 PM, Marc van Grootel > >> wrote: > >>> Hi, > >>> > >>> I'm sorry for the vague report. I can do more digging but it's > >>> happening deep inside some code and it's hard to pinpoint. > >>> > >>> In 8.4.3 I get the following error message: > >>> > >>> [XPTY0004] Function must not be updating: %updating > function($result,$tran > >>> > >>> In 8.4.2 and before the same code works as expected. > >>> > >>> What I can say that it's happening in a fold-left function which in > >>> it's body uses an xslt transform (using Saxon). I have > >>> MIXUPDATES=true. I'm not touching the database inside this code but I > >>> can say that the fn call in which the fold-left is located does > >>> contain a couple of db:* functions (but they are not in the active > >>> code path). That's all I can offer at the moment. > >>> > >>> I'm happy to do some more digging later but I wanted to post this just > >>> in case it gives someone a hunch and it's only introduced since 8.4.2. > >>> Also tried 8.4.4-SNAPSHOT and there it's broken too. > >>> > >>> Cheers, > >>> --Marc > > > > > > > > -- > > --Marc > > > > -- > --Marc >
Re: [basex-talk] Function must not be updating error in 8.4.3 (not in 8.4.2)
Hi Christian, This morning wanted to get to the bottom of this but found that with the latest snapshot (23/4) it is fixed (can still repro with 8.4.3 and older snapshots like the 22/4 snapshot). Unless you think it's worthwhile to try and get a minimal reproducible case for 8.4.3 I can try but as far as this issue goes it seems to be gone now. Thanks, --Marc On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 3:36 PM, Marc van Grootel wrote: > Checked with this new snapshot. It's still occurring. > Will do some more digging on monday. > > Thanks, > --Marc > > On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 3:21 PM, Christian Grün > wrote: >> Difficult to tell ;) I checked the places where your error message is >> triggered. Did you use updating functions in built-in XQuery functions >> (for-each, apply, ...)? Does your query run through with the new >> snapshot [1]? >> >> [1] http://files.basex.org/releases/latest/ >> >> >> >> >> On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 2:03 PM, Marc van Grootel >> wrote: >>> Hi, >>> >>> I'm sorry for the vague report. I can do more digging but it's >>> happening deep inside some code and it's hard to pinpoint. >>> >>> In 8.4.3 I get the following error message: >>> >>> [XPTY0004] Function must not be updating: %updating >>> function($result,$tran >>> >>> In 8.4.2 and before the same code works as expected. >>> >>> What I can say that it's happening in a fold-left function which in >>> it's body uses an xslt transform (using Saxon). I have >>> MIXUPDATES=true. I'm not touching the database inside this code but I >>> can say that the fn call in which the fold-left is located does >>> contain a couple of db:* functions (but they are not in the active >>> code path). That's all I can offer at the moment. >>> >>> I'm happy to do some more digging later but I wanted to post this just >>> in case it gives someone a hunch and it's only introduced since 8.4.2. >>> Also tried 8.4.4-SNAPSHOT and there it's broken too. >>> >>> Cheers, >>> --Marc > > > > -- > --Marc -- --Marc
Re: [basex-talk] Function must not be updating error in 8.4.3 (not in 8.4.2)
Checked with this new snapshot. It's still occurring. Will do some more digging on monday. Thanks, --Marc On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 3:21 PM, Christian Grün wrote: > Difficult to tell ;) I checked the places where your error message is > triggered. Did you use updating functions in built-in XQuery functions > (for-each, apply, ...)? Does your query run through with the new > snapshot [1]? > > [1] http://files.basex.org/releases/latest/ > > > > > On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 2:03 PM, Marc van Grootel > wrote: >> Hi, >> >> I'm sorry for the vague report. I can do more digging but it's >> happening deep inside some code and it's hard to pinpoint. >> >> In 8.4.3 I get the following error message: >> >> [XPTY0004] Function must not be updating: %updating >> function($result,$tran >> >> In 8.4.2 and before the same code works as expected. >> >> What I can say that it's happening in a fold-left function which in >> it's body uses an xslt transform (using Saxon). I have >> MIXUPDATES=true. I'm not touching the database inside this code but I >> can say that the fn call in which the fold-left is located does >> contain a couple of db:* functions (but they are not in the active >> code path). That's all I can offer at the moment. >> >> I'm happy to do some more digging later but I wanted to post this just >> in case it gives someone a hunch and it's only introduced since 8.4.2. >> Also tried 8.4.4-SNAPSHOT and there it's broken too. >> >> Cheers, >> --Marc -- --Marc
Re: [basex-talk] Function must not be updating error in 8.4.3 (not in 8.4.2)
Difficult to tell ;) I checked the places where your error message is triggered. Did you use updating functions in built-in XQuery functions (for-each, apply, ...)? Does your query run through with the new snapshot [1]? [1] http://files.basex.org/releases/latest/ On Fri, Apr 22, 2016 at 2:03 PM, Marc van Grootel wrote: > Hi, > > I'm sorry for the vague report. I can do more digging but it's > happening deep inside some code and it's hard to pinpoint. > > In 8.4.3 I get the following error message: > > [XPTY0004] Function must not be updating: %updating function($result,$tran > > In 8.4.2 and before the same code works as expected. > > What I can say that it's happening in a fold-left function which in > it's body uses an xslt transform (using Saxon). I have > MIXUPDATES=true. I'm not touching the database inside this code but I > can say that the fn call in which the fold-left is located does > contain a couple of db:* functions (but they are not in the active > code path). That's all I can offer at the moment. > > I'm happy to do some more digging later but I wanted to post this just > in case it gives someone a hunch and it's only introduced since 8.4.2. > Also tried 8.4.4-SNAPSHOT and there it's broken too. > > Cheers, > --Marc
[basex-talk] Function must not be updating error in 8.4.3 (not in 8.4.2)
Hi, I'm sorry for the vague report. I can do more digging but it's happening deep inside some code and it's hard to pinpoint. In 8.4.3 I get the following error message: [XPTY0004] Function must not be updating: %updating function($result,$tran In 8.4.2 and before the same code works as expected. What I can say that it's happening in a fold-left function which in it's body uses an xslt transform (using Saxon). I have MIXUPDATES=true. I'm not touching the database inside this code but I can say that the fn call in which the fold-left is located does contain a couple of db:* functions (but they are not in the active code path). That's all I can offer at the moment. I'm happy to do some more digging later but I wanted to post this just in case it gives someone a hunch and it's only introduced since 8.4.2. Also tried 8.4.4-SNAPSHOT and there it's broken too. Cheers, --Marc
