Re: static IP (was Re: Which domain name to put where?)

[Steve Kennedy]

On Wed, Feb 10, 1999 at 06:39:47PM +, Andy Smith wrote:

> On Wed, 10 Feb 1999, Chris Green wrote:
> > Demon Internet is exceptional in that it offers all its dial-up users
> > a static IP address.  I think it's basically because it was one of the
> > earliest ISPs and thus has the addresses available because it grabbed
> > them early before they were hard to come by.
> I don't know all the facts behind it but I believe there that the IP
> registry in question (RIPE) will not prevent any ISP from giving static IP
> to all it's customers, provided the ISP keeps all the relevant records.

Demon offers a 'host' based service, delivers mail to customers by
SMTP. Thus a customer logs-in, say with host, and their domain name
is host.demon.co.uk. Demon dont care about the user part and can in
fact have as many or as few 'users' on their host.

At the time static IP was the way to go.

RIPE DID try and stop Demon allocating static IP addresses, however
after certain high level shouting matches and threats to go to the
European court (RIPE aren't allowed to dictate how Demon run their
business, if they run an SMTP/host based service - that's what they
run, RIPE can't dictate for them to use dynamic IP). Anyway, Demon
have to account for every IP addressed used, and associate it (in
customer blocks) with a name and address. Which is fair enough.

Steve
-- 
NetTek Ltdtel +44-171 483 1169 fax +44-181 444 6103
Flat 2,  43 Howitt Road,  Belsize Park,  London NW3 4LU
   Epage [EMAIL PROTECTED] [body of text only]

Re: static IP (was Re: Which domain name to put where?)

[Lars Marowsky-Brée]

On 1999-02-10T18:39:47,
   Andy Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> said:

> I don't know all the facts behind it but I believe there that the IP
> registry in question (RIPE) will not prevent any ISP from giving static IP
> to all it's customers, provided the ISP keeps all the relevant records.

Thats incorrect. If you don't know all the facts behind it, don't talk.

RIPE NCC discourages assigning static IPs to dialup customers, unless they are
needed (like for MX entries in the DNS etc).

Sincerely,
Lars Marowsky-Brée

--
Lars Marowsky-Brée
Network Management

teuto.net Netzdienste GmbH - DPN Verbund-Partner

static IP (was Re: Which domain name to put where?)

[Andy Smith]

On Wed, 10 Feb 1999, Chris Green wrote:

> Demon Internet is exceptional in that it offers all its dial-up users
> a static IP address.  I think it's basically because it was one of the
> earliest ISPs and thus has the addresses available because it grabbed
> them early before they were hard to come by.

I don't know all the facts behind it but I believe there that the IP
registry in question (RIPE) will not prevent any ISP from giving static IP
to all it's customers, provided the ISP keeps all the relevant records.

Others may not provide them at all or may charge more because of this
'administrative overhead', but it isn't really a matter of IP addresses
being hard to come by.

-- 
Andy J. Smith ... <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> ... 
Mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] for PGP Key, or check the key servers ..
KeyID: 0xBF15490B FP: 0E42 36CB 5295 1E14 5360  6622 2099 B64C BF15 490B

3) I don't sign parts of the body, even if they're still attached.
  -- Terry Pratchett, news://alt.fan.pratchett