[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-05 Thread Jahanzeb
Jaadu Hai Nasha Hai (Jism) is surely something which is able to compete many ARR compositions. One of my heart favorites. From recent albums Paayaliya (Dev D) and Aisi Sazaa (Gulaal) are my favorites too. In fact Paayaliya is the first song that comes to mind thinking of a non-ARR female solo so

[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread AJ
For me, Khili Re is the most beautiful melody I've heard in an Indian film album in a very, very long timethe melodic contours in this song are just so classic and fluidevery note is blissfully carved out and not one line of the melody is jarring or out of place. The transitions are so

Re: [arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread anvesh
for me Aisi Sazaa (Gulaal) tops the list and tops kili re too, comfortably. Iktaara is not a solo right ?. Amazing song though. On Mon, May 3, 2010 at 11:42 PM, rtyags2k wrote: > > > > Hmmm... not that I don't like Khili Re, but since you ask, some of the > non-ARR female solos (and almost solo

[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread V S Rawat
The subject I chose for this thread seem to indicate by negation that "those who like Khili rey haven't high standards". Oh My God, that was never my intention. I was saying positive things about Khili Rey, so I couldn't have undermined beloved members among us who like this song. My apologies

Re: [arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread V S Rawat
On 5/3/2010 11:42 PM India Time, _rtyags2k_ wrote: > > Hmmm... not that I don't like Khili Re, but since you ask, some of the > non-ARR female solos (and almost solos) that I like as much as Khili Re (and > some much more than Khili Re right now.. thought that can obviously change > later).. >

[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread rtyags2k
Hmmm... not that I don't like Khili Re, but since you ask, some of the non-ARR female solos (and almost solos) that I like as much as Khili Re (and some much more than Khili Re right now.. thought that can obviously change later).. 1) Jaadu Hai Nasha Hai (Jism) 2) Paayaliya (Dev.D) 3) Sawar Gay

[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread adrcc2
Actually Rawat, Khili Rey is my favourite 1. it's the only semi-classical song of the album. 2. i thoroughly enjoy those tabla-chorus entries 3. Reena Bhardwaj is back to Bollywood after a long time. I'm disappointed by the rest of the album. I essentially listen to Hindi albums only but lately

Re: [arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread Roshan
It's my favorite too. the melody from 2.00 to 2.47 is magical! On Mon, May 3, 2010 at 4:40 PM, AJ wrote: > > > I feel Khilie Re is too short.the reason why I think it's too short IS > because it's one of my favorites! I want to hear more of it! > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com , V S

[arr] Re: "NOT" liking Khili Rey proves that ARR has raised our standards

2010-05-03 Thread AJ
I feel Khilie Re is too short.the reason why I think it's too short IS because it's one of my favorites! I want to hear more of it! --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, V S Rawat wrote: > > Actually, it is not really "NOT" liking, it is more like not rating it > as the best song of the alb