[Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Sun, 1 Feb 2004, Adir Abraham wrote:

 On Sun, 1 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:

  decide I said that from my message). I said we are going to use
  default/minimal setup and give them the CDs.

 The default should have many applications inside. We can't, and we
 shouldn't give the installee a minimal installation (unless we don't have
 another choice. For instance - storage reasons, or he knows in advance
 that it's going to be a server. In this case, we might want to minimize
 the installation). The installee should have a machine with many applications
 that we can use. He'll get a fully installed desktop machine, and from there
 (after some reading), he can choose what he likes to do with it.

  Given that, your entire message is moot. And installing 5GB takes a lot of
  time as we all witnessed during the last Installation Party. I don't want
  to do it again.

 In average, it takes about a hour to start and finish a full installation
 on a Celeron or Duron machine @ 1200MHz (I did those checks before the
 instaparty and I had the pleasure to install to such a machine in the
 instaparty itself). Ofcourse - if we don't have any special problems
 during the installation itself (hardware mismatch and other weird
 problems), and it goes smooth. You can conclude what happens with faster
 machines or those that include rich hardware features. I also assume that
 we'll have faster machines next year, so it will not take more than 40
 minutes in average. So, 5GB doesn't sound so big, anymore.


Some installations I've been at took several hours, (seriously), as they
were on underpowered computers. The updating of the updates also took
forever. And it barely fit on the hard-disk and filled in the partition
with zsh and other useless software.

Even one hour may be too long.

  BTW, my friend who is a newbie, had installed RedHat 9.0 on his own. The
  Internet works, but otherwise he has tons of trouble and thing don't work.
  I suggest we never install RedHat/Fedore again.

 RedHat 9.0 had many problems, I agree. But from that, going so far to
 never install RedHat/Fedore again ?!


Mandrake is a much superior distribution to RedHat.

Regards,

Shlomi Fish

--
Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

Hey? I'm just kidding!

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Adir Abraham
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:

   1. Buy a set of CDs from us.
 
  They already do it. However, they don't have to do it.
 

 Right, and I want them to have to do it, so it will simplify matters for
 us.

Hmm.. You can't force anyone to buy CDs. Once you do it, you will miss the
whole point of free (it's like forcing someone to buy an entrance
ticket to a free event).

 Eifhr.

?! (should I google this?)

  You assume that the person: 1) will know how to update (including all
  sorts of dependancies). 2) will bother to update. 3) has fast connection to
  the Internet. No, it's not a good idea.
 

 Yes, it is. There were a few updates for RedHat 9.0 since the last
 instaparty, and if the people who installed the computers did not update,
 there systems are vulnerable now. We can't escape the fact that we cannot
 leave the newcomers at a clueless stage. Cluelessness doesn't work when
 dealing with computers.

People do not think of maintenance, usually. The simple user will not
think of updates. Not too soon, whatsoever. He might even wait for the
next instaparty to occur. People do not think neither care of vulnerable
systems (fact, but true). Since no viruses are involved, other security
issues might not interest him (expolits and others).
Cluelessness is the default when one uses a computer with a new OS. You
install to such a person the new OS and from there he would like to have a
working system. He can RTFM and do other things with it - but he doesn't
have to.

 We have to teach them how to install stuff on their own! Many people are
 able to install stuff for Windows as well, as a pristine Windows machine
 does not come with all the required components. (it doesn't come up with
 anything that isn't Microsoft). Installing things is not so hard.

Tell That to Someone Who Cares (tm). Usually people do not care about it.
It's not Windows, in the meaning that it's a whole different attitude. And
if you want to let them get used to Linux as much as they would feel
comfortable with their Windows system (assuming they've had one), you have to
show them how, and moreover - to have a listening ear (they don't have to
listen to you. That's what the audience usually chooses). We're usually in
great lack of listeners, unfortunately.


 Regards,

   Shlomi Fish

  
   Regards,
  
 Shlomi Fish
  
  
  
   --
   Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
   Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/
  
   You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!
  
   Hey? I'm just kidding!
  
   --
   Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
   To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
  
  
  
 
 



 --
 Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

 You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

 Hey? I'm just kidding!

 --
 Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
 To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




-- 

Adir Abraham
Technion's Advisors Group and Public PC Farms Manager
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Haifa, Israel
ICQ# 1841481
Cel# +972-53-243438, +972-55-481245
KeyID: 0xD8DC85C7  Fingerprint: 138D 8F41 7A06 44A0  3DBB 9DC3 FE8B 2658



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use http://www.pgp.com
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=dgNP
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Ez-Aton
Some people do, some people talk. Don't forget.
Would *you* test mass deployment of Mandrake, as you say with such a clear 
voice RH sux, and Mandrake rulez. 
Grow up. Mandrake is better in some things, and RH is better on others. If you 
want to make it a flame war regarding distros, have fun, 'cause I ain't in 
this war. If you didn't like the last instaparty, you are most welcome to 
take the next one on yourself. I know that attitude matters, and if you keep 
this one, you're the only one going to be there. 
Get a life.

Ez.

On Monday 02 February 2004 10:30, Shlomi Fish wrote:
 On Sun, 1 Feb 2004, Ez-Aton wrote:
  ago, when MDK8.2 failed to install Lilo after failed X test. I had to
  write manually (running rescue mode) the /etc/lilo.conf file, and to hope
  for the best, as well as setup all kinds of post install scripts and
  actions, manually. It happened on too many computers. It's a stupid
  claim, and it has no basis, therefore, I did not claim the same. MDK9.2
  had few troubles (esp. regarding Heb interface, but not only), and we
  voted agains installing it. One could come up with the claim We should
  install MDK next time, and never install RH based distro (not to mention
  that after all, MDK is based on RH...), but this claimer does not know
  what could have happened if we actually did install MDK. Also, nice
  claim, but I never actually used MDK KickStart mechanism, and during an
  instaparty, is not the best time for the first run. It might work, it
  might fail.

 Then can you please do us all a favour and use the Mandrake KickStart
 mechanism for the first few times? So we'll be better prepared for the
 next installation party?

 Regards,

   Shlomi Fish

 --
 Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

 You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

 Hey? I'm just kidding!

 --
 Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
 To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]


--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Adir Abraham
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:

 Some installations I've been at took several hours, (seriously), as they
 were on underpowered computers. The updating of the updates also took
 forever. And it barely fit on the hard-disk and filled in the partition
 with zsh and other useless software.

And I can give you an example of a dual HT processor (4 logical processors
on one motherboard) with SCSI bus, and tell you that the installation took
only 10 minutes. My point is that I'm talking about the average line.

 Even one hour may be too long.

 Mandrake is a much superior distribution to RedHat.

Too subjective to discuss about.


 Regards,

   Shlomi Fish

 --
 Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

 You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

 Hey? I'm just kidding!


-- 

Adir Abraham
Technion's Advisors Group and Public PC Farms Manager
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Haifa, Israel
ICQ# 1841481
Cel# +972-53-243438, +972-55-481245
KeyID: 0xD8DC85C7  Fingerprint: 138D 8F41 7A06 44A0  3DBB 9DC3 FE8B 2658



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use http://www.pgp.com
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=dgNP
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Sun, 1 Feb 2004, Oron Peled wrote:

 On Sunday 01 February 2004 11:18, Adir Abraham wrote:
  [a lot of valid points]
  ... You can conclude what happens with faster
  machines or those that include rich hardware features. I also assume that
  we'll have faster machines next year, so it will not take more than 40
  minutes in average.

 Just adjusting some over-optimism: installation is very I/O bounded, and
 disk speed is advancing very slow (comparing to Moore's law for CPU).

 So unless next year you'll have everybody with SCSI disks, you won't
 see a lot of speedup.

 Still, I completely agree that the ~5GB full install is a wise decision in
 the context of install parties to newbies who would have hard time
 adding software. Worse, the typical newbie would assume that
 if some 'Z' software isn't on her system -- than Linux doesn't have 'Z'
 at all (actually, if an icon for 'Z' isn't on the menu than Linux doesn't
 have 'Z' software :-)


That's quite unlikely. If people see that 'Z' is not available on Windows,
they don't assume that Windows does not have 'Z' at all. They go to the
Internet and find it. We can assume this will be the case for Linux as
well.

The best thing we can do is explain them how they can install more
software, update their system, etc. Otherwise:

1. They eventually will find something that isn't on Linux, and won't know
what to do.

2. They will cause their system to become vulnerable eventually. (unless
we assume that absolutely no security bugs will be discovered from the
time we install it until infinity).

Regards,

Shlomi Fish


--
Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

Hey? I'm just kidding!

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Ez-Aton wrote:

 Some people do, some people talk. Don't forget.
 Would *you* test mass deployment of Mandrake, as you say with such a clear
 voice RH sux, and Mandrake rulez.

Sure, but I'll need some computers to test it on, as my father would kill
me if I test it with our own computers.

 Grow up. Mandrake is better in some things, and RH is better on others.

Wrong! Mandrake is superior to RedHat in any way, but let's not get into
it. (except for bugs that occur in both randomly).

Regards,

Shlomi Fish


--
Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

Hey? I'm just kidding!

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Adir Abraham
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:

 That's quite unlikely. If people see that 'Z' is not available on Windows,
 they don't assume that Windows does not have 'Z' at all. They go to the
 Internet and find it. We can assume this will be the case for Linux as
 well.

You're way too naive :) If People see that if 'Z' is not available on
Windows, they say that they simply don't have it, and they search the
Internet to find its Windows version (using some P2P programs ;). They
never claimed that it doesn't exist on Microsoft programs, and you won't
find them saying that.

 The best thing we can do is explain them how they can install more
 software, update their system, etc. Otherwise:

Finally I agree with you. I'll say even more - we can show them a whole
process of installation in different ways (RPM, compilation, sh, GUI and
other friends). I'm sure that we covered some of the chapters, but not in
one installation lecture (software installation).

 1. They eventually will find something that isn't on Linux, and won't know
 what to do.

The simple user will find anything he needs (otherwise he wouldn't be so
simple). Especially in the Internet.

 2. They will cause their system to become vulnerable eventually. (unless
 we assume that absolutely no security bugs will be discovered from the
 time we install it until infinity).

They don't care about it, and they don't know how dangerous it really is.
Really.
Security methods should be taught, and that's a whole different issue.


 Regards,

   Shlomi Fish


 --
 Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

 You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

 Hey? I'm just kidding!


-- 

Adir Abraham
Technion's Advisors Group and Public PC Farms Manager
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Haifa, Israel
ICQ# 1841481
Cel# +972-53-243438, +972-55-481245
KeyID: 0xD8DC85C7  Fingerprint: 138D 8F41 7A06 44A0  3DBB 9DC3 FE8B 2658



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use http://www.pgp.com

mQEPAzLax/sAAAEIAK2bI8utornDYd5LdU+/TABNmqXneiXuLx4j8OKD2GjfS/O8
E6nrX69ot4uU5ryjp5h+7VHBZqCQz+8VC8ly2ANtycejAc82gllVC96fbA+Y6uuN
uI9aXkwNqhphmmQZIVaOZDRAo9//1zX9r41xY+8rKSQuNcp+FPD/A5Itng0xhsfS
KkCV4tT0mGpiydUHFrugk/bouXPYwUHXSnHp/mPdGsjgqipezHPzCWIn3xcJjk2/
tjd5/ym+arWpKW5nvTuvalcMi2DIcEilSrT5NLwgeuh3eqitYOc9WTiMNMvUiVcP
sucJkdxNwjEX9MgD/bLY9wT/13brqxk71tjchccAEQEAAbQnQWRpciBBYnJhaGFt
IDxhZGlyQHZpcGUudGVjaG5pb24uYWMuaWw+iQEVAwUQMtrH+6sZO9bY3IXHAQGb
0gf9FwrJBKaTP0yvf3+vwtB+9ftS0woz1TawJwflC5EoHJs7D/5GzkAaRV82RSkH
P9fSHmM+LUB0huBBK1qtNyXHWIjQTmYwFYC8Oen4q0Fyze7cloSnpD1rVjI0HoCO
UU8bbz0Iseizdjhnl2PTItQ+dkKzLcww1jW5iPXOWd1o8/8s2aebhrpDRO8BfAYg
H29jhmDtuVQDPgFfkN/kP+xpHQplMN5Qh1oP22f+Wyg8sVvSv8P7cM+88u46FHi3
zvHpVnZKIBtKhksnH1PYXtz7FvS7vA+MbpM47kgmQGL5Ygig0pUUbBCGlzmg2Hvd
262YCdVYNwpIjQWBLJI8orea0Q==
=dgNP
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Ez-Aton
  Some people do, some people talk. Don't forget.
  Would *you* test mass deployment of Mandrake, as you say with such a
  clear voice RH sux, and Mandrake rulez.

 Sure, but I'll need some computers to test it on, as my father would kill
 me if I test it with our own computers.

That's your problem, not mine.
You like mandrake, you test and setup Mass Deployment.

Ez.


--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Eli Billauer
Hi clubbers,

Tell me guys, when is the next insta party? Soon? Couldn't find anything 
about that in the site.

Because otherwise you are all wasting your breaths and time on this 
discussion. Experience shows that the real decisions about W2L and 
parties are made soon before the events themselves, and they usually 
reflect the people involved more than any conclusions made before.

I suppose that you're all being nice, and giving someone his daily need 
of attention. Because that's exactly what you do.

  Eli

--
Web: http://www.billauer.co.il


--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: [Haifux] SiL installing software (was: Re: [Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust)

2004-02-02 Thread Alon Altman
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, guy keren wrote:

 On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Adir Abraham wrote:

  On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:
 
   The best thing we can do is explain them how they can install more
   software, update their system, etc. Otherwise:
 
  Finally I agree with you. I'll say even more - we can show them a whole
  process of installation in different ways (RPM, compilation, sh, GUI and
  other friends). I'm sure that we covered some of the chapters, but not in
  one installation lecture (software installation).

 ienvisiona.freeSiLSlot.filledup...with
 Installing new software - from A to Z

 anyone wants to take on this?

  I think the Basic Admin lecture of W2L covers software installation
reasonably, and there's no reason for another lecture on the topic,
especially not in SiL.

  Alon

-- 
This message was sent by Alon Altman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) ICQ:1366540
GPG public key at http://alon.wox.org/pubkey.txt
Key fingerprint = A670 6C81 19D3 3773 3627  DE14 B44A 50A3 FE06 7F24
--
 -=[ Random Fortune ]=-
Old age is the harbor of all ills.
-- Bion

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Shlomi Fish
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Ez-Aton wrote:

   Some people do, some people talk. Don't forget.
   Would *you* test mass deployment of Mandrake, as you say with such a
   clear voice RH sux, and Mandrake rulez.
 
  Sure, but I'll need some computers to test it on, as my father would kill
  me if I test it with our own computers.

 That's your problem, not mine.
 You like mandrake, you test and setup Mass Deployment.


Sorry, but it's _our_ problem. If we can't install Mandrake we are stuck
with the sub-standard Fedora. We're all in the same boat here.

Can anyone give me a couple of computers where I can test-drive KickStart
for Mandrake?

Regards,

Shlomi Fish

 Ez.


 --
 Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
 To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]





--
Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

Hey? I'm just kidding!

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Adir Abraham
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Shlomi Fish wrote:

 It's free as in speech not free as in beer. Either we burn enough CDs to

The installation is free. The CDs might be free based on sponsorship.

 give to anyone on our own expense, or tell them that either they buy CDs,

We can't tell them. We may suggest them. They have minds. They can
decide. Let the person who gets the service from us, to choose what he
wants to buy (you can tell him the advantages/disadvantages of buying the
CDs, but it shouldn't look like you force him. You'll miss the whole point
of the party if you do so).

 download stuf over an Internet, or simply be content with what they'll get

Once again, you assume that they will want to do it, and you assume that
they have fast connection to the Internet.

 So you're saying: fine! Let's install a system that can be eventually
 exploited for crackers to gain access on the machine and do all kinds of

I'm the last person who says that. I say that we should give them a
flexible machine, with simple security tweaks. Afterwards, we shall let
them choose what they wish to do with it, at home (every case is
personal, after all). You can't close their computer to the rest of the world,
and let them think that Linux doesn't work in the Internet. However, you may
tell them that their computer is vulnerable and they should do more (reading,
checking, maybe even use some auto-configuration scripts...) in order to
protect their systems. I'll try to give some of these concepts in my SiL
lecture, btw.

You also can't really defend them against crackers (unless you want to
visit them on a daily basis and update their system every day). They
should do so themselves, if they want (with Gentoo I would simply tell
them to emerge world, but let's leave that aside ;).

 nasty stuff there. Fine, let's not educate people that they need to be

We're not educators. We're spreading the word, or we do the best to spread
the word. If you think otherwise (i.e. I opened a hole for flames) - I'm
not going to argue about it.

 responsible and clueful when using a computer. Sorry, but it doesn't work
 in the long run. It will be bad for them and will be bad for us.

In the long run they will need to read stuff and keep learning, or they
can stick to their current configuration (some people still use kernel
2.0.x, and/or Redhat 7.3, for instance) - their choise.



 --
 Shlomi Fish[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Home Page: http://t2.technion.ac.il/~shlomif/

 You are banished! You are banished! You are banished!

 Hey? I'm just kidding!


-- 

Adir Abraham
Technion's Advisors Group and Public PC Farms Manager
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Haifa, Israel
ICQ# 1841481
Cel# +972-53-243438, +972-55-481245
KeyID: 0xD8DC85C7  Fingerprint: 138D 8F41 7A06 44A0  3DBB 9DC3 FE8B 2658



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use http://www.pgp.com
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=dgNP
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] SiL installing software (was: Re: [Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust)

2004-02-02 Thread guy keren
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Alon Altman wrote:

 On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, guy keren wrote:

  ienvisiona.freeSiLSlot.filledup...with
  Installing new software - from A to Z
 
  anyone wants to take on this?

 I think the Basic Admin lecture of W2L covers software installation
 reasonably, and there's no reason for another lecture on the topic,
 especially not in SiL.

the pace, the pace it's too fast during W2L, and too few
demonstrations.

what i envision, is taking several types of applications and showing how
they are installed. i would take:

1. an RPM application with dependencies...
2. an SRPM too?
3. one of the 'configure/make/make install' applications.
4. sun's or IBM's jdk. this includes setting PATH, LD_LIBRARY_PATH...
5. perhaps something coming from a project's CVS? there is no need to know
   much about CVS itself in order to do that, and people do get the
   occasional oh, this bug making the application crash for you, was
   solved in CVS head, try it.

in each case i will show how i find it on the web, download (preparing a
previously downloaded copy a-la the hachinoti imi merosh method),
install, and configure.

i will include showing how i create an icon for the application on the
desktop, if there is none, or a handy shell alias to run it, if it has a
complicated command-line.

i still remember what it was like, to install software, when i had very
little experience. it's in-ti-mi-da-ting, and when something fucks up, it
was hard to know what to do.

after seeing a few examples, people will probably feel better regarding
the whole issue, and be more willing to experiment on their own.

-- 
guy

For world domination - press 1,
 or dial 0, and please hold, for the creator. -- nob o. dy

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] SiL installing software (was: Re: [Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust)

2004-02-02 Thread Adir Abraham
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, guy keren wrote:

 ienvisiona.freeSiLSlot.filledup...with
 Installing new software - from A to Z

 anyone wants to take on this?

Ehh.. Go for it, please :) It is more than worth to be a seperate lecture,
and not something that is mixed between other lectures. It's something
that a newbie might look for and find, simply by checking the relevant
lecture.




-- 

Adir Abraham
Technion's Advisors Group and Public PC Farms Manager
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Haifa, Israel
ICQ# 1841481
Cel# +972-53-243438, +972-55-481245
KeyID: 0xD8DC85C7  Fingerprint: 138D 8F41 7A06 44A0  3DBB 9DC3 FE8B 2658



-BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-
Version: PGPfreeware 7.0.3 for non-commercial use http://www.pgp.com
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=dgNP
-END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




Re: [Haifux] Re: Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Alon Altman
On Mon, 2 Feb 2004, Adir Abraham wrote:
  So you're saying: fine! Let's install a system that can be eventually
  exploited for crackers to gain access on the machine and do all kinds of

 I'm the last person who says that. I say that we should give them a
 flexible machine, with simple security tweaks. Afterwards, we shall let
 them choose what they wish to do with it, at home (every case is
 personal, after all). You can't close their computer to the rest of the world,
 and let them think that Linux doesn't work in the Internet. However, you may
 tell them that their computer is vulnerable and they should do more (reading,
 checking, maybe even use some auto-configuration scripts...) in order to
 protect their systems. I'll try to give some of these concepts in my SiL
 lecture, btw.

 You also can't really defend them against crackers (unless you want to
 visit them on a daily basis and update their system every day). They
 should do so themselves, if they want (with Gentoo I would simply tell
 them to emerge world, but let's leave that aside ;).


  If we install the system sensibly, and close all incoming ports (maybe
except ssh) we solve most of the vulnerability problems, even if people
don't upgrade thier systems.

  Alon

-- 
This message was sent by Alon Altman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) ICQ:1366540
GPG public key at http://alon.wox.org/pubkey.txt
Key fingerprint = A670 6C81 19D3 3773 3627  DE14 B44A 50A3 FE06 7F24
--
 -=[ Random Fortune ]=-
CONGRATULATIONS!  Now should I make thinly veiled comments about
DIGNITY, self-esteem and finding TRUE FUN in your RIGHT VENTRICLE??

--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] Re: InstaParty Thought - Buy/Receive the CD or Bust

2004-02-02 Thread Ez-Aton
Some people do, some people talk. Don't forget.
Would *you* test mass deployment of Mandrake, as you say with such a
clear voice RH sux, and Mandrake rulez.
  
   Sure, but I'll need some computers to test it on, as my father would
   kill me if I test it with our own computers.
 
  That's your problem, not mine.
  You like mandrake, you test and setup Mass Deployment.

 Sorry, but it's _our_ problem. If we can't install Mandrake we are stuck
 with the sub-standard Fedora. We're all in the same boat here.

No. The moment you decided on a distro for everyone else is the moment this 
party became yours, and only yours, hence, you are to do the tests. 


 Can anyone give me a couple of computers where I can test-drive KickStart
 for Mandrake?

I have about 27 of them. No. I cannot give them, and no, I will not add 
network switches, not routers, nor anything else _you_ are to check. It is 
your party, your tests, and your mass deployment. I can hardly assume that 
two computers can make it up for a mass deployment tests. One as server and 
one as a client. Wow, it's working, and working fast. Now we can scale it up 
to a 40 computer setup.

 Regards,

   Shlomi Fish

Ez.

P.S - I use fedora, and I'm rather content with it. Works like a charm. 


--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]




[Haifux] RHN on Fedora stations

2004-02-02 Thread Dita Jacobovitz



Hi,

After re-installing our 12 linux stations in the 
students farm to Fedora Core 1,
We need an automatic solution for the RHN up2date service for these 12 stations,
Please advise, The demo version is for one station 
only.

Thanks in advance Dita.



Re: [Haifux] RHN on Fedora stations

2004-02-02 Thread Oron Peled
On Monday 02 February 2004 14:25, Dita Jacobovitz wrote:
 We need an automatic solution for the RHN up2date service for these 12
 stations,

One solution for up2date is 'current' (don't have the URL under my hand now)
from Duke university (IIRC). Haven't tested lately, so YMMV.

-- 
Oron Peled Voice/Fax: +972-4-8228492
[EMAIL PROTECTED]  http://www.actcom.co.il/~oron

Promises are like babies: fun to make, but hell to deliver.
   -- Nadav Har'El


--
Haifa Linux Club Mailing List (http://www.haifux.org)
To unsub send an empty message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]