Re: Release plan
Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
RE: Release plan
Do you still encounter that problem? I have been trying to reproduce it, but without any luck. If you have pointers, please share. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of KangMas Willy Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:39 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
RE: Release plan
By chance, you don't get any like the following message in log-level = 0? MYSQL: Database pool got no connection! DB update failed! Or something similar? == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Rene Kluwen Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:42 To: 'KangMas Willy'; 'Alexander Malysh' Cc: 'Kannel Devel' Subject: RE: Release plan Do you still encounter that problem? I have been trying to reproduce it, but without any luck. If you have pointers, please share. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of KangMas Willy Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:39 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Yeah, me neither. I've also tried to reproduce it on the weekend using latest Kannel's SVN and couldn't. If you still experience the issue, please let us know the versions you use and I'll re-verify it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 13/09/2010, at 15:42, Rene Kluwen wrote: Do you still encounter that problem? I have been trying to reproduce it, but without any luck. If you have pointers, please share. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of KangMas Willy Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:39 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
how do you store message body and udh in DB? hex? I ask because you may have some errors due to the missing escaping? And even sqlbox show errors, just make sure you send ACK to bearerbox _after_ successful insert into DB and you will never lose MOs. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 13.09.2010 um 15:48 schrieb Alejandro Guerrieri: Yeah, me neither. I've also tried to reproduce it on the weekend using latest Kannel's SVN and couldn't. If you still experience the issue, please let us know the versions you use and I'll re-verify it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 13/09/2010, at 15:42, Rene Kluwen wrote: Do you still encounter that problem? I have been trying to reproduce it, but without any luck. If you have pointers, please share. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of KangMas Willy Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:39 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
I don't think that's the problem here. When the error happened, it didn't matter what kind of content you used. I've tried inserting a lot of identical messages (like Hello) and about 40-50% of them were lost. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 13/09/2010, at 16:00, Alexander Malysh wrote: how do you store message body and udh in DB? hex? I ask because you may have some errors due to the missing escaping? And even sqlbox show errors, just make sure you send ACK to bearerbox _after_ successful insert into DB and you will never lose MOs. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 13.09.2010 um 15:48 schrieb Alejandro Guerrieri: Yeah, me neither. I've also tried to reproduce it on the weekend using latest Kannel's SVN and couldn't. If you still experience the issue, please let us know the versions you use and I'll re-verify it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 13/09/2010, at 15:42, Rene Kluwen wrote: Do you still encounter that problem? I have been trying to reproduce it, but without any luck. If you have pointers, please share. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of KangMas Willy Sent: Monday, 13 September, 2010 15:39 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Hi, At the user point of view. I think SQLBox is not ready yet, since it still contains bug on MO receiving with meta-data. I'm sure Alex is working on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 9, 2010, at 8:12 PM, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Yes I agree with it. In my case I need to restart the box early in the morning daily (I sent around 5 millions MT/day). Need some bug fix on it. sangprabv sangpr...@gmail.com http://www.petitiononline.com/froyo/ On Sep 12, 2010, at 4:18 AM, Alejandro Guerrieri wrote: I've just tried to reproduce the sqlbox issue with the MO's being lost, and couldn't. Tried with up to 100K messages using fakesmsc and all of them were inserted on the DB. I've tried both with latest sqlbox SVN and also with 0.7.2 and in both cases worked exactly the same. Perhaps something changed on Kannel's side during last year that fixed the issue without us noticing? Anyway, it's definitely gone for good :) BTW, I've been bitten by the retry bug: the few messages that failed on smsbox (because the web server couldn't cope with them) were queued in _memory_ (they'd be gone if I'd stop smsbox) and retried one by one on 30 seconds interval. IMHO_that_ is a serious bug on Kannel that should be taken care of asap. 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:41 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:09:49 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:10:19 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:10:49 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:11:19 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:11:49 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:12:19 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:12:49 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:13:19 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 127.0.0.1 - - [11/Sep/2010:18:13:49 -0300] GET /kannel.html HTTP/1.1 200 4 - Kannel/svn-r4838 Settings were: http-request-retry = 10 http-queue-delay= 30 Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 11/09/2010, at 11:55, Alexander Malysh wrote: oops, this patch should definitely go in. Am 10.09.2010 um 22:07 schrieb Rene Kluwen: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf
Re: Release plan
oops, this patch should definitely go in. Am 10.09.2010 um 22:07 schrieb Rene Kluwen: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
Re: Release plan
Commited to SVN. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 11/09/2010, at 11:55, Alexander Malysh wrote: oops, this patch should definitely go in. Am 10.09.2010 um 22:07 schrieb Rene Kluwen: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
Re: Release plan
it depends on patch, post it to ML and CC me directly. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 23:55 schrieb Victor Luchitz: Any chance for a patch that adds another parameter bb_smscconn_send_failed to set the meta_data field for DLR to be merged in the upcoming days? I'm yet to cook it, but it's pretty trivial and should be safe. 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
RE: Release plan
Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
RE: Release plan
If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
Re: Release plan
Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
RE: Release plan
Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch Description: Binary data
Re: Release plan
I wonder why it was like that on first place... I'm +1 for it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:07, Rene Kluwen wrote: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
RE: Release plan
It was like that in the first place, because I thought all the ACK/ messages in the log table were only noise and not relevant. Since no messages were acked at all, it didn't pose a problem. But now the messages are acked (more) correctly, these messages need to be acked as well. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 22:16 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel'; 'Alexander Malysh' Subject: Re: Release plan I wonder why it was like that on first place... I'm +1 for it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:07, Rene Kluwen wrote: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
Re: Release plan
I see. Do you want to commit it yourself? I can do it tomorrow otherwise. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:18, Rene Kluwen wrote: It was like that in the first place, because I thought all the “ACK/” messages in the log table were only noise and not relevant. Since no messages were acked at all, it didn’t pose a “problem”. But now the messages are acked (more) correctly, these messages need to be acked as well. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 22:16 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel'; 'Alexander Malysh' Subject: Re: Release plan I wonder why it was like that on first place... I'm +1 for it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:07, Rene Kluwen wrote: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
RE: Release plan
Please do it tomorrow for me. So other people have a chance to judge the patch as well. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 22:33 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel'; 'Alexander Malysh' Subject: Re: Release plan I see. Do you want to commit it yourself? I can do it tomorrow otherwise. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:18, Rene Kluwen wrote: It was like that in the first place, because I thought all the ACK/ messages in the log table were only noise and not relevant. Since no messages were acked at all, it didn't pose a problem. But now the messages are acked (more) correctly, these messages need to be acked as well. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 22:16 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel'; 'Alexander Malysh' Subject: Re: Release plan I wonder why it was like that on first place... I'm +1 for it. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 22:07, Rene Kluwen wrote: Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz sqlbox_acks_3.patch
Re: Release plan
Looks good. +1 Nikos - Original Message - From: Rene Kluwen To: 'Alejandro Guerrieri' Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri' ; 'Kannel Devel' Sent: Friday, September 10, 2010 11:07 PM Subject: RE: Release plan Not sure if anybody noticed. But not all sms messages were acked properly before, leaving messages in the message store. I stuck across this, while implementing sqlbox for a client. This patch solves the problem. I would like to see it implemented before next devel-release. Votes? == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:aguerri...@kannel.org] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 20:30 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: 'Alejandro Guerrieri'; 'Kannel Devel' Subject: Re: Release plan Yes, that was what I was thinking also. I'll try with an older version of Sqlbox and latest SVN to see if there's any differences. Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 10/09/2010, at 20:12, Rene Kluwen wrote: If it has something to do with acks, then this might be the case. == Rene From: Alejandro Guerrieri [mailto:alejandro.guerri...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, 10 September, 2010 19:23 To: Rene Kluwen Cc: Alexander Malysh; Victor Luchitz; Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Wow, that's odd. Perhaps one of the latest patches solved it? I'll try to reproduce it this weekend to be sure. Regards, Alex On Fri, Sep 10, 2010 at 7:16 PM, Rene Kluwen rene.klu...@chimit.nl wrote: Just sent a million messages via Nikos' stress test. And they all arrived, without losing a single message. == Rene 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
Re: Release plan
On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
hmm, I'm nor really sure how meta-data can affect MO handling... any chance to fix it this week/weekend? otherwise we have to exclude sqlbox... Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 15:33 schrieb Alejandro Guerrieri: On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
RE: Release plan
@Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Renee, Ok, fair enough, but probably all in caps ;) Regards, Alex -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 17:46, Rene Kluwen wrote: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Me neither, but the problem definitely arouse when that branch was merged. Using Kannel's code from the day before the merge works fine. I'm currently buried with work, but I'll try to give it a shot during the weekend. If anyone else also wishes to take a chance at it, he/she'll be more than welcomed also ;) Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 16:15, Alexander Malysh wrote: hmm, I'm nor really sure how meta-data can affect MO handling... any chance to fix it this week/weekend? otherwise we have to exclude sqlbox... Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 15:33 schrieb Alejandro Guerrieri: On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
RE: Release plan
Giving a shot at is, as we speak! == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 21:37 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan Me neither, but the problem definitely arouse when that branch was merged. Using Kannel's code from the day before the merge works fine. I'm currently buried with work, but I'll try to give it a shot during the weekend. If anyone else also wishes to take a chance at it, he/she'll be more than welcomed also ;) Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 16:15, Alexander Malysh wrote: hmm, I'm nor really sure how meta-data can affect MO handling... any chance to fix it this week/weekend? otherwise we have to exclude sqlbox... Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 15:33 schrieb Alejandro Guerrieri: On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh
Re: Release plan
Any chance for a patch that adds another parameter bb_smscconn_send_failed to set the meta_data field for DLR to be merged in the upcoming days? I'm yet to cook it, but it's pretty trivial and should be safe. 2010/9/10 Alexander Malysh amal...@kannel.org: Hi Rene, we can delay release for one more week but not longer. If you think it's better to delay let us know. Thanks, Alexander Malysh Am 09.09.2010 um 17:46 schrieb Rene Kluwen: @Alejandro: Not sure if it is a show stopper. It could be in the section known bugs. @Alexander: Even though I am +1 for a new release (the older release has been a while) next weekend is really a short notice. @ both: I will investigate the MO problem of sqlbox. == Rene -Original Message- From: devel-boun...@kannel.org [mailto:devel-boun...@kannel.org] On Behalf Of Alejandro Guerrieri Sent: Thursday, 09 September, 2010 15:34 To: Alexander Malysh Cc: Kannel Devel Subject: Re: Release plan On Sqlbox, we have that unsolved issue that arose when the meta-data branch was applied on Kannel. That's a showstopper imho. To describe the problem further: The issue arises when sqlbox is between bearerbox and smsbox, and it's only observed on MO traffic. When you receive just a few MO messages, it works fine. However, if you sustain a moderate level of inbound messages, some of them are lost. The logs shows nothing relevant. The bug was observed by many users on the list. I've also confirmed it's happening. I'm not sure if it's really an sqlbox bug, or if it's really on Kannel's side. The problem doesn't occur if you use an older version of Kannel (pre meta-data). Regards, -- Alejandro Guerrieri aguerri...@kannel.org On 09/09/2010, at 15:12, Alexander Malysh wrote: Hi together, we are plan to release new Kannel developer version. For this task we have at this point in time only one patch to merge, wtls branch. We also plan to release sqlbox opensmppbox with Kannel. Rene Alex: could you please check status of both boxes and let us know whether you agree to release with Kannel and whether boxes ready for release? The plan would be: 1) this weekend WTLS branch merge 2) next week testing 3) next weekend release but here depends on Stipe Please let me know which not commited patches should go in and whether somebody sees showstopper. Thanks, Alexander Malysh -- Best regards, Victor Luchitz
