[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-27 Thread pradeepananth
Though ARR has not made any explicit claims on his ethical standards he certainly has called on the general public to refrain from downloading Pirated mp3s. Therefore not taking a strong stance on issues like Ghajini/Memento could end up Portraying him as subscribing to double standards and his a

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-27 Thread vivek
the browsing center will defnitely be blamed if 1.he is aware of such wrong usage of his resources or, 2.he is not following his due diligence of recording the user's identity ARR will be blamed if he gives his studio on rent despite knowing the fact some of them use his resources wrongfully.

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread Kalimuthu
Your pak comparison does not make sense at all, IMO... How can the owner of the browsing center be blamed for the mail sent by his customer... Or the ISP for its customers' illegal access to copyrighted materials They are just providing tools... On 12/26/08, vivek wrote: > > Yes, ARR shoul

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread rayrai2k
Give me a chance of writing about ethics. Once a person went to a shop to purchased for Rs.50 and then paid him Rs 100. The shopkeeper returned 70 by mistake as a remainder. The person left the shop. It was late by when the shopkeeper realized his mistake. After a couple of days the same perso

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread pradeepananth
To clarify, I am not ethics police here and not accusing ARR of anything. Just trying to get a sense for what his (and everyone's) perspective on this is. I think Vivek put it really beautifully in terms of distinguishing between laws and morals. This is really about what moral standards does ARR

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread Pradeepan R
This is completely ridiculous.If I tell you that the Rice that you eat, is coming from a piece of land, owned by a farmer who beats up his Wife would you stop eating ?? Would you be willing to make an effort to find out ??!!! we all know for a fact that we pollute the earth by driving...isn't t

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread rayrai2k
Wah what a comparison? AM studio to Terrorism. One believes completely is peace loving and filled with love towards humanity, tries to unite humans. The other exactly believes in the opposite. Your thought itself speaks out you didn't do it right. Also ethics of killing is different than the ar

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread Gomzy™
You are listening to songs of a guy who promotes people who break copyright laws. You are not only encouraging him but also an accomplice. Partner in crime! Now how about your ethics? On Sat, Dec 27, 2008 at 4:25 AM, vivek wrote: > > Yes, ARR should not have involved with the project if he was a

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread vivek
Yes, ARR should not have involved with the project if he was aware that prior permission was not taken for remaking the movie. Yes, ARR should not rent out his studio to MDs who are blatantly and intentionally guilty of infringing on copyrights of other artists - international or domestic. we

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread Gomzy™
Now lets use your logic for something better. ARR's studio is given out on rent basis to various MDs. I wouldnt wanna name the MDs who use the studio. Now are we going to sue or question ARRs ethics if these MDs copy or rip off some guys music? (they are btw) Please stop catching anything related

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread ramakrisha laxmana subramanian siva gopala acharya iyer .aiyooo amma idli wada dosa sambar chatni .
What has AR got to do with it? His work is completely original, the basic story of GHAJINI is SURE to have been inspired from the H'wood flick, but the 'masala' is completely by the writer/director. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, "pradeepananth" wrote: > > So Ghajini is out and lo

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread || V i s h w e s h ||
bject: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, 26 December, 2008, 12:28 PM Are you questioning AR's ethics? I dont think he ripped the music anywhere from Memento. You should be asking the question to its producers and the s

Re: [arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-26 Thread Vithur
Isnt it the responsibility of the Producers of the Movie. ?. why should AR bother about all these ? May be he left all these issues to the Producers of the movie... I think its a grave sin to question AR's ethics. and Pls dont use the words " Rip Off" for AR. It really hurts. On Fri, Dec 26, 2

[arr] Re: Question on Ethics to ARR...

2008-12-25 Thread rayrai2k
Are you questioning AR's ethics? I dont think he ripped the music anywhere from Memento. You should be asking the question to its producers and the story writers. Why AR? To avoid downloading and using pirated music, movie or software is individual ethics. You might be using softwares are you