Re: DIS: Re: OFF: Judicial Assignments

2007-01-31 Thread Manuel Lanctot
On 1/31/07, Ed Murphy wrote: What about Manu? (The web database incorrectly listed em as being on hold. Fixed now.) Sshhh! Don't tell anyone! ~Manu

DIS: Re: OFF: [CotC, on behalf of] CFJ 1606 assigned to Quazie

2007-01-31 Thread Quazie
On 1/31/07, Ed Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Detail: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=1606 == CFJ 1606 == Goethe was deregistered in a Writ of FAGE in December 2006.

Re: DIS: A bit of heresy...

2007-01-31 Thread Zefram
Michael Slone wrote: Kelly's drafting is about the best I've ever seen (but I only started watching in 1998), but it tends to be hard to amend parts of her legislation without introducing subtle errors. My recollection is that it tends to have plenty of subtle errors to start with. And I

DIS: OFF: Judgement of CFJ 1597

2007-01-31 Thread Kerim Aydin
Michael wrote: If you like, I think my argument is in the best interests of the game: do you really want an unresolvable CFJ paralysing the system for evermore? (You might call the same CFJ again I suppose.) I called CFJ 1606 specifically to fix it. I explained that at the time. It creates

DIS: Re: BUS: Appeal of CFJ 1594

2007-01-31 Thread Ed Murphy
Eris wrote: On 1/31/07, Zefram [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I hereby appeal Sherlock's judgement of CFJ 1594. I also appeal this Judgement, because I've always wanted to try this. This is explicitly allowed by Rule 101, but contributes nothing toward Rule 1564's prerequisites for initiating an

Re: DIS: OFF: Judgement of CFJ 1597

2007-01-31 Thread Ed Murphy
Michael Norrish wrote: Kerim Aydin wrote: Let's say, in this case, the decision is OVERTURN AND REVERSE. Did that OVERTURN AND REVERSE apply to Goethe's FALSE or Sherlock's TRUE? There's no legal distinction the appeals court can make to distinguish them. I don't imagine the Appeals

Re: DIS: Proto: Revise Rotation

2007-01-31 Thread Ed Murphy
Zefram wrote: Ed Murphy wrote: What's this supposed to mean? Sounds like a barbecuing procedure. cause a player to become turned, then. It's the whole thing that I have a problem with, not the verb turn. I really can't make head or tail of it. What's it for? Shortly after you last

Re: DIS: Proto: Revise Rotation

2007-01-31 Thread Quazie
On 1/31/07, Ed Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:The intent was to jump ahead and make more Turns-for-All assignments to the greatest extent possible. As things currently stand, and even under your suggested middle ground, the CotC could have done this: CFJ 1607 is assigned to Quazie. This is a

DIS: Definitions

2007-01-31 Thread Scott Rollins
OK, I've drafted an unpublished protoDecision on the CFJ I was assigned. But before I submit it, I was just wondering if anybody had some rules or past judicial precedent to advise me of related to: * definition of terms, and * handling of terms which were formally defined under the rules.