Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-30 Thread J . A . Magallon


On 20011030 Han wrote:
John Haywood ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:

 --so looks asthough you might be missing the Mesa package

Seems like that solved it. All manuals state that if you have a nvidia
card you should not install the Mesa-package. Because of the
glx-libraries that will conflict. Well if I get into trouble later
well sort it out.


I think you only should install Mesa if you have XFree 3.3.x. With
XFree 4.1.0, you already get a libGL. So the two possible setups are:
- XF 3.3 + libMesaGL + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
- XF 4.1 + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
(same for the devel packages).

The Mesa- package contains control utils and config files for the DRI
implementation of Mesa. I do not know if it is needed for the version
included with XFree 4.1.

And of course if you install nVidia drivers, you do not need the libMesaGL
package, nor the libGL.so.xxx files installed with XFree4. The nVidia
installer wipes out the latter.

-- 
J.A. Magallon   #  Let the source be with you...
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Mandrake Linux release 8.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux werewolf 2.4.13-ac5-beo #1 SMP Tue Oct 30 00:10:00 CET 2001 i686




Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-30 Thread Han

J . A . Magallon ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:
 On 20011030 Han wrote:
John Haywood ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:

 --so looks asthough you might be missing the Mesa package

 Seems like that solved it. All manuals state that if you have a
 nvidia card you should not install the Mesa-package. Because of the
 glx-libraries that will conflict. Well if I get into trouble later
 well sort it out.

 I think you only should install Mesa if you have XFree 3.3.x. With
 XFree 4.1.0, you already get a libGL. So the two possible setups are:
 - XF 3.3 + libMesaGL + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 - XF 4.1 + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 (same for the devel packages).

 The Mesa- package contains control utils and config files for the
 DRI implementation of Mesa. I do not know if it is needed for the
 version included with XFree 4.1.

 And of course if you install nVidia drivers, you do not need the
 libMesaGL package, nor the libGL.so.xxx files installed with XFree4.
 The nVidia installer wipes out the latter.

Now you remind me of the other variation I thought of... at least I
needed the Mesa-package to be able to update, ahem it seemed so.

Yes the variation without Mesa.rpm also works fine and I still don't
like ladies with shotguns.

[~]$ rpm -qa|grep Mesa
Mesa-demos-3.5-2mdk
libMesaGLU1-3.5-2mdk
libMesaglut3-3.5-2mdk
libMesaGLU1-devel-3.5-2mdk
libMesaglut3-devel-3.5-2mdk

The glut-libraries seem to be unimportant for quake3 but what the
hell. Anyway this seems to bee a much more consistant way of packaging
the Mesa-stuff.


Cya, Han.




Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-30 Thread John Haywood

On Tue, 30 Oct 2001 21:05, you wrote:
 Han [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
  The glut-libraries seem to be unimportant for quake3 but what the
  hell. Anyway this seems to bee a much more consistant way of packaging
  the Mesa-stuff.

 Thanks, glut3 is problably not needed by a lot of GL stuff (especially
 games).

 This allows reducing potential error and allow using other library without
 too much error (libGLU for example), this one comes with libGLU 1.3 from
 SGI incorporated with Mesa 3.5.

 François.

So, in summary, what packages are needed with what? 

For example, as J . A . Magallon [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote, is this combo 
correct? :

 I think you only should install Mesa if you have XFree 3.3.x. With
 XFree 4.1.0, you already get a libGL. So the two possible setups are:
 - XF 3.3 + libMesaGL + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 - XF 4.1 + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 (same for the devel packages).

And further, is this true for *all* video cards (hidden agenda, I have a 3dfx 
G), or just non-Glide? 

cheers
-- 
john in syd




Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-30 Thread J . A . Magallon


On 20011030 John Haywood wrote:

For example, as J . A . Magallon [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote, is this combo 
correct? :

 I think you only should install Mesa if you have XFree 3.3.x. With
 XFree 4.1.0, you already get a libGL. So the two possible setups are:
 - XF 3.3 + libMesaGL + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 - XF 4.1 + libMesaGLU + libMesaglut
 (same for the devel packages).

And further, is this true for *all* video cards (hidden agenda, I have a 3dfx 
G), or just non-Glide? 


In short, XFree-4.1.0 includes Mesa-3.4.2. See

http://www.xfree86.org/4.1.0/RELNOTES2.html#4

So the status of 3D is that of Mesa 3.4.2, apart from bugfixes. So it means
it uses the DRI infraestructure. Take a look at:

http://www.xfree86.org/4.1.0/RELNOTES5.html#25

What I do not know is if you can overwrite XFree's Mesa 3.4.2 with 3.5 and
live happy
Experts ?

-- 
J.A. Magallon   #  Let the source be with you...
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Mandrake Linux release 8.2 (Cooker) for i586
Linux werewolf 2.4.13-ac5-beo #1 SMP Tue Oct 30 00:10:00 CET 2001 i686





Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-29 Thread John Haywood

On Mon, 29 Oct 2001 21:24, you wrote:
 Ok let me get this straight cause I still don't quitte understand what
 has to be done:

 When I try to update the Mesa-rpms I get:

 error: failed dependencies:
         Mesa-common = 3.4.2 is needed by Mesa-common-devel-3.4.2-2mdk

 This is the list of new rpms:

 libMesaGLU1-3.5-2mdk.i586.rpm
 libMesaglut3-3.5-2mdk.i586.rpm

 And this is the list of allready installed rpms:

 Mesa-common-devel-3.4.2-2mdk
 Mesa-common-3.4.2-2mdk


 Now what is the right way to get it straight?


On my system - Mesa is at version 3.5.2, and there are no more Mesa-common 
packages:

[root@thang john]# rpm -qa | grep -i mesa |sort
libMesaGL1-3.5-2mdk
libMesaGLU1-3.5-2mdk
libMesaglut3-3.5-2mdk
Mesa-3.5-2mdk
xmms-mesa-1.2.5-5mdk

--so looks asthough you might be missing the Mesa package
-- 
john in syd




Re: [Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-29 Thread Han

John Haywood ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:

 --so looks asthough you might be missing the Mesa package

Seems like that solved it. All manuals state that if you have a nvidia
card you should not install the Mesa-package. Because of the
glx-libraries that will conflict. Well if I get into trouble later
well sort it out.


Cya, Han.




[Cooker] Mesa-packages

2001-10-29 Thread Han

Ok let me get this straight cause I still don't quitte understand what
has to be done:

When I try to update the Mesa-rpms I get:

error: failed dependencies:
Mesa-common = 3.4.2 is needed by Mesa-common-devel-3.4.2-2mdk

This is the list of new rpms: 

libMesaGLU1-3.5-2mdk.i586.rpm
libMesaglut3-3.5-2mdk.i586.rpm

And this is the list of allready installed rpms: 

Mesa-common-devel-3.4.2-2mdk
Mesa-common-3.4.2-2mdk


Now what is the right way to get it straight?


Cya, Han.